Skip to main content

Background: I have several detailed drawings of CNW engines (and a caboose) that are framed and mounted on my home office walls. A few months ago I decided to complement the display with a few O-scale pieces, mostly freight cars but with one engine. These are displayed, along with my first HO-scale equipment that is 45-60 years old, in Showcase Express wall units. I selected MTH Premier equipment because of the level of detail.

I did purchase an MTH CNW U30C, which is currently in my display. However, my preference would be a non-powered unit, but the CNW road name seems to be scarce (looking only for new items). What I don't understand is the difference between Premier items; for example the 20-2561-3 Dash 9 version and the 20-20118-3 Dash 9 version. As noted, this will be primarily for display, and a high level of detail is preferred. It seems, using the example I mentioned, that the 20-20118-3 version is more scale-accurate.

Is that correct?

Thanks for any enlightenment.

Last edited by Tim L. Shuck
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Anything in the Premier line is going to be scale.  As with any model train manufacture MTH may have taken some liberties when making the tooling and the engines may not be 100% accurate to their true life counter part.

20-2561-3 is from 2004 and 20118-3 is from 2012.  They both represent Dash-9 engines.  They have slightly different paint schemes as the 20118-3 is the "lifesaver" scheme.  the one from 2012 probably has a little more detail.

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by MTH Electric Trains
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×