Originally Posted by chuck:
I believe the F's were only used in freight service and the Lionel version(s) never had the yellow blaze on the nose until the E's were released.
As much as a I lover the PW set (this was my first train set) it's a fantasy scheme on the wrong loco. If you really, really want the "real thing" then buy the E's.
Williams introduced E's before Lionel did and then proceeded to not do the the Texas Special on the E's while releasing a fantasy set of F-7's. I am betting that most of the train buyers have no idea what the real train looked like and either think
a) Lionel "got it right" or
b) assume the Lionel PW scheme isn't based on anything real (aka a "Lionel Lines" version).
I could execute quite a few electrons pointing out inaccuracies in Lionel, Williams and MTH paint jobs if I wanted to, particularly when it comes to postwar F3's and reproductions thereof.
But I won't. The toy vs. model thing was beaten to death AGAIN a week or so ago.
If folks want a foreshortened representation of trains like the Texas Special or others trains, it's purely up to them. If folks want to wait or search for the preciously released Lionel set with fluted E7's (with incorrect E6 pilots if you want to get fussy...)and long cars, it's also up to them.
Sometimes, a nice looking train is a nice looking train regardless of its accuracy.
Rusty