Skip to main content

THE D&S HAS PURCHASED 4 ALCO diesels from the WP&Y. This was partially due to the accusation the steam engines  lit up the dry brush a couple of years ago and started wild  fires.

Link to story.

https://trn.trains.com/news/ne...-pass--yukon-diesels

 

Last edited by prrhorseshoecurve
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

irish rifle posted:

Cool. My wife and I will be riding both the Durango and Silverton and the Cumbres and Toltec Scenic Railroads in September. Just made our arrangements this week.

Pat

I hope you are riding all the way across the Cumbres & Toltec.  It is authentic Colorado narrow gauge railroading, more so than the Durango & Silverton, however it does not have the dramatic track on the vertical canyon wall that the D&S does.

What use will ten new diesels be put to IF the WP&Y no longer hauls freight?  I made sure l rode the WP&Y behind steam.by arriving ln Skagway on the day it was running.  I rode the Silverton a couple of times in the 1950's (D&RGW), passed up other chances (big mistakes), but have only ridden half of the C&T once..(fire threat blocked other attempts). I want to ride them in the fall when the aspens have turned, but that has been fire season after a hot summer with drouth.   Only want to ride behind historical steam.

Rusty Traque - Thanks for providing the article about the new engines the WP&Y is acquiring, but it only refers to six (6) engines - not ten (10). So do you know if this going to be a phased purchase, where they get 6 first and 4 more at a later date?

Also, the article didn't clarify the engine manufacturer and type. Do you know?

colorado hirailer posted:

What use will ten new diesels be put to IF the WP&Y no longer hauls freight? 

What about all the tens of thousands of passengers from all the massive cruise ships that stop there? Yes, the cruise ships are currently "on hold", but next year will bring a whole new flock of tourists to Skagway.

I made sure l rode the WP&Y behind steam.by arriving ln Skagway on the day it was running. 

The WP&Y still has the steam locomotives.

I rode the Silverton a couple of times in the 1950's (D&RGW), passed up other chances (big mistakes), but have only ridden half of the C&T once..(fire threat blocked other attempts). I want to ride them in the fall when the aspens have turned, but that has been fire season after a hot summer with drouth.   Only want to ride behind historical steam.

Well, that's your choice but the vast majority of the tourists that ride the WP&Y, and even the Durango & Silverton, don't seem to care WHAT is pulling the train.

 

As Tom eluded.    Both Trains are dissimilar  but  TERRIFIC  / GRAND.

The C&T sided about half way for a Picnic style lunch on the grounds( with blanket ). It was in a Plateau with grass & Wild Flowers as the Train going the other way passed.  GREAT

The D&S turned around in Silverton for about an hour. A rebuilt town ( I e , Tourist                '  attraction ' )  .  They were  many terrific Views   Amazing

The Motive Power was ALL Steam in the late '70s 

 

I have ridden both D&S and C&T many times. The scenery on both are comparable. The D&S has the shelf carved out of the side of the Animas River gorge which is spectacular. But the C&T has similar stretches, especially in the section between the lunch break and Antonito ( east bound ). On balance the D&S has better marketing especially since it originates/terminates in real towns (Durango, Silverton). Chama and Antonito were dusty little cow towns back in the day and that has not really changed. Every time I go to Chama I expect to see the Lone Ranger & Tonto ride into town. But IMHO C&T has the edge but is a sleeper. It could use a little boosting. FWIW.

John

As one who has ridden both several times, sit on the right hand side going to Silverton on the D&S.  Otherwise you will see a lot of rock wall.  Save your money don't buy a roundtrip, take the bus back from Silverton.  This will give you time to explore Silverton.  The C&T is the more interesting and the lunch is great.  Glad to see you are coming to New Mexico and southern Colorado the people depend on tourism and the economy is hurting.   

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×