Skip to main content

Looking for a suggestion on cross match rattle can for Lionel Orange paint.

who makes the best off the shelf match for Lionel Orange. I am looking to paint a 260E Lionel Orange and Blue. I have matched the blue but haven’t found a ready made match for the orange.

any all suggestions are highly appreciated

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I'm not a paint expert by any measure, but I've learned that trying to match a color using off-the-shelf products is challenging at best.

On a recent project (see below) I used "Rust-Oleum 334043 Painter's Touch 2X Ultra Cover Spray Paint, Gloss Real Orange" - readily available at Menards, Lowe's, Home Depot, etc.  It's very orange, but I don't have a "Lionel orange" piece to compare it against.  Any color looks different in person vs. a photo, and comparisons to an existing piece are affected by the age of the finish.

A can costs under $8, so it's possible to experiment on a test piece.  If an exact match is a requirement, I'd suggest contacting a vendor of toy train paint such as Henning's.  However, I don't think they sell rattle cans, so using their paint is likely to require using an airbrush.

South Shore trolley side view

Attachments

Images (1)
  • South Shore trolley side view
Last edited by Mallard4468

Yes can you post the info here. 30 is a good price. I hate the cleaning involved with my sprayer and really don’t see myself investing in new equipment. I live in VA also so shipping should be minimal.

I have flirted with the idea of powder coating. Does anyone have any good advice on starter equipment and paint matching.

thanks

Lowe's or Home Depot can provide a paint match by computerized color meter, and supply a sample jar of the color for a few dollars (used to be free !).  It will be latex paint and you may have to work around the sheen with a clear over spray.

Charlie

My experience with computerized color matching is that it has problems if the item being matched isn't flat and smooth - ridges, rivets, etc. on a car will throw it off.  Also, the paint will either need to be brushed on or thinned for an airbrush. 

@Norton posted:

Lionel Orange is not an exact color. I would simply take a modern box that hasn’t faded to a hardware or home store and put it against the paint chips they have next to the spray paint. No need for computers here.

Pete

This is how I've gotten my closest matches.  I've found that using the paint chips is also good because you know exactly what you're getting - using a custom mix can be dicey. 

A few years ago I painted the fascia trim of my layout "Lionel Orange." At Home Depot, I discovered a series of paint colors based on NFL team colors.  The orange of the NFL Denver Broncos was a VERY CLOSE match in enamel. However, HD may not have it any more.  Even if they do still have it, it may not be suitable for use in a rattle can or an airbrush for your project..

A photo is attached of my paint job ...

Just saying,

Mike Mottler       LCCA 12394

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Dino Pk Overview
  • Dino Pk Juveniles
  • Dino Park 1

Ok so I went to Home Depot and Tractor Supply and came come with the following CC8C8C56-F459-434E-8D59-312B49548258

1. Rust-Oleum Kubota Orange

2. Rust-Oleum Allis Chambers Orange

3. Rust-Oleum Orange GPE

4. Magic AC Orange

I am trying to match as close as possible to the two new cars I purchased from Side Track Hobbies for $35 each. (Beyond Excellent Price).ED8806BA-6C87-408E-A578-766183AEDC02

My goal is to match my 260E and 263w to the colors of those cars.
Rust-Oleum Navy Blue is a perfect Match D5907FFC-CA49-4C3C-B72F-BBF549C846E9

so I chose paint 1&4 and this is my test 2BFABEEB-913C-4312-A965-5243DE0A32AC

close up of the Blue

C4E13011-4C0B-4A0C-B531-4CFC09AC135F

Attachments

Images (6)
  • CC8C8C56-F459-434E-8D59-312B49548258
  • D5907FFC-CA49-4C3C-B72F-BBF549C846E9
  • ED8806BA-6C87-408E-A578-766183AEDC02
  • E01FD631-C26A-4010-BAC5-7F188B618A48
  • C4E13011-4C0B-4A0C-B531-4CFC09AC135F
  • 2BFABEEB-913C-4312-A965-5243DE0A32AC

Sorry this has taken so long I just now was able to get to the club to look at the paint. I had James T. Davis Paints (Roanoke and Lynchburg ,VA ) color match the Lionel Orange, Blue and Ivory colors from my rolling stock. This paint is actually PPG auto paint and will be an exact match. I bought 4 ounce cans so I could do multiple projects and touch-up's.

Here is the Lionel Orange formula:

20240727_122954

Lionel Blue;20240727_122805

Here is the Lionel Ivory used with the Lionel Club series cars

20240727_123228

If you buy their custom mixed spray paint cans expect to pay about $30.00 per can. If you are buying 4 ounce cans like I did you will have to mix hardner and a drying agent which isn't difficult at all.

20240727_12341720240727_123354 Expect to pay a little more than $120.00 for all 3 cans and the harder and drying agents. Please take the time to use a tack cloth to remove dust before painting you will get much better results.

Scott Smith

Attachments

Images (5)
  • 20240727_122954
  • 20240727_122805
  • 20240727_123228
  • 20240727_123417
  • 20240727_123354

Early Mock-up of my train, I like the color it is close match with age it might darken a little so I’m happy with with. 81427813-69A2-489A-BB06-443384CEF5BF
train with tender have a lot to do need to sand and polish the tender and final coat than add all the nickel and trucks. 47EFC31E-8CCF-4F3A-9F67-711D5C83194825E69B9A-F5E5-4313-873E-494B9689D551The leading and rear wheel frames came out great along with all the other parts.

The train as I assemble all the cars.  I am going to repaint the roof of the cattle car to blue EFB4F3C5-51FD-4D53-B16E-E4BBB4D3ECC6

B8ABAF78-D6DA-4E70-98BF-35EC247ED252

Attachments

Images (5)
  • 81427813-69A2-489A-BB06-443384CEF5BF: Matched to MTH refer car factory color
  • B8ABAF78-D6DA-4E70-98BF-35EC247ED252: Mock-up of train
  • 47EFC31E-8CCF-4F3A-9F67-711D5C831948: Mock-up of train and tender
  • EFB4F3C5-51FD-4D53-B16E-E4BBB4D3ECC6: Train
  • 25E69B9A-F5E5-4313-873E-494B9689D551

Excellent did you make that or just paint it ?
It looks fantastic I want one.

Hi Michael - that was an old kit from around 2001 that I found. They do come up on auction sites if you want to search for one. Very easy kit to assemble.

To the original posters question - this color match is not easy, but you can get good results with a little playing around.

Paul

@Railrunnin posted:

Hi Michael - that was an old kit from around 2001 that I found. They do come up on auction sites if you want to search for one. Very easy kit to assemble.

To the original posters question - this color match is not easy, but you can get good results with a little playing around.

Paul

A very similar kit is still available from forum sponsor TW Trainworx. It, too, is very easy to assemble.  

https://www.twtrainworxstore.c...circle-l-bridge-kit/

I painted some prewar O gauge in the Lionel orange and blue colors. This is one of the junk pieces I brought back to life. Did the engine and a bunch of freight cars and caboose with the Lionel colors. Just a note all of the items I paint were to far gone with the original paint). Anyway, the orange I used is a rattle can of Rustoleum. The color is called Real Orange. They also have another orange but is not that close to the oringinal Lionel orange. I would only do this if you are painting everything, so this is not intended for touch ups😊

Attachments

Images (1)
  • mceclip0

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×