Skip to main content

I recently aquired a locomotive near mint with a Pittman 9434. I see no signs on drivers or pickups of any running. When I broke it down for inspection and test running I noticed an unusual fore and aft play on the front shaft. Rest of locomotive was...well mint. Blind luck I had another 9434 on hand. Installed it and proceded with my project. Opened the removed motor and the oilite bearing fell out. This is the output shaft side. I test fitted the bearing and it appears too large for the end cap. Likely a size larger that correct for this motor. I'm thinking a replacement would be hard to find. So why not replace it with a ball bearing? If I measured correctly, a 4X9X2mm bearing should fit. I can't find a 2mm but 2.5 is available.  Am I on the right track with this idea? Please let me know.

Richard

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Pat, where do you get these bearings and shims?

McMaster Carr or Kimball Midwest for the shims, and those unmentionable shopping sites for the bearings …….We used to be able to buy all the parts we could ever ask for right from Charlie Pittman himself, but that’s a bygone era now ……biggest thing to remember when buying ball bearing inserts is to make sure they’re rated for electric motors,….

Pat

@Rppoind posted:

Pat....many thanks. McMaster Carr is an old favorite for me. Would you reccomend changing both ends?  I'm aware of the shims in Pittman's. I'll pay attention to end play.

Truth be told, ball bearing motors are a little overkill in our hobby. With that said, they are noticeably smoother with ball bearings. When you buy bearings from overseas suppliers, they are usually sold in packs of 10. So you’re right there, might as well complete the job……..one word of caution when converting from olite. I usually install one very thin shim between the bearing and the end bell. I’ve found in the past, the end bell’s bearing pockets can snag the inner race, thus locking up the bearing. A thin shim in the pocket cures this. Be sure your new insert is bottomed out, and square before setting up end plays. Also be sure the brush holder end bell shims position the brushes to ride center on the segments. All of these checks can be performed before putting everything back in the can…..

Pat

I am familiar with both of those motors, the F686 will not accept ball bearings, but the L187’s will accept ball bearings.

usually, the bearings are sold in packs of 10.

I’ve only been able to learn all of this stuff through trial & error ever since Ametek priced themselves right out of our lives!…😉

There’s certain casting ID numbers on the inside of the end bells, at some point, I’ll pull some parts out and give y’all the dos and donts that I’ve learned over the past few decades….

Pat  

Pat.....Ball Bearings arrived yesterday and I have shims. Trying to avoid a rookie mistake. I noted centering the brushes on the communtator with shims. Also thin shim between bearing and end bell. I can quess the oil wick for bushings is not used. Do you use the copper retainer or no? My bearings slip right in the end bells. Do the bearings require locktite or  simular?

Richard

@Rppoind posted:

Pat.....Ball Bearings arrived yesterday and I have shims. Trying to avoid a rookie mistake. I noted centering the brushes on the communtator with shims. Also thin shim between bearing and end bell. I can quess the oil wick for bushings is not used. Do you use the copper retainer or no? My bearings slip right in the end bells. Do the bearings require locktite or  simular?

Richard

Ball bearing inserts should be a very snug slip fit. Not loose,…..discard oil wick, and oil wick retainer. Do not use loctite on any bearings. Shims set bearing in place. When you’re finished, you should wind up with a very free spinning motor, with virtually no end play. A tiny tiny bit is needed, and that’s just enough so the bearing isn’t loaded …..

Pat

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×