Skip to main content

I would like to build a test track for checking out locomotives and other various powered rolling stock.  Can anyone suggest an ammeter and volt meter for such a project?  I am looking for something panel mounted.  I don't have a a strong preference but would lean towards analog displays.  If it makes any difference, I hope to use this stand to program dcs engines.

 

I am hoping to make the stand fairly quickly, so if anyone knows of a common retailer such as radioshack, that might have what I need, please let me know.

 

thanks in advance,

 

John Z

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by jhz563:

I would like to build a test track for checking out locomotives and other various powered rolling stock.  Can anyone suggest an ammeter and volt meter for such a project?  I am looking for something panel mounted.  I don't have a a strong preference but would lean towards analog displays.  If it makes any difference, I hope to use this stand to program dcs engines.

 

I am hoping to make the stand fairly quickly, so if anyone knows of a common retailer such as radioshack, that might have what I need, please let me know.

 

thanks in advance,

 

John Z

 

If you are "testing" locos and such, a digital meter is a lot more accurate than analog, but if you just want to know "approximate" measurements, then analog are fine...FYI!

Being digital is not the measure of a meters accuracy.
 
 It is only a different way of reading results.
 
Analog can actually do things digital cant, and visa versa.
 
The class is the measure of accuracy.
 
Note the class 2.5 on the "cheap" meter in Dewey's post.
That's, 2.5% of 15amp= variance.
The lower the number the more accurate it is. 2.5% isn't awful.
 
Originally Posted by Dewey Trogdon:

 

IMG_1989

 

 

John

 

I just finished a test stand recently. It was after reading lots and lots of posts from other members. It's built on copying members information.

 

One thing to point out. A lot of the guys / gals suggested to use the 0-15 AMP and the 0-20 volts gauges.

 

Mainly because we don't look for any higher readings that that and easy to read them as well.

 

Mine are from e-bay (via China) as well. Good luck with your project.

 

Larry

 

 

 

 

DSCN3954

Attachments

Images (1)
  • DSCN3954
Originally Posted by jhz563:

I am hoping to make the stand fairly quickly, so if anyone knows of a common retailer such as radioshack, that might have what I need, please let me know.

 

thanks in advance,

 

John Z


John,

You should work with Larry Sr as he's recently completed this project and did a fantastic job.  He may be able to save you some 'pit falls' as you progress.

 

Good luck, let's see it when you're done!

The sarcasm on "cheap" didn't make it through well. I saw the brand.

I think the cheap ones are more like class 5-7.

 

Selecting a scale of 15-20 amps should be plenty. Two large, broken but running post war engines, would have trouble reaching that 15 amp mark

.

And 0-15a will normally give more accuracy than one that reads 0-20+ amps.

 

 It really should be matched to read the power supplies maximum amps.

Or be fused at the meters limit if you have a very high amp supply, but only test at lower low amps, so you wish a low read meter for accuracy. (a fused meter isn't a bad idea anyhow)

I recently purchased a few toggle switches and some momentary on switches from jameco.com.  They sent a free catalog of their products.  They offer both Analog and LCD Digital Meters.  Prices ranged from $9.95 to $12.95 for analog meters and $7.95 to $14.95 for LCD Digital meters.  You might find them cheaper, but this is a starting place.

 

Not as good as panel meters, but I use a Harbor Freight Digital Multimeter.

I also have an old Radio Shack Analog meter. Cost each was about $10.

You can jump either one to the track with clip leads or leads with alligator clip ends.

One of these days I'll do a setup with panel meters so I'm saving this thread.

John Z

You can make a simple two-meter panel from 1/8" Masonite and mount it in a cheap 4x6 picture frame if you don't want to fabricate something. The barrel of most standard and inexpensive analog meters requires a 2" hole saw for mounting and four 1/8" holes for the retaining studs. 

I suggest a 0-30 VAC range for a voltmeter and 0-15 AAC for the amp meter. If you get higher range meters they don't read far enough up the scale on basic 18-20 volt and 10 amp power districts for easy viewing. Volt meters are wired across the line[parallel] , amp meters are wired inline[series]

 

A several of my old photos show the general idea....

 

IMG_1721

Meter Wiring

 

 

IMG_1991-001

Attachments

Images (3)
  • IMG_1721
  • Meter Wiring
  • IMG_1991-001
Last edited by Dewey Trogdon

I am looking for a digital version of the analog merters talked about above.  Want to add them to a Lionel zw.  Looked on line and can't find one. A 2 in 1 didital merter would be great for V & A on the same unit. Does anyone know where to pick digital meters for ac in the 0-30v & 0-10A range. 

 

Thanks,

 

rad400

Does anyone know why there are lots of DC digital panel in low voltage rating 0-30V, but all of the digital AC panel meters I find on line are in the 80 to 300V range.  The same holds true for AC amp meters. 

 

I wonder what Lionel used when they had their digital meter add on for the zw, 10 years ago.

 

rad400

My plans are to utilize an old analog Simpson 260 multimeter tied into the test track.  I wonder if not being able to instantaneously monitor both voltage and amps, without switching between the 2, has any drawbacks? 

 

Also have the same type running stands as Larry Sr.  I can see the entire workbench design and build isn't going to simply be a weekend project.  Like I need more jobs.

 

Bruce

I'd probably just get analog meters from eBay, they're plentiful in the right ranges.  Line up a matching amp and volt meter and you'll have it covered for around $10.

 

I have to say, I do what Dave does, I use a clamp-on if I want to measure current on my bench setup, I don't have to do that most of the time.  Ditto for voltage, I know pretty much what voltage is applied, I just look at the transformer.

 

I have a 2A in-line circuit breaker for the bench supply, that keeps a really bad short from cooking anything.  It's extremely rare that I'd need more than 2 amps of power for bench testing, so that isn't a problem.  I've incorporated the 2A breaker in both my PS/2 and PS/3 testsets as well, there's never a time that I can recall that either of those should need more power when testing a board.

Originally Posted by Pine Creek Railroad:

John Z,

   I use the Harbor Freight mini clamp on multi meter, for actuals on my test & Programming Track,

I see no need for building any thing with permanent meters now.

PCRR/Dave

Dave, 

  I actually have a good multimeter at home. After I started this thread I did use it to do some diagnostics.  I was initially afraid that it wouldn't work at low ac voltages but was pleasantly surprised.   I still think I will build a test bench eventually that will have meters permanently mounted.  This thread got me thinking that on my eventual finish layout I might even include some meters hiding in plain sight.  I am thinking of something like a clock tower with a volt or ammeter display. Another possibility would be a roof top bill board -think of a Reddy Kilowatt figure on a billboard that happens to i clude a working volt meter.

Anyway,  thank you for the suggestion, good luck with your projects. 

John Z.

Originally Posted by brwebster:

My plans are to utilize an old analog Simpson 260 multimeter tied into the test track.  I wonder if not being able to instantaneously monitor both voltage and amps, without switching between the 2, has any drawbacks? 

 

Also have the same type running stands as Larry Sr.  I can see the entire workbench design and build isn't going to simply be a weekend project.  Like I need more jobs.

 

Bruce

Two bits of info are better than one.

I think I'd rather monitor amperage drawn. A visual fuse if you will.

 Because we adjust voltage to suit our needs.

Unless of course, you want a more throttle orientated read then go volts.

  

I like amperage better to monitor serious changes in a device.

I like voltage to monitor a supply output.

Good diagnostics take both.

  Many controls at least have markings to indicate approximate voltages too. That leaves amps totally unknown, and without reference.

 

 

  

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×