Skip to main content

Hi all,

Can I please get some recommendations for a good book or DVD on how to service and repair postwar Lionel trains? I am not a total beginner but still have much to learn. 

Have been using my dad’s old copy of Greenberg’s Repair & Operating Manual and, to be honest, have not found it too useful. Looking for something more detailed and comprehensive.

Any suggestions?

Thanks!

Kevin

A5244009-6495-4E09-BA6E-2E301EA320EA

Attachments

Images (1)
  • A5244009-6495-4E09-BA6E-2E301EA320EA
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have both the original K-Line hardback book and the Greenberg paperback version of Guide to Servicing Lionel Trains.  The K-Line book is easier to read as the printing is a bit larger and the fact that it is hard bound makes viewing the many diagrams a pleasure as it will lay flat.

Other than those references type in your particular question on Youtube.  There are many enthusiasts that like to give their versions of repairing trains.   

   I take the "fix what's broken when it breaks with whatever's handy" approach mostly. I prefer nuts and bolts to rivets.  If it isn't factory, it can usually be reversed 99% of the time anyhow.

  I don't like to rely too heavily on manuals because it's not always "best", current, or even 100% way to correct things all the time IMExp.  I digress to collectors points of view, but I'm an operator more than a purest.

  The way I see it, there are only two ways to reverse an open frame motor. by brush or field swap. The rest, the e unit, is slightly more varible, a puzzle, but still limited to two types, and those limited in variations to be used. The rest is mostly common sense logic &/or mechanical in nature.

   Basically, I did this stuff as a kid and have confidence enough to know it's not that hard, I'm smarter, and more skilled today too.  I'd save for some proper tools and wing "knowledge" by asking for advice on each issue. Without the wheel pullers, rivet sets, arbor press, etc. the manual looses impact except for parts id, and such.

  Setting things down neatly and taking pictures as you go can help tons with reassembly if that's your weakness.

  My weakness is the rocket launcher and Wells Fargo gunfighter car on the same train...      I did it all the time; two of my oldest, most favorite cars.

My lone Sunoco tanker is also humbled

Adriatic posted:

   I take the "fix what's broken when it breaks with whatever's handy" approach mostly. I prefer nuts and bolts to rivets.  If it isn't factory, it can usually be reversed 99% of the time anyhow.

  I don't like to rely too heavily on manuals because it's not always "best", current, or even 100% way to correct things all the time IMExp.  I digress to collectors points of view, but I'm an operator more than a purest.

  The way I see it, there are only two ways to reverse an open frame motor. by brush or field swap. The rest, the e unit, is slightly more varible, a puzzle, but still limited to two types, and those limited in variations to be used. The rest is mostly common sense logic &/or mechanical in nature.

   Basically, I did this stuff as a kid and have confidence enough to know it's not that hard, I'm smarter, and more skilled today too.  I'd save for some proper tools and wing "knowledge" by asking for advice on each issue. Without the wheel pullers, rivet sets, arbor press, etc. the manual looses impact except for parts id, and such.

  Setting things down neatly and taking pictures as you go can help tons with reassembly if that's your weakness.

  My weakness is the rocket launcher and Wells Fargo gunfighter car on the same train...      I did it all the time; two of my oldest, most favorite cars.

My lone Sunoco tanker is also humbled

I was too young as a kid to be much help to my dad when he was fixing stuff. Now I can take most of it on. Great idea about taking pictures for reassembly - will definitely take that advice.

Those tankers are all beaters, had on eBay for a couple bucks each. Love having strings of things as I'm a fan of long trains.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×