Skip to main content

Originally Posted by Hot Water:
Originally Posted by Jerry Kimble:

 We realize there is a tremendous amount of passion over the Santa Fe version of this locomotive and we'll diligently try not to disappoint the faithful including looking at all options of paint finishes including plating.

 

 

I hope this helps in making your decision whether to purchase our version of the F7 or another brand. I'm a huge Santa Fe Railway enthusiast myself modeling it on my modular railroad.

 

Jerry Kimble

Atlas Model Railroad Company

Coordinator Sales/Marketing/Product Development

So that confirms the Santa Fe models will be "plated" in order to correctly represent stainless steel side panels!

Just out of curiousity how do you equate Jerrys statement with looking at all options of finishes painted or plated with confirmed plated.

Originally Posted by hibar:
Originally Posted by Hot Water:
Originally Posted by Jerry Kimble:

 We realize there is a tremendous amount of passion over the Santa Fe version of this locomotive and we'll diligently try not to disappoint the faithful including looking at all options of paint finishes including plating.

 

 

I hope this helps in making your decision whether to purchase our version of the F7 or another brand. I'm a huge Santa Fe Railway enthusiast myself modeling it on my modular railroad.

 

Jerry Kimble

Atlas Model Railroad Company

Coordinator Sales/Marketing/Product Development

So that confirms the Santa Fe models will be "plated" in order to correctly represent stainless steel side panels!

Just out of curiousity how do you equate Jerrys statement with looking at all options of finishes painted or plated with confirmed plated.

Well darn. I guess someone will have to ask Mr. Kimble directly then, won't they? I just assumed that his answer covered it.

Mr. Kimble, your response is what I was hoping to see.  It is what I would expect of the excellent reputation that Atlas established building some of the finest O gauge equipment available.  You have a heavy Santa Fe schedule this year and I'm looking to pick up as much as possible.  I am especially looking forward to the Santa Fe F7!

 

My humble thanks.

Last edited by marker

Trust me if AtasO can do the plating and within their financial constraints, they will. Nobody does a better job of getting our trains right then AtlasO.

 

If ordering the SF units and whether they come plated or not they will still be the best F units in O gauge. 

 

No I do not work for AtlasO but I am a satisfied customer. 

Originally Posted by david1:

Trust me if AtasO can do the plating and within their financial constraints, they will. Nobody does a better job of getting our trains right then AtlasO.

 

If ordering the SF units and whether they come plated or not they will still be the best F units in O gauge. 

 

Well, if the Santa Fe F7 units do not come "plated" in order to properly represent stainless steel, then they sure as the devil will not be the "best F units in O gauge"! 

 

No I do not work for AtlasO but I am a satisfied customer. 

 

This stainless panel issue comes up every time there is a new release of the Santa Fe F units. Last May when 3rd Rail announced the F7's, and those are a couple hundred more than the street price of the Atlas units. No one has done it yet, (the simulated MTH units don't count) so if the Atlas models don't have stainless panels, there is nothing that sets them apart from anyone else.

 

Lets not have the price agreement either, because the Athearn Genesis engines sell at several hundred dollars in the HO market.

 

I have an ABBA set of 3rd Rail F7's on order, so unless the Atlas engines come plated, I just don't need another set of F7's. I'm not going to commit $1500 to a pre-order for Atlas with a "try not to disappoint" and "look at all options" statement. Atlas makes great products yes, but based on the past few years of delivery issues, it's going to take a little more than that for me to get back on board with Atlas.   

Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Laidoffsick:

This stainless panel issue comes up every time there is a new release of the Santa Fe F units. Last May when 3rd Rail announced the F7's, and those are a couple hundred more than the street price of the Atlas units. No one has done it yet, (the simulated MTH units don't count) so if the Atlas models don't have stainless panels, there is nothing that sets them apart from anyone else.

 

Lets not have the price agreement either, because the Athearn Genesis engines sell at several hundred dollars in the HO market.

 

I have an ABBA set of 3rd Rail F7's on order, so unless the Atlas engines come plated, I just don't need another set of F7's. I'm not going to commit $1500 to a pre-order for Atlas with a "try not to disappoint" and "look at all options" statement. Atlas makes great products yes, but based on the past few years of delivery issues, it's going to take a little more than that for me to get back on board with Atlas.   

If we're strickly speaking plated side panels (to simulate SS) on SF F units in O Scale,  other than Key Import's SF F7 units, IMO the plating on the MTH SF F3 models are the best I've seen on any O Scale SF F unit so far, so I'm not sure what you mean by the your comments "No one has done it yet" and "the simulated MTH units don't count," they are plated. I'm sure the 3rd Rail F's will be fantastic, but I don't recall reading anywhere in there product decription that their SF F units will have plated side panels?   

 

Joe

Last edited by jvega2

I didn't say the 3rd rail units will be plated.... that's exactly why I don't need another set of F7's that are no better than any of the others. With the MTH "tether" between the F3's (not even F7's) and various other details.... I don't count those. If Atlas is going to plate the panels, then absolutely I would be in for another set, and would consider them to be the best offerings out there.

 

Ignored completely! That's why I won't pre order them. I don't think its fair to the hobby shops for me to order them based on a "maybe" I'll take them once I see them. Even though they don't require any money up front, and would sell them anyway just because they are Santa Fe Warbonnets, I'm done ordering stuff up front without seeing it first. 

 

These manufacturers want to "build to order", or reservations determine the number of units produced......  then show me EXACTLY what I am ordering up front! If they can't commit, NOR WILL I!

Last edited by Former Member
Originally Posted by Jerry Kimble

 

We want to thank all the Atlas supporters who have pre-ordered our F7 and that     have been positive in their remarks on this forum. We realize there is a tremendous amount of passion over the Santa Fe version of this locomotive and we'll diligently try not to disappoint the faithful including looking at all options of paint finishes including plating.

 

In our haste to meet the catalog deadline there were some typos and mistakes that happened along the way for which we apologize, but rest assured when these locomotives arrive they'll have the following:

 

  • Highly detailed body and railroad specific details
  • Accurate painting and lettering
  • Accurate road numbers
  • Steam generator on either the A or B unit as appropriate by railroad
  • Available in powered and unpowered versions
  • All metal grab irons
  • Die-cast metal chassis, fuel tank and trucks
  • A hidden port in the bottom of each of the Blomberg "B" trucks for lubrication of the worm gears without disassembly of the locomotive
  • Twin flywheel equipped can motors for the powered models
  • Directional golden white LED lighting with MARS lighting where appropriate
  • Close coupling between units for a better look
  • 3-rail models will have Electric Railroad Company's "Cruise Commander"® speed control
  • 3-rail models will have improved Lionel ®"RailSounds" digital sound system with improved "Crew Talk"
  • 3-rail models will be 100 percent "TMCC"® or "LEGACY"® Command Control compatible
  • 3-rail models will include operating diesel exhaust
  • 3-rail model "A" units will include an alternate full scale front pilot for a great look 
  • 2-rail models will incorporate all the features and options mentioned for the 3-rail models specific for a 2-rail version regardless of the decoder or sound system we use

 

 

Jerry Kimble

Atlas Model Railroad Company

Coordinator Sales/Marketing/Product Development

 

We all appreciate Mr Kimble taking the time to post here in an attempt to quell the concerns for the faithful so to speak. In reading and re reading the (edited) statement above, I don't get the assurance that the Santa Fe's will definitely be plated which is the major concern expressed by most of us.  It would have been better if Jerry was more concise with a definite 'yes', a definite 'no', or something like 'we're evaluating the possibility' of having them plated. 

As has been mentioned before, Athern has been able to offer this finish on their beautiful HO models at a reasonable price so it IS doable. Hopefully Atlas will be able as well.

Laid Off Sick is right.  At this point we have no guarantee of how the body will be treated.


When does the pre-order window close?  I would like to buy an ABBA set but I want to have a clearer understanding of what I am getting for my $1300.

 

Mr. Kimble, will you have a sample or a definitive description of how the bodies will be treated before the pre-order window closes?

thank you

Originally Posted by Hot Water:

Is it just me, or is Mr. Kimble specifically ignoring the posts from myself and Laidoffsick, concerning the "plated" side panels on Santa Fe F7 units?

I don't think he's ignoring you guys. Realistically, he can't just say "Oh yeah." He needs time to work the thing internally and verify what they can commit to doing. You guys have raised the issue - let them work it.

Wow,you Santa Fe fans have some real issues to contend with.  Rightfully so,I might add.

I'm glad to be a Pennsy fan.  My choices are simple: Tuscan or DGLE,whiskers or  single stripe,A-B-A,or A-B.  I made my choice awhile back with an A-B set in DGLE,single stripe from 3rd Rail.

Good luck to all of you guys in your quest for fidelity.

Norm

Last edited by Norm
Originally Posted by Norm:

Wow,you Santa Fe fans have some real issues to contend with.  Rightfully so,I might add.

I'm glad to be a Pennsy fan.  My choices are simple: Tuscan or DGLE,whiskers or  single stripe,A-B-A,or A-B.  I made my choice awhile back with an A-B set in DGLE,single stripe from 3rd Rail.

Good luck to all of you guys in your quest for fidelity.

Norm

PRR is not as straight forward as you might think.  PRR owned F7s in every major phase of design.  If you look closely there are at least 5 variations across the F7 as the PRR finally went all in on EMD and F7s when they determined steam was basically done.  However, I know the 3rd Rail one will be extremely faithful to the correct phase that is being produced

 

Santa Fe has it's challenges for sure based on what road numbers are assigned and what period of time you are looking at.  With the original units in the 37 and 300 warbonnets, the 200 series freight units and the later 325 dual service warbonnet units.  The numbering alone, the year being modeled and the associated details are enough to make your head spin.

T4TT and All,

 

This will be my final post on this subject. We are currently working with the factory of choosing the decorative method that has the most prototypical appearance for the Santa Fe Warbonnet F7, which will include plating.

 

We are working to have this resolved in time for the March announcement with a deadline to place your order being the second week of April. Look for the March announcement on our Atlas O webpage at this address: http://www.atlaso.com/nowshipping.htm

 

Jerry Kimble

Atlas Model Railroad Company

Coordinator Sales/Marketing/Product Development

Jonathan,

It is simple for me.  You are right though,I have trust that Scott will make the right engine.  That simplifies my choice.  I am just not into taking a "snapshot"  and picking a model for a given time.  I don't believe in making things more difficult for myself with my trains.  My A-B will be correct for me and I will eventually have fun running it on my layout.

By the way,I'm sure that Atlas will do a good job with their product.  I would have ordered theirs if was announced first.  I hope that Atlas will be able to make these and deliver them in a reasonable timeframe.  Atlas products are outstanding,as we all know.

Norm

Last edited by Norm

Thank you Jerry,

I could not expect any more from you our your company.  I appreciate the information you shared I will watch the Atlas homepage for the formal announcement in March.  I did not realize that the catalog was not the "formal announcement".  Sorry for the confusion, but thanks again for clearing it up.  I hope to order the engines from my dealer before the second week in April.

 

thanks again!

Originally Posted by Norm:

Jonathan,

It is simple for me.  You are right though,I have trust that Scott will make the right engine.  That simplifies my choice.  I am just not into taking a "snapshot"  and picking a model for a given time.  I don't believe in making things more difficult for myself with my trains.  My A-B will be correct for me and I will eventually have fun running it on my layout.

By the way,I'm sure that Atlas will do a good job with their product.  I would have ordered theirs if was announced first.  I hope that Atlas will be able to make these and deliver them in a reasonable timeframe.  Atlas products are outstanding,as we all know.

Norm

Norm - I'm biased since I'm working on final drawing revisions for 3rd Rail F7s now.    A lot of research went into them.  Many, many months.  Atlas makes great products too.  They are my second choice for accurate diesels and their AEM7 of 1999 is still the most accurate one I've seen in O.

Jonathan,

I think that I understand your bias.  You being a GG1 fan and all.  I still remember your photo camparing many GG1's side by side and different scales.  Very impressive.

I really appreciate the work that you guys do to get it right.  Atlas does the same.

Our hobby is enriched when 3rd Rail and Atlas do what it takes to turn out  the very best.  

I happen to have that AEM7.  It is still the standard as you say.

Thank you for all of the work that you do to get correct models for us. I appreciate it.

Norm 

Sorry in advance if this is a stupid question.   Have never bought any Atlas engines and trying to decide if/what/etc. Santa Fe combination I might be interested in.  I have no need, that I know of, for 3 powered ABBA, so I suppose that rules out 37LABC.  That leaves 45LABC as my preferred option, unless I want to mix-and-match numbers.  Can you run 45LA and 45CB as two separate AB trains, independent from each other, then join them for an ABBA?  I didn't think this was possible with MTH or Lionel. 

Originally Posted by VADarthDad:

Sorry in advance if this is a stupid question.   Have never bought any Atlas engines and trying to decide if/what/etc. Santa Fe combination I might be interested in.  I have no need, that I know of, for 3 powered ABBA, so I suppose that rules out 37LABC.  That leaves 45LABC as my preferred option, unless I want to mix-and-match numbers.  Can you run 45LA and 45CB as two separate AB trains, independent from each other

 

Yes.

 

, then join them for an ABBA?

 

Yes, again.

 

 I didn't think this was possible with MTH or Lionel. 

 

I sure though it was possible.

 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×