Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

boin106,

 

I'm really glad that Sasquatch replied to your post. He and I have access to two of the absolute FINEST custom painter/weatherer guys in the entire midwest. Since both guys who do the weathering work off prototype photos of the specific locomotives that are to be weathered, the end result is stunning. As someone who has worked in the "steam locomotive" business for more than 50 years, I pretty well know just what gets dirty/greasy and mineral deposits covered on the real thing. 

 

There are great differences in just what "gets dirty" between many different railroads, and the water quality they used. Many differences in coal quality also made noticeable differences in "weathering", and of course you model the Southern Pacific which used oil as fuel, which also made visual differences.

 

Hope things work out for with Sasquatch.

Originally Posted by Hot Water:

boin106,

 

I'm really glad that Sasquatch replied to your post. He and I have access to two of the absolute FINEST custom painter/weatherer guys in the entire midwest. Since both guys who do the weathering work off prototype photos of the specific locomotives that are to be weathered, the end result is stunning. As someone who has worked in the "steam locomotive" business for more than 50 years, I pretty well know just what gets dirty/greasy and mineral deposits covered on the real thing. 

 

There are great differences in just what "gets dirty" between many different railroads, and the water quality they used. Many differences in coal quality also made noticeable differences in "weathering", and of course you model the Southern Pacific which used oil as fuel, which also made visual differences.

 

Hope things work out for with Sasquatch.

I too would be interested, but why are YOUR two finest painters such a top secret? Wouldn't it serve them well to simply post there info here on the forum? 

Originally Posted by Nicko McBrain:

I too would be interested, but why are YOUR two finest painters such a top secret? Wouldn't it serve them well to simply post there info here on the forum? 

I am not at liberty to divulge, nor offer their services, without THEM coming on line and doing such. Both guys do work for themselves & friends, and may not want to be overwhelmed. No "top secret" about it, just simple business curtesy. 
 

I am with Allan.  Anybody who says they can weather a locomotive for under $200 as a business is going to go broke and starve to death.  I bet their buddy does it as a favor or a hobby, and that is why he does not advertise.

 

You need powdered chalk, a jar of dullcote and appropriate thinner, an airbrush, and some Floquil weathered black.

 

Chalk wipes off - you can have some fun at no risk.  Dullcote fixes it, but also diminishes its effect.

 

All opinion.

I bet their buddy does it as a favor or a hobby, and that is why he does not advertise.


While you maybe right, there is an ac-9 on eBay right now for 2300 that looks like its on a familiar layout. Though it has some other mods, I picked my stock ac-9 up for around 800. Either the mods cost a lot more than I suspect or someone is not just weathering trains for beer and pizza. Now will he get 2300$? That remains to be seen. If you would care to have your friend contact me I will surely keep it confidential. Gregj410@yahoo.com
Originally Posted by Allan Miller:

Do it yourself.  Norm Charbonneau shows you how in a bonus section in TM Books & Video's Hi-Rail Layouts, Part 4.  The results he achieves look great!

Not to take food (money) from the pro's....but try it....you'll like it.

This is my first loco I weathered. I'd done 8-10 cars but just jumped in on this loco. A little scary...but I am really happy with it. I followed Rich's Black Diamond DVD II instructions.

Originally Posted by bob2:

Anybody who says they can weather a locomotive for under $200 as a business is going to go broke and starve to death.  I bet their buddy does it as a favor or a hobby, and that is why he does not advertise.

 

You need powdered chalk, a jar of dullcote and appropriate thinner, an airbrush, and some Floquil weathered black.

 

Chalk wipes off - you can have some fun at no risk.  Dullcote fixes it, but also diminishes its effect.

 

All opinion.

I agree. I also think $200 for a professional quality, prototypical weathering job is a bargain. I don't mind messing around with my inexpensive locos, but when the time comes to have my MT-5 weathered I'm going to pay the price to have it done professionally. "Maybe" I could do an OK job myself but I'm not willing to risk screwing up a $2K locomotive just so I can say I did it myself.

 

Cheers,

Ken

I'm in the "do it yourself" camp.   

 

Start with chalks on less expensive cars.   Work your way on those until you are happy with your results.   Then move to a lessor detailed engine etc etc.   Saving the expensive, highly detailed stuff for last.

 

The thing I like about chalks is if you are totally unhappy with it you can wash them off.   Once I am happy with how it looks I spray it with dull coat.   This makes the chalks more of a forever thing.  Until the dull coat spray you can undo it.

Matt, before you commit to a painter I'd suggest seeing samples of his/her work. Everyone has a different opinion of what is good weathering. I would try and get as many photographs, color preferably, of the prototype you can find to work off of. Also if you are weathering steam the weathering would vary by type of service and era. Crack passenger locos in the '30s were cleaned regularly. By the '50s most had signs of neglect. 

 

Pete

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×