Skip to main content

Hi,

I have been preparing several brass cars for service on the RR.

One had a single 2-56 screw holding the KD draft gear box.

The other has two smaller screws on each side of the KD draft gear box.  One of the screw holes is stripped.

Questions:

1. Which is stronger, one 2-56 hole in the center or two smaller screws, one on each side?

2. What is the best way to fix the stripped hole?  I have two thoughts on this: the first is to dip the screw in ACC and then insert the screw into the hole.  The second is a variation on the theme.  I would dip the screw in epoxy or JB Weld and then screw it into the hole.

Thanks,

Ed

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Using an adhesive on the stripped hole might work but it depends on how badly it's stripped.  Loctite® offers Threadlocker Blue 242®  It might be a better choice than ACC or J-B Weld in the event you need to remove the screw.  Check the Loctite® website for product details/warnings and other adhesives.

 

J-B Weld offers a medium threadlocker but it's recommended for screws 1/4"- 1".

 

Matt

 

Hi Ed

 

In 40 years of running I've never had a coupler pocket screw sheer off - but I've had quite a few vibrate loose. I always use two screws - not for strength, but to assure that the pocket stays in alignment with the centerline of the car. To address normal vibration I put a very light dab of Locktite on the screw threads - but I wouldn't trust it as replacement for thread contact. In most cases for stripped threads I re-tap the hole for the next size larger screw - going from Metric to English or vice versa. Imported brass models typically have 2mm coupler pocket screws. For those I re-tap the hole for 2-56 - works like a charm. NWSL offers a complete selection of small screws and taps. I particularly find useful their phillips cap head 2 mm x 9mm blackened steel screws for replacing plated brass screws often found on brass imports - many of which are a tad short for mounting a Kadee pocket. Also with a magnetized screw driver you can navigate them into tight places under car bodies.

 

 

Ed Rappe

Last edited by Keystoned Ed

I am with Ed above. Makes no difference what size, but 2-56 is easier to deal with.  I personally use socket head cap screws, which are 125,000 psi steel, but brass is plenty strong enough.

 

I would use all hex head, but they are no longer economically available in steel.

 

Be careful about taps.  There are good ones and bad ones.  Do not bother with the ones from hobby stores - look for Greenfield, or some quality tap.  And use appropriate fluid.

 

Check out Micro Fasteners - they have fairly good taps.  The best are only available through good wholesalers or machinery supply places.  Micro Fasteners also sells screws cheaper than your local hardware store.

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×