Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by DaveJfr0:

Okay, I posted them to my blog.

 

They are in the second half of this post:

 

http://davejfr0.blogspot.com/2...cluding-prr-gla.html

Thanks for uploading those photos, Dave. Very informative. Looks like Lionel is also dumping the fast-angle wheel in favor of a more realistic countour, albeit with an extra wide tread and large flange. Looking forward to the production models hitting the streets this year and the 8-door  versions next year.

Well, I'm wondering about the "unique road numbers each car" 

 

Have we finally achieved a new cost-effective printing technique?....ratcheting, sequential pad printing? Think of the collecting mayhem that will ensue!....The secondary market prices on the first and last cars of a series!.....No more Sheldon-like commentary from people scanning Lionel boxes ("Got it, got it, got it, got it, got it, got it....").... 

 

Hmmmm.....  This could be bigger than non-operating doors.  Maybe it should be at the TOP of the list, instead of the bottom!

 

 

Last edited by dkdkrd
Originally Posted by N.Q.D.Y.:

They do look nice, and I'm looking forward to seeing the finished articles. 

 

But.... I'm still puzzled as to why the fact that the doors don't open qualifies as a listed feature? 

Non-opening doors = no grossly oversized door guides to detract from the appearance of the scale detailing on the model, so yes, I'd say that's a feature. 

 

Case in point:  Weaver's 57' mechanical refrigerator cars have non-operating plug doors & therefore have very realistic looking door guide railings.  Now take Lionel's version of the same car that has opening doors, and look at how large the door guides are in comparison.

Originally Posted by John Korling:
Originally Posted by N.Q.D.Y.:

They do look nice, and I'm looking forward to seeing the finished articles. 

 

But.... I'm still puzzled as to why the fact that the doors don't open qualifies as a listed feature? 

Non-opening doors = no grossly oversized door guides to detract from the appearance of the scale detailing on the model, so yes, I'd say that's a feature. 

 

Case in point:  Weaver's 57' mechanical refrigerator cars have non-operating plug doors & therefore have very realistic looking door guide railings.  Now take Lionel's version of the same car that has opening doors, and look at how large the door guides are in comparison.

Absolutely! Also, no doors vibrating open during operation. Saw the Lionel 57-foot reefer and didn't like the look of the bulky door guides. Don't care for the opening doors on MTH box cars either for the same reason.

Originally Posted by AGHRMatt:

       




Absolutely! Also, no doors vibrating open during operation. Saw the Lionel 57-foot reefer and didn't like the look of the bulky door guides. Don't care for the opening doors on MTH box cars either for the same reason.


       


Yes, not to mention that the prototype 57' mechanical refrigerator cars have cushion underframes which is reflected on the Weaver models but absent from the Lionel version.  The Lionel version is also missing the simulated exhaust cover on the roof over the diesel engine compartment,  another feature that Weaver got right.

Hey guys!

Glad you enjoyed seeing the 3-D models at the show. Couple useful tid-bits to assist in the conversation.

 

Each car will feature our existing 70T rotating Bearing Cap trucks as shown in Mr. Slater's pics.

 

Each car will feature pads and holes to accommodate scale coupler boxes, but even more each car will include a pair of injection molded draft gear boxes which will extend the scale coupler from the end of the car for a more prototypical feel and to assist scale guys in getting these cars around their curves!

 

The stirrup steps on the ends of the car will be die-cast for durability I am pretty certain every one of the steps that were 3-D printed were gone in the first 3 hours! 

 

We are really excited to get these cars produced. Glad to hear the reaction to their appearance at York is positive!

 

Thanks to everyone who swung by the booth at York!

Mike Reagan

Lionel

Originally Posted by Mike Slater:

I got to handle the 4-door prototype which was 3-d printed, wow!!!!!!

_MG_2137

_MG_2136

_MG_2135

 

Great Pictures! I am sitting here viewing them and say to myself, self, that guy is wearing a watch a lot like mine!

 

Duh! I was holding them for I guess Mike and didn't know I would be a hand model on the forums!

Last edited by PRR2818

Hi Mike

 

Some questions/comments about these AWESOME cars!

 

1. I don't want to body mount my scale couplers, I'd much rather be able to mount a scale coupler box on the "cool swinging arm thingy" that allows the 3 rail couplers to move for tight curves. Since these cars aren't fully in production yet, please consider making a part that would allow this.

2. The extended draft gear boxes are a GREAT idea. PLEASE consider offering these for separate sale. I know lots of guys who would want to use these on other freight cars. Nobody makes anything like this for O scale. 

3. Road names for the 8 door cars Detroit & Toledo Shore Line, DT&I,  SP/Cotton Belt, and GTW again.

3. Lastly, PLEASE offer these cars for sale as single cars. The policy of "only available in a two-pack" is killing me. It forces me to buy more cars than I need need or want and wastes the money I have available to spend on other cars or locomotives.

 

Thanks SO much for listening to your customers and making these great cars!
– RICH

Originally Posted by falconservice:

Perhaps there will be a few train stores that will sell the boxcars from the GTW, CR, NS 2-packs separately.

 

 

If you like to make the density of Grand Trunk Western freight higher, then the 2-Pack for the GTW 86' high-cube boxcars is the way to do it.

 

 

Andrew

 

Originally Posted by Mike Slater:
Rich they are avaliable in 2 packs and single cars

3 different numbers per roadname

A different Mike

What I'm seeing is U have to get the two packs of some names and others are only in the full set with the engine, right?

 I'd better order some packs soon?

Originally Posted by DaveJfr0:
Looks like a winner so far…Lionel should pay serious QA time checking the paint colors, so they don't end up with another X-31 PRR Chocolate Brown fiasco. A lot of 2R's had those cars on pre-order and won't do it again because of it.

 

I would like to see Lionel thoroughly research the road numbers for these as well and not use made-up numbers or numbers used on different series of cars as they've had on other similar high-end cars like their auto carriers.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×