Skip to main content

A couple of years ago a friend gave me a book about the late John Allen and the Gorre and Daphetid Railroad, which I highly recommend by the way. But it has started me thinking, could there be a market for a high quality coffee table book of some of the legends of the toy train hobby that either they or their layouts have past on. This would go beyond the normal OGR article or TM Books and Video segment, but the biographical story of the person(s) behind the layout. How and why they choose this hobby. Who influenced them. What their legacy to the hobby is. Also a consistent technical breakdown of the layout itself. Such things as type of track, type of switches, table construction method, wiring method, scenery construction methods, etc.... A book with high gloss pages, the highest quality pictures available, excellent writing and oversized to command a presence on the coffee table. It could feature 5 or 6 people per issue and there could be a series. Books such as these exist for motorsports at least, as I have several of them. Granted that is a much bigger market, but I personally would be interested in a series such as this in order to remember those that helped build the hobby.

Some of the possible candidates would include:

Charles Griffin and The Misty Mountain Railroad

Frank Petruzzo and his coal train

Ward Kimble

Frank Ellison and The Delta Lines

I am thinking of several others but because I am not sure of the persons status will decline from listing them here. I am sure the folks here could contribute many people and layouts to the list. But again, I personally think it should be limited to those that are gone in order to remember them and the legacy to the hobby.

Thoughts?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Well, I dunno....I think I've changed my mind on this.

 

I have a nice java table book on toy trains....Great American Toy Train Layouts, by McComas and Touhy, 1987.  It's a nice hardcover book, lots of nice layouts...different size/make trains, some of the owner/builders of 25 years ago now gone...or less published/well-known?  Last featured layout of that book is (drum roll, please!) Frank Sinatra's, completely housed in its own railroad station-esque structure on Frank's estate.  Ward Kimball was also featured.

 

There are lots of this book on the auctions, used book stores, flea markets, amazon, etc......all sorts of prices, some signed, etc..

 

But the reason I say I've changed my mind is that the same authors have since published/produced VHS and DVD's under the same title in several succeeding volumes, more contemporary layouts of their released year, etc..  And I now find it just as easy to pop one of their DVD's into a player and look at the layouts in BIG hi-def. screen from my easy chair.  So, I think this is the 'coffee table book' du jour...the DVD.

 

Also, printing/binding costs are, like everything else, skyrocketing.  My book had an original retail of just under $30.  I would imagine the same book/format today would easily run $60+.   That amount of money will buy several DVD's.  And, the BIG screen views will be less challenging to my failing septuagenarian eyesight.

 

I'd probably pass on a contemporary hardcover book opportunity re the same.

 

Besides, I'm afraid as 'PC' as the world has become, the limited selection of layouts published in a book of this sort would simply be forum-fodder.  (I find myself humming 'My dog's better than your dog!' more often as I read through threads and blogs of all sorts these days!)

 

KD

Last edited by dkdkrd
Fine, put them in there own book. I am referring to a book about "common Joes" who left a lasting impression on the hobby due to the layout they created.
 
Originally Posted by Greg Houser:
There are many "legends" of the hobby who better qualify as such for reasons other than their layouts.  For example,  Robert Wagner, Frank Pettit, AC Gilbert just to name a few.

--Greg

 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×