Skip to main content

I just rcieved an SD-70 mac CSX 2-11558 Lionel/Kline I think it is one of the Kline clubs special purchase that Lionel absorbed. My problem is it works beautiful in conventional with the cruse switch under panel in roof turned off, when turned on the engine barely creeps

along at full throttle. Is there a reset, or something I am doing wrong? It does not have command or railsounds but some kind of sound. Any help? Tanks Mark

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hi Mark,

 

Unfortunately, you have a real orphan on your hands.  The K-line conventional engines with sound, smoke, and speed control were not continued by Lionel beyond the club engines.  There's no documentation for the system on either the K-Line by Lionel or the Legacy K-Line web sites.  Hopefully someone with one of these engines will see your post and can at least provide any info from the user's manual.

 

Sorry I couldn't be more help, but I figured a post would help keep your thread on page 1 through tomorrow morning.  A lot of folks don't get to see much of the forum until the weekend.

Originally Posted by raildog:

It does not have command or railsounds but some kind of sound.

Hi guys,

 

I think the real difficulty here is that this is NOT a TMCC engine.  If it was Mark could do a reset w/ TMCC or Legacy and get back to good.  Unfortunately, if what Mark wrote is correct, his engine has sound and speed control but is conventionally controlled, like this ARR SD70MAC.

 

Personally, I never saw one of these non-command engines in person.  However, I do have experience with the TMCC versions.  As Sasquatch indicated, it was sometimes difficult to get the K-Line command engines to accept their speed step setting (32, 128, or 256).  Once they were set the speed curve was non-linear so the engines took some getting use to.  One of the best I ever ran was a K-Line 2-truck Shay set at 128 steps.  It would creep beautifully and had excellent speed control up to about 15 smph.  Once you got it dialed in right it was quite good.  IIRC, some of the technology that was funneled to K-Line by Lionel's then engineer, Marty Pearson, was the cruise control design which was being developed for Legacy.  These late K-Line engines have speed control that is far better than anything Lionel ever put in a TMCC engine prior to Legacy.  I'm not sure how much things changed between the K-Line Cruise designs and what Lionel put into production for Legacy (Odyssey II speed control), but if you have the two apart there are some obvious similarities, such as the tach wheel.

I have a Weaver "Little Joe" which used the K-Line speed control.  It operates, OK, but you have to get used to the very slow rate of acceleration it provides.  When the speed control is on, the engine may take over a minute and travel some 10 or 15 feet before it gets to full speed.  So it might seem to you that it's top speed is restricted but on mine, it will get up there; it just takes a long time.

 

Actually, that kind of acceleration is more realistic because a large engine pulling a long train really does take a long time to get up to speed.  Play withe the engine, a bit, and see if you can adjust to this slow acceleration rate.

 

Paul Fischer

I had a similar problem with the K-Line club EP-5 Electric... I still have it...  It's the TMCC version and operation with the K-Line Cruise control active was very erratic..  It, too, worked great with the Cruise Control turned OFF...  The engine ran well in this state with the Legacy controller and the TMCC controller although operation was smoother with the CAB-2...  Changing the speed steps [at least with my engine] did not make any difference in the erratic operation with Cruise Control active...

 

I decided the cruise control design was faulty and installed an ERR Cruise Commander M into the Engine; now it runs great under cruise control...

 

I don't think it matters whether the engine is a Conventional or TMCC version -- the K-Line cruise control had problems...

Originally Posted by JimQ:

I had a similar problem with the K-Line club EP-5 Electric... operation with the K-Line Cruise control active was very erratic.. 

I decided the cruise control design was faulty and installed an ERR Cruise Commander M into the Engine; now it runs great under cruise control...

 

There's been a lot of discussion about problem K-Line cruise units for a long time, and for years now EP-5 owners have pretty much all agreed that the thing to do is remove it and drop in an ERR cruise unit.

 

That's what I did on my NH #379, and it transformed the cruise function.

 

Gunrunnerjohn is right on - it's a waste of time and money trying to rehabilitate the K-Line unit when you can get an ERR unit for the same money.

Originally Posted by Bob Karas:

Nothing is pointless. Yes the cost is about the same installing ERR system . This will work on diesels but on steam it is a little more involved. You see the err board does not have programmable chuff. You have to install a switch or magnetic reed switch  to trigger the chuff. One the k-line board is programmed correctly it runs as good as a lionel system. I have several k-line steam  that have been converted to ver4  and they all  are right up there in performance with lionel. I can program the chuff from 1 to 6 chuffs per wheel cycle,try doing that with err in steam engs .K-line system was good if you knew how to use it. If you look at the design it was lionel second generation cruise board. Who knows what would happen to the design if K-line stayed in business

Problem is, as you say, K-Line is NOT in business, and those upgrade boards are obviously scarce or non-existent.  OTOH, I can order the ERR unit right now.  Oh, and last time I checked the EP-5 didn't have a chuff.   You're right, on a steamer if it doesn't have a chuff switch.  OTOH, I have a K-Line tank engine, and it does have a chuff switch, so that comment doesn't apply.

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×