Skip to main content

great thread! i love when MPC comes up on here. as far as i'm concerned if you don't like it don't buy it. i have stuff from all era's no command or anything like that though. most of diesels are MPC for the most part they run well my blue and orange sd-28 saw a lot of track time this year it pulls a dummy gp and and about 13-14 cars on my 5x10 i was running my 8770 yesterday i snagged that for 30 bucks. i have a next to new milwaulkee special , the blue comet cars, but my favorite is my live savers car, my grandmother insisted i get that car when i was 8, i didn't want it i wanted a car with a real road name so she got me that car for christmas because she liked it so much, many years later i picked up atootsie roll car i run them every year on my christmas train. i also use a kw anda zw for power so no worries about too much draw. lol

Dave

Originally Posted by Balshis:
Originally Posted by JC642:
Let alone the safety issues those older models create.  

Really?  "Safety 'issues?'"  Thank you, sir, for alerting me to the horrible dangers posed by my postwar and MPC trains!  Each and every one of them is obviously a rolling time bomb, putting my life on the line every time I power it up!

 

LOL, Nothing like a quick short cut & paste to take a message out of context..

OH, so boring...

 

Its easy to see by the quality and depth of recent posts on this forum, the real interesting ones like yours.. this one time multi-faceted hobby is fast becoming so one dimension towards operating, there will be no room for anything else.

Joe

Back in the mid 80's and early 90's I had a slew of MPC.  The MPC era pretty much captured the magic of postwar, except for the fact you had to wear shades because of the bright colors.

 

Eventually had to sell it off during the mid 90's, along with my postwar to help finance my way through a 2+ year layoff.

 

While I probably wouldn't start collecting it again, I don't regret my time with MPC.  It was probably the most fun time I've had with model railroading.

 

Rusty

 

 

Originally Posted by ADCX Rob:
Originally Posted by JC642:
...Let alone the safety issues those older models create...  

We would like to know more about this statement that was stuck into the middle of unrelated content.

Who is we? The context of the statement was in relation to the safety of other engines with modern electronics on the same track when a roller sparking pulmor relic drawing high amps is running.  

 

All it takes to understand why the safety of anything modern sitting on the rails is compromised is run your finger down the center rail with power set at 18 volts drawing 8 amps and feel the vibration. Then try it at three.

Joe

 

Last edited by JC642

I really don't think those of us running Postwar and MPC are going to be running modern day electronic stuff on the same track. We are 99% or better running conventional old school.

"We" is those of us who take umbrage at your comments about safety issues that don't really exist other than in your opinion.

Your comment about them being relics leads me to believe you have no love for older stuff and that's fine but don't make up safety and operational issues that don't exist to justify it for what ever reason you might have.

Personally if it won't run I won't buy it or I'll make it run, no shelf queens in my train room.

 

Jerry

Last edited by baltimoretrainworks
Originally Posted by baltimoretrainworks:

I really don't think those of us running Postwar and MPC are going to be running modern day electronic stuff on the same track. We are 99% or better running conventional old school.

"We" is those of us who take umbrage at your comments about safety issues that don't really exist other than in your opinion.

Your comment about them being relics leads me to believe you have no love for older stuff and that's fine but don't make up safety and operational issues that don't exist to justify it for what ever reason you might have.

Personally if it won't run I won't buy it or I'll make it run, no shelf queens in my train room.

 

Jerry

LOL, all I can say to that is I love and enjoy my MPC relics right where it sits, on a shelf..

Joe

 

If it weren't for MPC I doubt there would be O gauge as we know it today. I give credit to them for seeing there was a future for it which I think bucked the fashionable trends of the day. MPC is like Rock and Roll, it's colorful crude, loud and cranky..all this latest fad of trying to make O gauge "respectable" wouldnt be around if it were not for MPC.

Oh these arent toys they are scale models...right.

All I know is that they kept the fun going. Put on some Chuck berry and let them roll. Long may they run.

Last edited by electroliner

What a great thread.....

 

I also have several MPC's...heck my first train set was the Sears Silver Star set however slightly different than Christophers shown above.  Mine has a green republic gon and a blue Great Northern Hopper but Engine Flat and Caboose are the same.

 

Have several other pieces as well and have quite a collection of 9800 Billboard Reefers.  Also had the complete Spirit of 76 set but I parted with that several years ago.  I loved the state boxcars in that set but detested the cheap paint job on the engine and caboose.

Originally Posted by baltimoretrainworks:

I really don't think those of us running Postwar and MPC are going to be running modern day electronic stuff on the same track. We are 99% or better running conventional old school.

"We" is those of us who take umbrage at your comments about safety issues that don't really exist other than in your opinion.

 

I would be. I run the most modern Legacy equipment with MPC, LTI or Postwar equipment; enjoy all my trains an all see action. That's why I bought them. I don't know where the 8-9 amps come from. My MPC Santa Fe Trainmaster draws about 2.5 amps with a train in tow. My 2343 draws just about 3 amps. The newer GP30's or GP35's or SD70ACe's draw 1.5 to 2 amps so it is not a huge difference. 

Originally Posted by JC642:
 

All it takes to understand why the safety of anything modern sitting on the rails is compromised is run your finger down the center rail with power set at 18 volts drawing 8 amps and feel the vibration. Then try it at three.

Joe

 

Seriously, if you have equipment drawing 8 amps, something is wrong. 




quote:
The context of the statement was in relation to the safety of other engines with modern electronics on the same track when a roller sparking pulmor relic drawing high amps is running.  




 

I didn't see where this context was established in the original post.

 

Regardless, are the electronics in modern trains so sensitive that the sparking from an older modern era piece is going to cook them?

Originally Posted by C W Burfle:

 

Regardless, are the electronics in modern trains so sensitive that the sparking from an older modern era piece is going to cook them?

I've routinely operated postwar diesels and MTH units equipped with the original Protosounds in multiple unit consists. The operating characteristics in terms of electric power consumption and gearing are very similar for the two types and they run well together. I've not noticed any problems developing with the MTH units due to MU'ing them with postwar locomotives so my experience has been fine in this regard.

 

Bob

Originally Posted by electroliner:

If it weren't for MPC I doubt there would be O gauge as we know it today. I give credit to them for seeing there was a future for it which I think bucked the fashionable trends of the day. MPC is like Rock and Roll, it's colorful crude, loud and cranky..all this latest fad of trying to make O gauge "respectable" wouldnt be around if it were not for MPC.

Oh these arent toys they are scale models...right.

All I know is that they kept the fun going. Put on some Chuck berry and let them roll. Long may they run.

I agree with you on your first paragraph.  I was living in Hawaii, just being discharged from the Navy, and I went to the Sears store during Christmas and to my surprise was some Lionel track, a couple of freight cars and a 1972 MPC catalog.  I asked if I could order from the catalog and soon had my first new Lionel trains since 1957.

 

MPC was and is still great stuff.  MPC bridged the gap needed to keep the icon name Lionel going.  It also started the early trend of "operating" trains instead of just "collecting" and watching post war trains accumulating dust on shelves.  There will always be good memories and a special place in my heart for MPC.

 

Steve, Lady and Tex

Originally Posted by TexSpecial:
Originally Posted by electroliner:

If it weren't for MPC I doubt there would be O gauge as we know it today.

...I was living in Hawaii, just being discharged from the Navy, and I went to the Sears store during Christmas and to my surprise was some Lionel track, a couple of freight cars and a 1972 MPC catalog.  I asked if I could order from the catalog and soon had my first new Lionel trains since 1957.

 

MPC was and is still great stuff.  MPC bridged the gap needed to keep the icon name Lionel going.  It also started the early trend of "operating" trains instead of just "collecting" and watching post war trains accumulating dust on shelves.  There will always be good memories and a special place in my heart for MPC.

 

I agree with both observations.  Had it not been for MPC, I likely would not even have gotten back into the O gauge segment of the hobby.

 

I also was living in Hawaii at the time.  Received Ron Hollander's "All Aboard" book as a Christmas gift and the very next day drove over to Honolulu Trains & Hobby where I spent a good amount of money on Lionel (MPC) trains, track, and accessories.  All the things I bought back in those days performed just fine, and I haven't looked back since then.

 

It was a most important era in Lionel production and in the O gauge hobby.  Perhaps the MOST important era in terms of perpetuating this segment.

Last edited by Allan Miller

Sadly, I missed the MPC era.  Grew up with Lionel trains in the 50's and 60's and loved playing with them.  Graduated from HS in 70 and had to concentrate on getting the college degree, followed getting a job, marriage and having 3 kids in 4 1/2 years.  When I decided it was time to get back to trains by having a train around the Christmas tree for the kids, it was 1984 and the Richard Kughn era was beginning.  Because of how things worked out, I do not have any sentimental attachment to Lionel trains of that era.

Originally Posted by Tiffany:
How good were the MPC 8206 Hudson ? Did they ever come as a set ?

Excellent runners except for one batch that had off-centered driver wheels.  They were 2055/2065/665 clones mechanically, with Baldwin Disc wheels(1st used since 1949) as MagneTraction was not a feature.  They are good pullers due to the weight and rubber tire traction.

 

They had the first Lionel electronic whistles.

 

The 8206 headed the 1972 Service Station set.

Originally Posted by dandeo50:

I really like the MPC Standard 0 box cars especially they way the are painted,

I also converted some MPC engines to magnatraction by simply replacing the trucks

with post war trucks. My last conversion was a MPC Virginian electric that runs as well as it's post war counterpart at a fraction of the cost.

Where do you get your trucks? I have been debating this for years with a Preamble F3.

Originally Posted by nyc5340:
Originally Posted by dandeo50:

I really like the MPC Standard 0 box cars especially they way the are painted,

I also converted some MPC engines to magnatraction by simply replacing the trucks with post war trucks. My last conversion was a MPC Virginian electric that runs as well as it's post war counterpart at a fraction of the cost.

Where do you get your trucks? I have been debating this for years with a Preamble F3.

I've got an MPC Virginian Rectifier, too, and I have the same idea in mind.  Where do you get your trucks?

 

Originally Posted by nyc5340:
Originally Posted by dandeo50:

I really like the MPC Standard 0 box cars especially they way the are painted,

I also converted some MPC engines to magnatraction by simply replacing the trucks

with post war trucks. My last conversion was a MPC Virginian electric that runs as well as it's post war counterpart at a fraction of the cost.

Where do you get your trucks? I have been debating this for years with a Preamble F3.

ON the Auction site unfortunately

Recently, I picked up several MPC sets from th early 1970s, and in Mint condition: Cannonball Freight, Thunderball Freight, Kickapoo Valley Freight, Blue Streak Freight. The most I paid for one was $195. I haven't got the Blue Streak yet (waiting for delivery), but the others ran fine right out of the box after sitting idle for 40 years. And they look neat and are fun to watch run.

Two MPC themes kept me occupied back in the early to mid- '70s and made me take my eye off PostWar (at least for awhile):

 

1.  The 9800 Series plug-door reefer cars (and the 9800s only).  Just gorgeous and a brilliant move by Lionel in '72 as those cars (plus the Standard O) took the hobby in a new direction.  I was able to gather together all those reefers, plus variations.  Some of my favorite toy trains...ever.

 

2.  The original Bicentennial trains made from ~'74 -'78 or so.  Locs, cars, caboose.  FAN-tastic.

Originally Posted by Tiffany:

Hello guys and gals..........

 

How good were the MPC 8206 Hudson ? Did they ever come as a set ?

 

the woman who loves the S.F.5011,2678

Tiffany

 

Beware the Lionel 8206 Hudson steam engine.I bought one in the late 1980s when they were at their price peak.The engine wobbled badly.I read over the years that they were all like that.My Dad actually bought me one when I was a kid and returned it right away because of the bad wheels.I ended up buying a postwar chassis that ran smooth,a Berkshire boiler front,and a Lionel Railsounds tender for my 8206.The only thing left from my 8206 is the shell.The reworked engine is in the video above.

Dan

I swapped out the trucks in my MPC Pennsy green and tuscan F3's with later Magnetraction version Lionel F3 trucks.  Also swapped out the 8753 and 8850 GG1 chassis with later Lionel G chassis.  Changed the trucks to uncoupling trucks on my PRR Broadway Limited set and added a Lionel electronic reverse unit to the New Englander plastic bodied 2-6-4 K4 type steamer.

 

I repaired for a dealer/service station in Fayetteville, NC while I was stationed at Bragg.  Got the parts direct from Lionel at 50% off because of it so the cost wasn't too bad.

 

Those changes didn't absolutely need to be done but did improve things.

Originally Posted by Johnsgg1:

 added a Lionel electronic reverse unit to the New Englander plastic bodied 2-6-4 K4 type steamer.

 

 

Johnsgg1 - Were you able to fit the electronic reverse unit in the loco itself ?

I have an 8001 Plastic K4 that I would like to do this with.

 

 

8001

Attachments

Images (1)
  • 8001
Last edited by ed h

A number of folks have asked about swapping Magnetraction trucks under MPC F3s. I did exactly this with a truck I bought from Olsen's Toy Train Parts. I can say that the improvement is not huge, as the MPC F3 trucks, in my experience, are pretty good.

 

The problematic trucks (again, in my experience) are found under GPs, switchers and 4-axle U-boats. The gears are a mix of plastic and metal and the whole geartrain seemed to have too much play in it. Years of use can make it worse. This is why my beloved 8654 now rides an LTI chassis that uses the postwar F3-style truck/motor. Yes, it's MT, but the real improvement is from the more robust gears and bearings.

 

If your MPC is a Rectifier or F3, IMO, I'm not sure that a truck swap is worth the trouble.

Last edited by Alan P

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×