Skip to main content

Good Day,
 
The 21st Century Commuter Trains get no respect! Where are the modern day commuter trains with engines and matching passenger cars in O Scale?
 
The MPI MP36PH-3C would be fantastic in O Scale. Offering these engines and their matching passenger cars would be great.
 
Regards,
Swafford
 
 

3361

3362

3363

3364

3365

3366

3368

3369

3370

Attachments

Images (9)
  • 3361
  • 3362
  • 3363
  • 3364
  • 3365
  • 3366
  • 3368
  • 3369
  • 3370
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Well, I figure it is like this:

- People who live near commuter train routes take these things and see them every day and probably don't want to see them when they get home and have time to play.

- People who don't live near commuter train routes and don't take and see them every day probably don't care about them.

So I expect they will continue to get no respect except form the folks, like I used to be, who depend on them every day.

I'm practically in the same boat as Lee. I see MARC and VRE EVERY day, 5 days a week. They both run MP36s and similar cars. I see them so often, I don't really even pick up my head when they go by. Would I buy a MARC set...maybe. Since I see them so much, I would be likely to say "no". 

 

MARC does use the front couplers somewhat regularly. It is somewhat common, on the heavier and faster trains running the Corridor, as well as up to Brunswick and Martinsburg and Camden Yards to have doubleheaders both with MP36s or a combination with MPs and older units. 

Swafford:

 

The Rail Runner was on my "top three" wish list of passenger trains that I would like to see available in the marketplace. With the K-Line Bombardier cars long gone, I figured the likelihood of this set being made in O-Gauge was not good, so I had a custom set done.

 

This is one the most colorful passenger trains in service. It sure is an attention getter.

Originally Posted by Jim M Sr:

"There is an F59 for sale on the Bay right now!"

 

Has 4.3 miles, and 36 minutes on it according to the pictures,. I'd bet someone was very disappointed with it!

No Jim I.... I mean I'm sure THEY were happy with it I.... I mean THEY just didn't have any passenger cars with the MetroLink logo to go along with it.  It was originally purchased to head up an Amtrak Superliner consist but just didn't look right.  My F40 (I think thats it) just looks better since it is Amtrak also. 

Originally Posted by Passenger Train Collector:

Swafford:

 

The Rail Runner was on my "top three" wish list of passenger trains that I would like to see available in the marketplace. With the K-Line Bombardier cars long gone, I figured the likelihood of this set being made in O-Gauge was not good, so I had a custom set done.

 

This is one the most colorful passenger trains in service. It sure is an attention getter.


Interesting.  Would love to get my hands on one.Where did you get a custom Rail runner made?  Do you have pics or videos?  More info please!!!! 

 

 

I don't know about "No respect" but O guage DOES have a variety [abeit small one] for commuter trains:

 

Atlas O

NJT

Amtrak

Marc

Septa

Boston "T"

 

MTH

Metro North- [Condot NH]

Boston "T"

Tri-Rail

CNW

Metra

Caltrans

Amtrak-[ex CNW Bi-Level cars]

Amtrak NE direct

Amtrak California

Marc*

Septa*

NJ Transit*

 

* denotes Mth used incorrect Amfleet for passenger cars. also MTH used incorrect lossenge bi-levels for nj transit as well.

 

K-line

027 Amtrak

North Carolina

027 NJ transit

 

Lionel

027 Metro North

027 Lirr

 

There maybe others but they just escape me now

 

Originally Posted by Lee Willis:

Well, I figure it is like this:

- People who live near commuter train routes take these things and see them every day and probably don't want to see them when they get home and have time to play.

- People who don't live near commuter train routes and don't take and see them every day probably don't care about them.

So I expect they will continue to get no respect except form the folks, like I used to be, who depend on them every day.


Bingo! I will be modeling PRR commuter service on our layout, but it will be K-4s and P70 coaches though so...

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×