Skip to main content

I just purchased a used Santa Fe Alco PA A-A set from a hobby store today. After driving home two hours I found that the engine will only (somewhat) operate after pushing the unit forward some distance. Once the engine is up to speed it seems to run fine until stopped. While the engine picks up speed my Lionel CW-80 blinks like there is a short. After doing a thorough cleaning and lube, the engine still works sporadically. 

 

while cleaning the underside of the engine I noticed that the rear wheels begin spinning much sooner the front wheels. Can the dual motors get out of sync? Or could the motor in the front of the unit be worn to the point that the engine is binding up, causing my transformer to think there is a short.  

 

Please if anyone might have an idea about what may be wrong let me know. I'd rather not drive two hours back to the store if I can fix it myself, but i guess serves me right for not having the store demonstrate to me that the used set works! 

 

Chris

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Chris check your motor mounts. I just had to replace the rear motor on my williams GP38 engine that burn up and when i put the new motor in that motor turn tight too. I was lucky when williams sent me a new motor the motor mount was with it and i used it. It took care of the problem.  Also make sure you grease the gears well and make sure you don't have a broken wire on the pick up not getting power to that motor.  

Williams motors don't get out of sync as they are electrically connected to the circuit board, unless your circuit board is bad.

Like others have mentioned check the wires to the motors and then check each motor by itself for electrical operation.

You may have a motor not mounted properly or loose. After assembly of the motors and wheelsets check that the motor can turn the wheelset by spinning the top side of the motor by hand.  Also check for lube on the gears that turn the wheels.

 

Lee Fritz

1 - A loose (rather than tight) truck/motor mounting screw can also bind things up - not uncommon on Wms locos, which are often assembled a bit casually. The truck spur gear drops away from the motor worm gear. Fixed one this summer with that same problem.

 

2 - Had another Wms diesel a few years ago (a friend's) with a variation on this, same

result: the big truck/motor mounting was fine - but the 2 small screws inside that actually

attach the motor to that truck mounting piece were both loose. So the worm and spur were trying to separate...binding in reverse only (don't you love it?). 

 

Loco #2 was a factory-fresh, out of the box new unit. #1 had had "body work", but no

mechanical fiddling.

Last edited by D500

Sounds like the trouble I had.  I found on my Alco the gear as slipping around the axle right where it is in the grease box.  You have to take it apart, tap the axle out, crimp the axle and slide the gear back on.  OR, take it o the next York meet in the Orange hall back against the wall, the great guy from Harrisburg who deals in Williams etc, and he will fix it VERY reasonable. I am sorry I forgot his name but he is a GREAT guy!!

Thanks for the quick responses everyone.  I looked over the motor mounts and couldn't find anything obviously wrong.  I started to think about the transformer I was using. After putting another Williams engine, a GP9, on the track I found that that engine was behaving the same way as the Alco. 

 

The problem ended up being the CW80 transformer I was using. After swapping out the transformer for a newer CW80 the engine runs great!  I read that some people have had problems with some generations of the CW80. I must have one of those troublesome transformers.  

 

Chris

Origin

 

The problem ended up being the CW80 transformer I was using. After swapping out the transformer for a newer CW80 the engine runs great!  I read that some people have had problems with some generations of the CW80. I must have one of those troublesome transformers.  

 

Chris

I have not used a CW-80 with any of my trains. So I would not have suspected the CW-80 as being the culprit in your case. The first production run of CW-80's were said to have problems, maybe that is what you have.

 

I use the MTH Z-1000 or the post war ZW or KW with my Williams engines and have no problems with them.

 

Lee Fritz

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×