Skip to main content

After successfully repairing several fans in these, I got to thinking:

Why is the cooling fan sucking in air and dust and blowing that air/dust onto the transformers and then pushing hot air from those transformers right up and onto the processor/control boards before it escapes??

There’s dust and grime and dirt EVERYWHERE after several years in a normal environment.

Would anyone with experience in cooling systems care elaborate on why this makes more sense than having the fan go in the opposite direction - pulling cool air in first through the top as it moves onto and over the control/processor board first then pulls hot air off the transformer cores (out and away from the processors) before finally escaping through the fan and out the bottom vent.

I’m thinking of flipping the fan around in mine and don’t some tests, but not before I’ve heard some expert opinions.

OK. Thanks!

Very cool inside these things 😎 (pun intended).

*oh in case you were wondering-

this one went sorta dead months ago:

~no red light at all

~4000; 0124 readout on panel

so far found that the throttles needed adjustments, red light plug was flopping around inside; filth everywhere - doing a deep cleaning; and suspicious about the control board so I’m going to test that hard before I put it back together completely; have a spare new one on hand just in case

85823766-5743-4355-83C1-F70BBC6F17F34246E3C3-4681-493F-A396-62D4A9DD91594825E6FD-C3B1-45E9-8F94-4838C014E5756D3A7F13-B2A5-43CA-B316-F26EC11CE6E5F66280D3-BE2F-4281-9FA9-EDB9BED64E44

9FFFD70F-44B9-4D96-92C7-2A2A520EBB1E

Attachments

Images (6)
  • 85823766-5743-4355-83C1-F70BBC6F17F3
  • 4246E3C3-4681-493F-A396-62D4A9DD9159
  • 4825E6FD-C3B1-45E9-8F94-4838C014E575
  • 6D3A7F13-B2A5-43CA-B316-F26EC11CE6E5
  • F66280D3-BE2F-4281-9FA9-EDB9BED64E44
  • 9FFFD70F-44B9-4D96-92C7-2A2A520EBB1E: F I L T H Y
Last edited by DdotCdot
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Fans running either way will have the same effect.  Look at the inside of your PC after it runs for a few months.  The power supply fan sucks air out of the case and through the power supply before exhausting it.  When I open mine for it's semi-annual cleaning, there is a coating of dust on EVERYTHING!  Remember, the dust didn't grow inside the transformer, no matter which way the fan blows, the dust all came in from the outside!  Also, remember that hot air rises, they're just using the fan to help it along and provide cooling.

My advice is to trust the design team that build the Z-4000, I suspect they knew which way was best for airflow and cooling.

Fans running either way will have the same effect.  Look at the inside of your PC after it runs for a few months.  The power supply fan sucks air out of the case and through the power supply before exhausting it.  When I open mine for it's semi-annual cleaning, there is a coating of dust on EVERYTHING!  Remember, the dust didn't grow inside the transformer, no matter which way the fan blows, the dust all came in from the outside!  Also, remember that hot air rises, they're just using the fan to help it along and provide cooling.

My advice is to trust the design team that build the Z-4000, I suspect they knew which way was best for airflow and cooling.

Fair enough. Thanks. And you’re right - come to think of it - back when I was repairing and rebuilding MAC computers it was the same thing inside, always, but I never played with the fan direction (mostly because there wasn’t much room inside to fool around with those; it just required routine cleaning). Dust is an unavoidable monster, but I was curious if maybe this could reduce it to some degree, looking at how air travels through this design.

Dave Krebiehl and MTH team did a beautiful job on this design. Hard to believe this is 23 years ago right here. Impressive.

Last edited by DdotCdot

Add Reply

Post
This forum is sponsored by MTH Electric Trains
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×