Skip to main content

Forgive me if this is the wrong place to post this, but I don't know of anywhere else to put it. 
I've been looking at getting a 3rd Rail FL9 non powered locomotive for my collection, but the only one they have is the 2 rail version. 
If I want to run it on my layout I'll need to add highrail wheels and O Gauge couplers to it..but what I need to know is is this possible? 
If not then I guess I could just use it for display, but in a perfect world I would be able to get it to run in a kind of "Streamliners at Spencer" themed train. 
Anyone have any ideas? 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Stirling R. Callahan:

Forgive me if this is the wrong place to post this, but I don't know of anywhere else to put it. 
I've been looking at getting a 3rd Rail FL9 non powered locomotive for my collection, but the only one they have is the 2 rail version. 
If I want to run it on my layout I'll need to add highrail wheels and O Gauge couplers to it..but what I need to know is is this possible? 
If not then I guess I could just use it for display, but in a perfect world I would be able to get it to run in a kind of "Streamliners at Spencer" themed train. 
Anyone have any ideas? 

Although I have no personal experience with them, MTH 2-3 rail locos run just fine with 2-rail flanges on the AGHR O-72 min radii and Ross switches. Matt Jackson, our principal addict, could chime in here.

 

1 - if you have GG, Atlas or MTH track (either kind) you do not have to change the trucks as all those track types have essentially prototypically flat or near-flat top rails. "Two-Rail" wheels with the smaller (still not scale) flanges and narrower wheel treads like it just fine.

GG 2-rail O-scale track (yes, they make it) uses the same running rails as 3-rail-O.

 

2 - switches will be an issue, though. The small flanges and narrow treads will fall into the Hi-Rail flange ways. The 3-axle truck my handle them well, but the leading 2-axle may (will) have a switch tracking issue.

 

3 - use a portion of your layout with few, if any, switches, for the loco, if possible.

 

4 - power - tether a 3-rail passenger car "permanently" behind the loco to pass power to the FL9. You can use a rectifier to send DC instead of AC to the loco, if that is what it expects. Is this a straight-DC loco? If not, send it AC from the track by way of the passenger car.

 

5 - best way: GG track (for example) is set in wood ties, so all the rails are insulated from each other unless you connect them. Don't connect the outside rails, set up a toggle switch or two to choose 2-rail or 3-rail current from the appropriate power sources, and run it as a 2-rail on the 3-rail track. The middle rail just becomes nonexistent, electrically.

You will have to use 2-rail rolling stock with insulated wheel sets, of course.

 

All of the above takes effort - not to mention your re-trucking idea - and all has been done, here and there. Maybe just wait until the 3-rail comes along?

 

Or, bash a 3-rail one out of a frame, F-unit bodies and an MTH SD-9 truck. More fun, too.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×