Skip to main content

Here's another comparison for everyone's reference. Lionel's 28084 Dreyfuss Hudson actually goes very well with K-Line's 18" 1938 20th Century Limited cars. The grays are different shades, but the stripes are a very good match. Unfortunately K-Line was not around long enough to produce these in 21" length, but the 18" cars are still very nice. The car in the photo is the add-on coach I recently won off eBay, I do not actually own the core K-4670J 5-PAC set yet.

 

IMG_2954

IMG_2955

IMG_2958

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_2954
  • IMG_2955
  • IMG_2958
Last edited by PC9850
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

We have the K-Line 15" 20th Century Ltd cars, same paint as the 18".  We have 3 Dreyfuss Hudsons, but only the MTH 20-3045 is a close gray match to the K-Line cars.  The Lionel is, of course, a good match to their own 20th Century set.  The 3rd Rail engine (1940 scheme, white stripe) is somewhere betwixt/between for grayness.  But who cares?

 

One of the 'yawniest' discussions we have at the store (LHS) is re paint colors...fidelity, match, accuracy, etc.  Sunny, cloudy, shady, fresh, faded, shop A, shop B, greenish black, blackish green, ....blah, blah, blah.  It's always fun to mix passionate opinion with aging knowledge with all-too-common ignorance.  What a bloviated brew.  Good show, though....It competes well with some of the loud discussions in the adjacent department....Games....the role-playing type.   (Good grief, what ARE they talking about???)

 

Ah, well, it beats talking about the weather or politics, anyway.

 

 

 

At long last, plucked a set off eBay as soon as it was listed. This was by far the hardest to find K-Line set I've ever been after. Very reasonable "Buy it Now" price from closeouttrains in NJ. I'm thrilled, can't wait to complete the train when I get home (they were delivered to me in NY while I'm here on business).

 

20140525_181618

20140525_181720

20140525_184533

Attachments

Images (3)
  • 20140525_181618
  • 20140525_181720
  • 20140525_184533
Last edited by PC9850
Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×