Skip to main content

While running trains this morning, the Blue Comet abruptly stopped at a switch on the main line leading into a passenger station branch. The mechanism of the switch would not move, the breaker on the Z4000 opened, and there was no continuity through the third rail elements of the switch.   This switch is an 042 RH Real Trax piece that gets a lot of use on my layout, so it is imperative that it be in good working order.

 

After digging the switch out of the ground cover scenery and taking it apart, I discovered that one of the copper foil paths in a circuit board had melted itself into the sliding parts of the switch mechanism. The sketches below tell the rest of the story. Although I have a simple fix of the switch, I do not have a solution for the cause of the problem which is momentary short circuiting (sparking) of train wheels as they pass through the switch. Sparking is prevalent as trains pass through everyone of the 16 Real Trax switches on my layout.

 

 

Real Trax Switch Open Circuit Fix

Real Trax Switch Sparking Locations

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Real Trax Switch Open Circuit Fix
  • Real Trax Switch Sparking Locations
Last edited by Bobby Ogage
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have the the same problem on only 3 of my RealTrax switches. It always sparks for certain Locos and occasiobally enough to cause a shut down. I have watched as best I can to find out exactly what's happening but still can't find cause and cure. I also have burnt a path on switch and my LHS replaced with jumper wire. LHS said I did not have enough common wires to outside rails so instead of short going to common it fried switch. I have no idea if that's true or even the case. 

Hi Jeff,

All of my switches are on flat terrain. The sparking problem is prevalent on all of my switches where the mainline route enters the switch on the curve, and not so prevalent where trains enter on the straight going into the curve.

 

I will be experimenting on the worst case switch to minimize the sparking. Here are the fixes I will try. More to follow!

Real Trax Switch Sparking Locations

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Real Trax Switch Sparking Locations
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×