Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Jim Kelly-Evans posted:

Real live tinplate...My husband and I traveled on the Orient Express from Berlin to London last year. The beautiful, restored cars date from the 20s and 30s, and of course they were the prototypes for tinplate cars made by Marklin and others. It was the train trip of a lifetime!

 

 

Wow Jim! Thanks for sharing. That is very elegant. You and your husband look very dapper at dinner!

George

American Flyer Set #16 - ca 1919

  Flyer's set #16 was featured in the catalogs over a number of years and underwent a number of changes with respect to engine type, tender type, and car lithography.  In 1918 Flyer featured Set #16 on the cover

1918_Set16

  A close examination of the cover indicates the cars carry the Union Pacific  herald.

  The set below resembles the 1918 cover in many respects save one - the tender.

1919_AF_Set_16

According the Greenberg guide the tender with "No. 120" on the sides and ends was not offered until 1919.  Given that the set matches the 1918 cover in all other aspects my guess is that it is from 1919 or 1920.

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 1918_Set16
  • 1919_AF_Set_16

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

I have been trying to figure out why the #607 caboose for the Narrow Gauge freight cars is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the 607 eight-wheel caboose appeared in the 1928 catalog.  It was not included in any sets, but was only available as an extra car. That explains its scarcity. I wonder if that was true in other years as well.  I am looking for two examples; one with journals and one without, both with black trucks

Have a Great Tinplate Weekend

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Last edited by Greg J. Turinetti
Greg J. Turinetti posted:

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

I have been trying to figure out why the caboose for this segment of the O gauge line is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the caboose was never included in any sets, but was a separate sale item.  That explains its scarcity, but it seems odd considering how plentiful cabooses are for other manufacturers.

Have a Great Tinplate Weekend

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Greg, all freight sets I have came with a caboose. Some are 8 wheel, some are 4 wheel.

Steve

Steve "Papa" Eastman posted:
Greg J. Turinetti posted:

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

I have been trying to figure out why the caboose for this segment of the O gauge line is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the caboose was never included in any sets, but was a separate sale item.  That explains its scarcity, but it seems odd considering how plentiful cabooses are for other manufacturers.

Have a Great Tinplate Weekend

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Greg, all freight sets I have came with a caboose. Some are 8 wheel, some are 4 wheel.

Steve

Thanks for the response Steve.  Somehow the thoughts in my head did not make it accurately to my typing fingers .  This is what I really meant to say.

I have been trying to figure out why the #607 caboose for the Narrow Gauge freight cars is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the 607 eight-wheel caboose appeared in the 1928 catalog.  It was not included in any sets, but was only available as an extra car. That explains its scarcity. I wonder if that was true in other years as well.  I am looking for two examples; one with brass journals and one without, both with black trucks.

I corrected the original post.

Greg

Greg J. Turinetti posted:
Steve "Papa" Eastman posted:
Greg J. Turinetti posted:

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

I have been trying to figure out why the caboose for this segment of the O gauge line is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the caboose was never included in any sets, but was a separate sale item.  That explains its scarcity, but it seems odd considering how plentiful cabooses are for other manufacturers.

Have a Great Tinplate Weekend

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Greg, all freight sets I have came with a caboose. Some are 8 wheel, some are 4 wheel.

Steve

Thanks for the response Steve.  Somehow the thoughts in my head did not make it accurately to my typing fingers .  This is what I really meant to say.

I have been trying to figure out why the #607 caboose for the Narrow Gauge freight cars is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the 607 eight-wheel caboose appeared in the 1928 catalog.  It was not included in any sets, but was only available as an extra car. That explains its scarcity. I wonder if that was true in other years as well.  I am looking for two examples; one with brass journals and one without, both with black trucks.

I corrected the original post.

Greg

99E98C77-9837-480A-BFB2-1EA4CA6BF08287A91D7D-0495-418C-B8BB-6E3587936887

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 99E98C77-9837-480A-BFB2-1EA4CA6BF082
  • 87A91D7D-0495-418C-B8BB-6E3587936887
 
Steve "Papa" Eastman posted:
Greg J. Turinetti posted:
Steve "Papa" Eastman posted:
Greg J. Turinetti posted:

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

I have been trying to figure out why the caboose for this segment of the O gauge line is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the caboose was never included in any sets, but was a separate sale item.  That explains its scarcity, but it seems odd considering how plentiful cabooses are for other manufacturers.

Have a Great Tinplate Weekend

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

Greg, all freight sets I have came with a caboose. Some are 8 wheel, some are 4 wheel.

Steve

Thanks for the response Steve.  Somehow the thoughts in my head did not make it accurately to my typing fingers .  This is what I really meant to say.

I have been trying to figure out why the #607 caboose for the Narrow Gauge freight cars is so difficult to find.  I read in one resource that the 607 eight-wheel caboose appeared in the 1928 catalog.  It was not included in any sets, but was only available as an extra car. That explains its scarcity. I wonder if that was true in other years as well.  I am looking for two examples; one with brass journals and one without, both with black trucks.

I corrected the original post.

Greg

99E98C77-9837-480A-BFB2-1EA4CA6BF08287A91D7D-0495-418C-B8BB-6E3587936887

Wow!

George

Robert S. Butler posted:

American Flyer Set #16 - ca 1919

  Flyer's set #16 was featured in the catalogs over a number of years and underwent a number of changes with respect to engine type, tender type, and car lithography.  In 1918 Flyer featured Set #16 on the cover

1918_Set16

  A close examination of the cover indicates the cars carry the Union Pacific  herald.

  The set below resembles the 1918 cover in many respects save one - the tender.

1919_AF_Set_16

According the Greenberg guide the tender with "No. 120" on the sides and ends was not offered until 1919.  Given that the set matches the 1918 cover in all other aspects my guess is that it is from 1919 or 1920.

i'm feeling young these days hanging out around all these 100 year olds...

some variations...

Type V locomotive w/ 8 spoke drivers...

Flyer Type V loco

white lettered versions...

Flyer UP cars

cheers...gary

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Flyer Type V loco
  • Flyer UP cars
overlandflyer posted:
George S posted:

How did you do that?

George

or did you mean this...

smoker 01
tissue paper... semi-shaped.

smoker 02
move back and forth for the first few seconds, then pull away quickly.  thin smoke, ~15% of the exposure time; thicker smoke, up to 45-50% of the exposure time.  experiment... it doesn't always turn out great.

smoker 3

=====+++=====

AF481-07-w.smoke

fun stuff!
cheers...gary

 

...But when it does work, it looks great! 

Tom 

Greg J. Turinetti posted:

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

...  I am looking for two examples; one with journals and one without, both with black trucks.

brass journals or steel journals...?

Dorfan 607 caboose

i'm always suspicious of Dorfan cars with near perfect roofs.  if it is a repaint, this one certainly deserves it, though.  98% of the litho is C7+

Dorfan 607 caboose 02

missing an end rail and a bit more "weathered", the brass cupola is another slight variation.

another car variation besides the trucks (deluxe sets - with journal boxes; standard sets without), there were brass and black hardware details.

Dorfan PRR boxcar types
ladders were only on one side of the boxcars.

cheers...gary

 

Attachments

Images (3)
  • Dorfan 607 caboose 02
  • Dorfan 607 caboose
  • Dorfan PRR boxcar types
overlandflyer posted:
Greg J. Turinetti posted:

The Dorfan portion of the collection continues to expand.

...  I am looking for two examples; one with journals and one without, both with black trucks.

brass journals or steel journals...?

Dorfan 607 caboose

 

cheers...gary

 

Gary,

Brass journals.  I have been working on finding the cars with brass journals.  

This was supposed to be an endeavor to add some representative pieces of Dorfan to the collection.  I can see I have already started down a slippery slope.  

Northwoods Flyer

Greg

I finished a multi-weekend project today!  I re-wheeled and tuned up the last two of these engines.  Over the past 6 weeks or so, I have been working on re-wheeling and tuning up (new springs, brushes, headlight holders, headlights, wiring) these engines and making them run like they should.  

The paint on all of these engines, is factory original...even the blue 3116 and orange 3110.

 

NWL

overlandflyer posted:
George S posted:

How did you do that?

George

or did you mean this...

smoker 01
tissue paper... semi-shaped.

smoker 02
move back and forth for the first few seconds, then pull away quickly.  thin smoke, ~15% of the exposure time; thicker smoke, up to 45-50% of the exposure time.  experiment... it doesn't always turn out great.

smoker 3

=====+++=====

AF481-07-w.smoke

fun stuff!
cheers...gary

 

Hey now, that's a lot more smoke than the 4014 was just blowing!!  

Greg J. Turinetti posted:

 

Gary,

Brass journals.  I have been working on finding the cars with brass journals.  

This was supposed to be an endeavor to add some representative pieces of Dorfan to the collection.  I can see I have already started down a slippery slope.  

you're actually not that far from the bottom... aside from the caboose, of course, which would be a big hurdle.  i'd rate the log car as one of the hardest and the wrecker, next in line... especially if its a functioning car.  i see one of the boxcars up for sale every so often.

i've adapted a Lionel 258 to pull my narrow gauge Dorfan as i have no Dorfan locomotives that run (and only two that don't & never will without a lot of shop time).

good luck...gary

Last edited by overlandflyer

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×