Skip to main content

Hello friends!

I am at a crossroads right now. I'm 18 in College and I have a 24x13 U shaped layout in my basement that my Dad and I built. It's nowhere near finished but over half of it has ground cover and quite a few buildings and trees. Our family is going to be moving halfway across the US around the time I finish my first year of College in May and while the layout is built on a bunch of 4x8 sections that CAN be taken apart and moved, I'm not quite sure if I want to do that. I feel that taking it apart, moving it and rebuilding it would be too much of a hassle with little benefit. After working on it since 2010, I know that I can do so much better: using gargraves/ross or atlas track instead of O tubular, better ballasting, better wiring, etc. But on the other hand, we've invested so much money into the layout that getting rid of a lot of it and starting over seems like a stupid move. We could save all of the wood in the benchwork minus the 4x8 sheets and all of the stuff on the layout minus ground cover and ballast. So as you can see, I'm quite torn.

ANY advice would be most appreciated. I thank you all for reading. Have a great one!

-Zach

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Save what you can and want to. First projects seldom turn out the way you wish they would, so don't feel bad about ditching any elements you need to. they weren't a waste; they were tuition and lab fees.

Think about building the next one so you can take it apart. It doesn't have to be full-on modular if you don't want it to be, but built with an eye toward the next move or reconfiguration. You don't know where life will take you after college and being able to take some layout with you is a good thing.

 

--Becky

Save what you care to from it and then start over.  Consider that first layout as a sort of "learning lab" where you picked-up and fine-tuned various techniques that can be incorporated into the next layout.

 

Almost none of us have our first, or even our second, third, or fourth layouts, and each successive pike generally improves upon its forerunners as we learn new and better ways of doing things.

Hopefully college is going well for you.  You need to focus on the next three years in college.  Trains, one way or another, will always be there.  A college degree, in a good field, is extremely important.  IMO.   You may want to sell some of the train items and apply the cash to the college experience.   The least amount of debt when you graduate is to your advantage.  IMO.    

Last edited by Mike CT

Those of us who moved often during our work careers are very familiar with your situation. I have dismantled 5 layouts in various states of completion, including two recent in '08 and '09--one complete and one 75%. If you built it with screws you can save and recycle most of the lumber which is a major expense. If not abused you can even save some of the electrical components including wire.

 

My experience with trying to reuse units or modules has not been productive because of having to disassemble and rework the units anyway to accommodate a new and different setting. However I have been able to recycle a majority of the individual 1x4s, 2x4s and 50-60% of the plywood decking.

 

And, as many have said, the experience gained will produce new, improved ideas and a more satisfying layout next time. Good luck.  

If you're paying a moving company, consider the cost of moving anything you want to salvage. When I moved with the Air Force back in the day, cost was based on weight and the weight of wood can add up. If that's the case, it won't be a dollar for dollar trade-off, but may tip the scales in favor of starting from scratch in the new location AFTER college.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×