Skip to main content

My wife has become enthusiastic about making a more elaborate Christmas Tree train layout for 2018.

We recently saw a display of "Dept 56" buildings and there were a few that she thought would go well with our holiday train layout. One building in particular that we both agreed on was the 'Snow Village 56th St. Brewery'.

We are visiting family until the 30th so it's not easy for me to take a piece of rolling stock to the 'Dept 56" display to get an idea of size.

My question is- does anyone have an idea what scale the "Dept 56" buildings are and does anyone have an opinion if they would work well for an 'Under the tree' layout?

We are not rivet counters and if the buildings are slightly larger or smaller than Traditional 'O' scale, we don't care that much.

Any opinions are appreciated. Thank you and may you all be blessed in the coming year.

Last edited by MG Brown
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Department 56 buildings aren’t made in any particular scale. And there are so many different villages — Original Snow Village, Christmas in the City, Alpine Village, Dickens Village, New England Village, North Pole Series and the various licensed villages like Peanuts and Disney — that you really can’t generalize about size, or, for that matter, what will work best fo you.

So my best advice is to simply to do what you want.

I have plenty of Department 56 buildings, though not nearly as many as serious collectors. Personally, for traditional-sized O gauge trains and Christmas charm, I prefer the Original Snow Village. The snow village tends to be a bit larger than other village buildings and fits in with the smallish Lionel or MTH RailKing trains that also are undersized.

I also like Christmas in the City, but those structures are often scaled way down from real buildings. So the Empire State Building isn’t anywhere near O scale. But other buildings in the series are.

Basically, don’t worry about scale. Choose what you like and decide for yourself what looks good in your village.

Last edited by Jim R.

I use a mix of Lemax, Dept56, Walmart. Anything that looks good. My favorites in Dept56 are also Snow Village and Christmas in the City along with their movie theme collections. As for the Dept56 skyscrapers, those look really nice at the back end of a layout with some sort of divider between the track and the buildings to add some depth perception. Really wish I could afford some of those, they are really nice.

As Jim R. notes, though not to any scale in particular, the village pieces are very festive and look great under the tree with O/O-27 Trains.  Like RICKA states, there are several variations available. We buy what we like and have a blend of several different series and makes. I’ve attached a short clip from our 2017 layout. However, the best show is at night with only the tree lights and the village lights on with the trains running. 

1357E13E-8938-4B00-B457-CD3997563458

ABEEA9BC-D9DA-4A4B-AED3-EAAE80C50627

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 1357E13E-8938-4B00-B457-CD3997563458
  • ABEEA9BC-D9DA-4A4B-AED3-EAAE80C50627
Videos (1)
F816FFF2-EEBF-4085-92B6-6303694E4512

Department 56 ceramic buildings are ideal for Christmas layouts and as several folks said they vary in "scale". They are a bit more costly and some of the "retired" building go for nose-bleed prices. You might take a look at the wide variety of Lemax buildings which are lower priced. In your shopping, you may come across K-Line Christmas buildings which were made by Lemax. Department 56 & Lemax have websites and there are year-around internet sellers of both brands. The last quarter of the year is the big selling season. I have purchased both major brands at pop-up mall stores, major tool chains such as Home Depot, department stores, fabric/craft stores, drug stores and even a garden/plant store. Happy shopping and please post pictures of your successful search.

Tony

Up on "The D & H Bridge Line"

 

For comparison, here are (1)three Lemax buildings along with Lemax carolers.  The people are too big even for their own buildings.  (2)The depot is a Woodland Scenics building with O scale figures.  The buildings are different, but no-one has made comment about the size match.  (These were taken in the work area before display)

C7269AEA-E2B7-4D3E-A14E-CF8BD7162E29

BB9C85BD-24BD-48CE-BC6F-0A048B01881E

3228FFA7-20A3-4983-906B-35E57135B6A7

 

Attachments

Images (3)
  • C7269AEA-E2B7-4D3E-A14E-CF8BD7162E29
  • BB9C85BD-24BD-48CE-BC6F-0A048B01881E
  • 3228FFA7-20A3-4983-906B-35E57135B6A7
DL&W Pete posted:

I have a complete Kohls St. Nicholas Square village buildings, I went back to HO so I no longer use them. If interested send me a email and I will send you a complete list of what I have.

My layout uses the Kohls St. Nicholas Square buildings if someone want to get an idea of the "details" that DL&W is offering...

Less costly than the Dept 56 items... a lot less costly!

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×