Skip to main content

This is just wondering out loud. Doubt anyone has a hard answer. I have taken to believe the world of 'Logistics' is very much like the story ' The Emperor's New Clothes'.  Logistics doesn't really work.....but backed by so many college degrees no one will question.

I ask because as I track packages containing my model trains I notice they travel much more than any person on vacation would. And if this was the first time a train had taken this route I'd figure it was a fluke. But 9 out of 10 times a package shipped from a location within a 3-4 hour drive is sent cross country on a 'vacation'!!  I buy from a OGR sponsor on a semi-regular basis. They are 200 miles East of my house. Yet EVERY package sent from them goes to Columbus Ohio first, 300 miles West of my house before returning to my house. When you ask why......'Logistics' !! Items shipped from the Mid-West almost always pass within 75 miles of my house....travel to Charlotte NC and then return. Logistics!! I checked on a purchase made  last week.  Shipped from MD......it's now vacationing in Florida!!!

 

usps

Is there anyone that can explain logistics as something other than what it looks like to the 'under educated'????

At least my model trains travel like real trains!!!!

Attachments

Images (1)
  • usps
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hi Dave,

 

I have a B.S. in transportation and Logistics.  The reason your packages travel so much has to do with factors other than the costs of the extra miles.  It all started with Fedx.  Its actually cheaper, faster and more efficient to ship all packages to a central location, sort everything and then send them onto their destination.  This is so due to economy of scale, cheaper land and building costs at the central location.  These "hubs" also are located near less trafficked railroad and air hubs usually making the shipping company the dominate player for the railroad and airport facilities in their area giving them priority.  These hubs are usually located where taxes and labor costs are cheaper.  Lastly, as these hubs are huge facilities , the companies usually can negotiate great tax breaks and infrastructure improvements. Hope this was helpful.

I flew extensively for work from the mid 70s through the 90s, and it was not uncommon for luggage to "vacation" somewhere other then where I was. A carryon with a essentials was the solution. I have had winter-weight suits vacation in Hawaii while I'm working in New York. So goes logistics, I expect the suits where as unhappy as me.

Originally Posted by JSP:

Hi Dave,

 

I have a B.S. in transportation and Logistics.  The reason your packages travel so much has to do with factors other than the costs of the extra miles.  It all started with Fedx.  Its actually cheaper, faster and more efficient to ship all packages to a central location, sort everything and then send them onto their destination.  This is so due to economy of scale, cheaper land and building costs at the central location.  These "hubs" also are located near less trafficked railroad and air hubs usually making the shipping company the dominate player for the railroad and airport facilities in their area giving them priority.  These hubs are usually located where taxes and labor costs are cheaper.  Lastly, as these hubs are huge facilities , the companies usually can negotiate great tax breaks and infrastructure improvements. Hope this was helpful.

Thanks for the reply.

My real job was a senior Analyst for a big bank. I am old school in that I learned the job via OJT and not a degree. I still have a hard time seeing my package being driven within miles of my house only to stop 6 hours later and immediately be turned around the opposite direction. Maybe it's like my wife accuses me of......over analyzing it!!!!

 

Lee......it's not the amount of time the trip takes as much as the path taken!!! Just seems odd to me at times.....but as I get older many things don't make sense!!

"I still have a hard time seeing my package being driven within miles of my house only to stop 6 hours later and immediately be turned around the opposite direction. Maybe it's like my wife accuses me of......over analyzing it!!! It's not the amount of time the trip takes as much as the path taken!!! Just seems odd to me at times.....but as I get older many things don't make sense!!" 

 

I agree. However, as I tried to illustrate in my previous post, a more direct routing approach is no guarantee of efficient delivery. With a hub, one gets all the crap in one place, then sorts it out, I practice approach myself when dealing with my crap. With the "hub" concept, when things are lost, at least they are lost in the same place.

 

I shipped a medium box of trains from Scottsdale AZ to central PA.  First the box went to California before it went east.  It took about 6 days, and this was Parcel Post!  I think you are over analyzing, think of something else; like when is MTH going to update their website for ordering parts!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×