Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have two on order and I’m not really looking forward to them after the L1 fiasco. Lionel could ruin an anvil right about now.

At least it’s not a Dreyfuss…

I love Decapods, but have all I need with my two 3rd Rail beauties (one short tender, one long tender).  If I recall, this tooling was originally from MTH's 2006 version (gorgeous).  Norm, I have a request:  Once you work all out their little kinks, how about making a YouTube video of your double-headed Hippos pulling a 100 car beer train?  You do have a beer reefer for every bottle in your avatar, right?   

George

Chris’ Trains and Things just posted his newly arrived Dec on YouTube. Hard to tell but it looks a tad darker than the L1. At least it ain’t chartreuse or something!

Norm, do you just recommend hitting the green areas with several layers of grimy black or a similar paint to tone down the awful green Lionel has been using? I have several engines I need to correct, one being the PRR Class A (FG-1). It looks like a Christmas tree with the red cab roof !

Your weathering on the L1s came out great. Any more tips on correcting the paint while applying a weathered finish is very much appreciated.

I hit my L1 with Dullcote first as usual and was a bit more generous with the Grimy Black. Nothing too over the top though. The idea is not to turn the job into an overly consistent haze. I thought of trying some acrylic filters (like the ones made by Vallejo) but didn't bother as it would have probably been diminishing returns considering that a lot of the detail is actually pretty low relief (typical for diecast). I hope to do the 1369 this weekend. When I get the I1s, I'll probably do them the same way. Chris claims they are a bit darker.

These cost quite a bit more than the L1s and I assume/hope that means they get the Canon driveline. I probably shouldn't have ordered these. Just glad I didn't decide to replace my long lost TMCC Dreyfuss. Good god.

The I1 looks promising! Gotta love every wild color variation on those GLa hoopers. You can see how Lionel went from semi-ok colors to Crayola in one train.

…and for those just can’t fathom why there are color complaints, here’s an example showing some DGLE paint jobs from Lionel’s own recent past (with a vintage Atlas GP7 thrown in):

IMG_5625

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_5625

The reason I didn't preorder any of these I1s is because I already have a short tender version from MTH, so the long tender was all I was interested in and unfortunately in the Lionel Catalog, it's pictured with the incorrect 180F84 tender (from the Q2).

Both 3rd Rail and MTH got the correct 180/210/250F82 tenders on their versions of the I1sa.

Last edited by rplst8

It’s AWESOME - IMO 😊 - I had about 10 minutes this morning before I had to run - took a quick look and put it back in the box

I love the color - compared to the L1 it’s much darker / deeper

I have no idea how it runs - obviously - boxed nicely - the “Lionel” wrapping around the engine and tender feels softer / heavier to me ???

I have one with the long tender - I’ll try to post a few pics tonight

Thank you

Joe S

I am really hoping that there is zero issues at all with the I1's. Given that it is a larger locomotive(not by much) than the L1's, I would hope that the gear of isn't the same, that it is more in tune with the engines that have no gearbox issues like the Mohawks and M1's. Hopefully we'll have an answer quickly and I won't have to worry about putting another engine in shipping to see Pat.

Color aside, it looks like they got the letter size for PENNSYLVANIA correct this time.  Letters should be 7 scale inches tall.    If someone is repainting their L1s, I recommend using Clover House's PRR dry transfer lettering sets.  They have sets in gold and dulux/buff (freight and post 1952 passenger) cataloged by era. They offer 6 different lengths for the word PENNSYLVANIA so the modeler can match prototype practice for the era and tender size.

Last edited by Keystoned Ed

Great looking engine, John. I for one appreciate the close coupling distance between engine and tender.

As Ryan said in a past Trainworld interview, the PRR Hippo has been a long time coming for Lionel. Evidently, he is a avid and talented model railroader.

The I1s were a staple, often doubleheader or used in "Snapper" service. For anyone who knows PRR country, it's easy to understand why the PRR needed such a workhorse.

Last edited by Paul Kallus

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by Lionel, LLC

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×