Skip to main content

I'm having trouble determining the difference between AtlasO 70 Ton and 100 Ton roller bearing trucks.

Here is what I have.  The box and instructions say nothing about the type and style of trucks.  It is from a Trinity 25,500 Tank Car, Item number 3005012-2

Here is the 100 Ton truck from the Atlas website.

Here is the 70 Ton truck form the Atlas website.

The only thing I can see that looks different is this piece I circled.  So I'm guessing this is a 100 Ton truck?   Does anyone else have any thoughts?

Attachments

Images (4)
  • mceclip0
  • mceclip1
  • mceclip2
  • mceclip3
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

If you have either a Maxi IV or an articulated auto carrier you can see the slight difference between the 70 ton and 100 ton trucks.  The auto carrier has 70 ton according to the Atlas website.  Those same trucks are the outboard trucks on the Maxi IV.  The inboard trucks are 100 ton.  All of the 70 ton I have show the word “Gould” on the left side of the frame in really small print.  The 100 ton side frames are slightly thicker right above the axel.  The 70 ton side frames have a small recess above the axel. The 100 ton have a small rib that protrudes in that area.  You can see that difference in the 2 pictures from Atlas.  Your original picture looks like a 100 ton.

Last edited by JFC454

I think the size of the wheel is one thing - as mentioned above.    100 ton trucks seem to have larger 36 inch wheels. vs 33 inch on most lighter cars.

A second thing you cannot see is the size of the bearings on the prototype.    I'm pretty sure the prototype 100 ton trucks had wider bearings - that is more surface for the axle to ride on.    The PRR did that when it converted X29 boxcars to express service in passenger trains.    It wasn't just for the weight which stayed the same, it was because of the higher speeds.    they also changed some things on the trucks.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×