Skip to main content

Earlier today, in a post on the 3-Rail Forum, someone asked why The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition is necessary since DCS already came with its own DCS User Guide.

 

I responded with a list of all of the differences between the two documents, and included a viewable/downloadable pdf of the book's Table of Contents and Table of Figures, so that prospective purchasers of the book would have an idea as regards its contents. Upon reflection, it occurred to me that it might be a good idea to repost my response on the DCS Forum, where it would be easier for DCS newbies to see.

 

For those of you who already have the book, feel free to post your impressions of the book on this thread.

 

The DCS manual covers less than 50% of DCS as compared to The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition.

 

The DCS manual is 119 pages in a 5" X 7" format while The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition is 215 pages in an 8" X 10" format,and the font size is about the same.

 

The DCS mania; is black and white while The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition is full-color.

 

The DCS manual is a very basic guide that pretty much states what pressing each button on the remote does. The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition is set up as both a tutorial as well as a reference manual which explains not only what buttons do what, it also discusses why things work the way they do.

 

The DCS manual discusses MTH engine operation via the remote acceptably enough to get someone started using DCS. TMCC is discussed in a couple of pages. It does not discuss AIU operation, switch tracks or accessories at all.

 

The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition discusses everything in-depth, and also discusses how to connect Lionel command bases (both TMCC and Legacy) separately or together; use of the AIU to operate switch tracks and accessories; and connecting switch tracks and accessories from both MTH and other manufacturers.

 

With thee exception of a couple of simple wire to track connection diagrams, the DCS manual's pictures are solely those of greyscale DCS Remote screens. The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition has 64 figures, many in full color, that actually illustrate how to do things, as well as 10 Appendices tag provide reference material that does't exist elsewhere.

 

The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition include sections on the DCS Commander and DCS Remote Commander. The DCS manual does not.

 

I've attached a table of contents and a table of figures to this post. Feel free to download them and peruse them to see what makes this book unique.

 

Hopefully, this will allow potential potential purchasers of there book to determine its usefulness.  

 

 

Everything that you need to know about DCS is all in the “The DCS O Gauge Companion 2nd Edition", available for purchase from many fine OGR advertisers and forum sponsors, or as an eBook or a printed book at MTH's web store!

 
 

Attachments

Last edited by Barry Broskowitz
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Get the DCS O Gauge Companion (aka 'Barry's Book' around here). Get the printed copy. Read it from cover to cover (more than once if you wish). Place it near your DCS command center for easy reference thereafter. You will then understand the entire DCS system, it's wiring and it's operation to the fullest extent possible. This will be the best investment you make in your DCS system, next to purchasing the system itself.

Barry's book is the source he has taken the system and gone above and beyond what MTH has provided in the basic instructional manuals and beta tested the system on his own RR giving insights on ways to run a RR in the command environment to give all of us the best experience to run our RR's. And we should also thank folks like Marty Fitzhenry as well!

 It's like the difference between a car's owner's manual and a Chilton's guide.

 The DCS manual shows you the buttons. The DCS Companion, helps you use them fully.

I guess if you were just running a small loop and didn't need all the features, you may not understand. As your layout grows, and you need to explore all the benefits, the Companion will be a trusty guide threw it all.

 I've been following this forum for years and look at all these posts. I still go back to the Companion when I add new stuff. There's just too much to remember.

Engineer-Joe makes a really good analogy.  There is no comparison between the DCS user guide and Barry's DCS Companion Book.  

 

Just buy the book and save yourself a lot of trouble and questions.  Unlike many other how-to books that seem to have more useless filler info than useful info the DCS Companion is packed with good info beginning to end. You won't be sorry?

 

I bought the book a few years ago and every time I lookup something I find something else I didn't know DCS could do.

 

Ed

Read it from cover to cover (more than once if you wish).

I never could.  For one thing, I wouldn't remember everything. For another, there are subjects about which I have no interest. But, it is a complete reference manual.  I have both the printed and Acrobat versions; the latter has the advantage of being word searchable.

 

It is not necessary to buy it to set up and enjoy DCS.  If you're setting up a simple loop for smaller kids, and yourself have no interest in trains or their operation, probably not needed.  But if you have any interest in going beyond the basics, or conclude that the kids would benefit from knowing more about the control system they're using, it's worth the price.

 

I agree with Engr Joe's analogy. (Actually, I never liked the Chilton's manuals.  I preferred the car makers Shop Manual that had more detail.)

Last edited by RJR

Good morning and happy Labor Day everyone!!!!!

 

Although I do not have many issues with the DCS system on my layout when something out of the ordinary does shows up I reach for Barry's DCS Manual.

 

What I like about this manual is the fact it is written in simple terms that you can understand without being an electrical expert or engineer.

 

Great job Barry, and thank you !!!!!!

Gentlemen,

    Anyone asking this kind of question has not set up many DCS/Legacy controlled layouts.  Most all experienced DCS runners can tell you that Barry's detailed engineering instruction has no equal in our hobby.  His technical writing is top shelf, having done lots of it myself for NASA I have commended him in the past very highly for his great technical writing, it's an art in itself.  His attention to detail is top self engineering instruction. The only thing that could improve on his technical writing, is if he would also put his DCS book in video instruction form, for those who need it, a massive undertaking for sure. However Rich Melvin does a great job in the OGR Video Guide to DCS, for the beginner, I can only imagine the job Barry could do, with his own DCS engineering material, in a Video format.  IMO you should own and use both.

PCRR/Dave 

DSCN1127

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN1127

Barry's Book ! ... As a senior I would discribe it as the old saying .." best thing since sliced bread " ... It is one of those things that come along in life that when you get it, you wounder how you lived with out it !  .. Well written and organised ...I too will buy both the hard copy and the digital version .. and would pay twice the price. I believe the MTH DCS is a major contribution to saving our hobby.Hopeing the Wi Fi will ship soon.. it just keeps getting better and better.  : )

BUY the book.

The book (rel 2) saved me $169.95 cost of a new TIU. I replaced 2 20Amp auto fuses ($1.99) that I did not know were in the TIU.

I'll be buying the Digital version to have on MY MACBookAir.

I've used DCS for over 10 years.  Once I get a USB to RS232 converter, I'll try to upgrade my Ver I3 unit. I'll use an old HP laptop running Vista. 

Thanks Barry once again.

 

Last edited by decoynh

To order the DCS Companion 3rd Edition Book from MTH, do the following.

 

1) Call MTH - Either Sales of the Railroaders Club option.

2) The pre-order the print copy is $38.95 before October 20th, 2015.

3) The book will become available, if I remember right, sometime in early

      November 2015.

4) The download copy will be available in November from the MTH online store for

     $14.95.

 

Thank You Again, Mr. Broskowitz for your efforts in creating this priceless publication..

As a conventional runner and only around the Christmas holidays I was reluctant to move to DCS  however after having my local hobby shop and OGR Forumites talk me into it I purchased it. and immediately began to run into Trouble getting it to work.  Marty Fitzhenry worked with me and Also suggested Barry's book to which i purchased.  it was night and day within a few minutes of getting the Digital edition of the book i was able to have a temporary layout up and running without problems.  The companion fills in a lot of blanks that the original documentation left blank.  Also I was able to hear the freight sounds on a ps2.0 locomotive that i have never heard since i purchased the set in early 2000 it was incredible.  I want to personally thank Barry for his kindness and generousity in helping all of us out here on the forum and providing this book so that we can enjoy and run MTH's DCS System.    

Also it was Barry's book and me running my layout that convinced a friend of mine to upgrade from Conventional Control to DCS.

We all see trains we gotta have.  If you're running DCS, Barry's book is a gotta have.  DCS is so complicated and can do so much, the book, and Barry himself have solved many of my issues running two large layouts with two TIU's, six MTH engines, three LCP's and three conventionals.  

Agree.  Just buy it.

Jerry

Sarcasm?  Nah.  I'm just surprised that you would think OGR would send you to a fake site to get a book that they are advertising.  Besides since I've ordered a copy via that same link I didn't really have to fact check...I knew the fact and just the facts.

Didn't mean to get you upset.  My apologies. I hope the rest of your day is less stressful.

Last edited by MartyE

Sarcasm? Yeah, point is OGR doesn't run that site, nor do they have control over orders that are placed on it, nor are they able to see the status of orders from it, nor do they have anyway to check if orders are being satisfied.....its a legitimate concern when they claim to be selling it but then send you to a different site to order instead of their own store....I simply stated I hope it isn't a broken link or a scam site, thats simply all....its a legitimate red flag when one site claims to be taking orders for it when in reality they aren't 

Add Reply

Post
The DCS Forum is sponsored by
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×