I know lionel has the new version/x mth. as far a the running mechanics. the motor gear drive ect. is this model more robust than a new lionel version.
the more I see problems with the new lionel one. the mth one looks better and better. I am just wrong? other than the legacy sounds and higer price am I missing somthing?
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Yes, mechanically as well as cosmetically ,the MTH version is better.
@RickO posted:Yes, mechanically as well as cosmetically ,the MTH version is better.
I'd agree 100%. The Lionel L1 uses a single RS385 motor (same one used in twin motor diesels) with a worm shaft permanently attached to the motor. The MTH L1 has a big, fat, 9343 Pittman with a separate worm shaft. No comparison. The MTH L1 has a mechanically bullet proof driveline that makes more torque.
MTH 20-80007A. One of my favorite engines. One available on that certain website.
I have three of them. Great locomotives. One is like new, one is weathered and the third has a repaired valve gear hanger.
The valve gear hangers are a weak spot. If the engine rolls on its side or isn’t packaged properly for shipping, they tend to snap off…
Tom
wow thanks. seems the one I saw for a good price is gone already. just watched norms video and decided I want on only lionels seems to have numerous problems.
I figured the mth model would be a lot better and you guys said it. mabachi motor and all. thanks.
Access to this requires an OGR Forum Supporting Membership
