Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Sure wish someone had pictures of the NKP unit.  But I see they (Lionel) got the LV unit CORRECT, that is NOT as incorrectly depicted in the catalog.  So this gives hope that the NKP unit I have on order being correct.

 

Sure do LIKE the fact that the nose door is correct and long hood headlights are correct.  Lionel APPEARS to out done MTH on these, and I am a big MTH fan.  BUT MTH particularly Mike Wolf made the WRONG decision not investing in the new tooling to make these right! 

Originally Posted by jojofry:

In those pictures they don't look glossy finish .Did they do these in mate finish? 

Yes they all have the gloss finish.  Although they don't look quite as glossy as the SD 70s in my opinion.  It just doesn't show up in pics well.  The conrail looked really glossy in the store.  The pennsy and lehigh valley not quite as glossy, might just be the color.  

Very nice. In addition to the nose door location and light positions, mentioned above, notice that the screens on top of the radiator wing are raised, rather than fitting flush with the surrounding surface (as on original ES44 production) and notice the smaller, more uniform vents in the car body underneath the radiator wing. (Gone is the single large screen accompanied by a few smaller ones). Both are features of late ES44 production. Lionel did a nice job in accurately representing these changes. Regardless of how one feels about die cast vs. plastic, the accuracy in these models I think makes the new tooling worthwhile.

Originally Posted by AGHRMatt:

Very nice looking units. I like how Lionel "semi-fixed" the pilots. 

This type of pilot originally came on the Vision Hybrids and I agree that it is fantastic! It is almost a perfect compromise. IMHO ALL new Lionel diesels should use this type of pilot. There is no reason for anything else. This is one of the best innovations that Lionel has come out with over the past few years.

I agree.  The semi-fixed pilots idea is a winner!
 
Has anyone tried putting kadees on this model? 
 
Originally Posted by david1:

For those of us who can't run the fixed pilots, Lionel has done a great job on these models and past models like the AC6000's, SD70ace and now the ES44ac's. The semi-fixed pilots as Matt calls them is a good is a good way of making them look like fixed pilots. Nice job Lionel. 

 

 

 

Originally Posted by Martin H:
I agree.  The semi-fixed pilots idea is a winner!
 
Has anyone tried putting kadees on this model? 
 
Originally Posted by david1:

For those of us who can't run the fixed pilots, Lionel has done a great job on these models and past models like the AC6000's, SD70ace and now the ES44ac's. The semi-fixed pilots as Matt calls them is a good is a good way of making them look like fixed pilots. Nice job Lionel. 

 

 

 

I run would kadees on all my engine if they ever make them ussable by legacy remote.. But to answer your question the coupler attaches to the pilots and its the same as  the sd70 and ac6000 lionel engines.. so if this helps ..

Last edited by jojofry

Is anyone else having issues with these things pulling cars on O54? I've had mine running around the tree, which is half O72 and half O54, and the engine runs by itself just fine, but couple a car up to it, and it doesnt seem like there's enough travel in the rear end to not pull the trailing car off the track. Have tried 3 different cars right now, always the same result. Normally not an issue as my layout has an O72 loop, but my legacy set is hooked up to the tree layout for the time being.

Yabba-Dabba-Doo the NKP unit has the Prototypical CORRECT paint scheme (NOT as depicted in the catalog).  Looking forward for mine to arrive. These ES44s with the correct nose door position, long hood horizontal headlights, screen & vent detail etc. eat MTH's lunch.  Oh and there is the pilots.  That is my opinion and I am a big big MTH fan but they missed the mark on these HS-Heritage units.

 

The two downsides with these Lionel units is not modeling the long hood ditch lights (operational OR not) and if one wants several of the units WITH prototypical road numbers we are FORCED to purchase the expensive powered units, NO non-powered with correct numbers.

 

Ron

Last edited by PRRronbh
 
Interesting that they got the front door correct on these $550 dollar units, but the $850 Vison BNSF had the door on the wrong side, missing its window.
 
 
Originally Posted by PRRronbh:

 These ES44s with the correct nose door position, long hood horizontal headlights, filter detail etc. eat MTH's lunch.  That is my opinion and I am a big big MTH fan but they missed the mark on these HS-Heritage units.

 

 

Originally Posted by Martin H:
 
Interesting that they got the front door correct on these $550 dollar units, but the $850 Vison BNSF had the door on the wrong side, missing its window.
 
 
Originally Posted by PRRronbh:

 These ES44s with the correct nose door position, long hood horizontal headlights, filter detail etc. eat MTH's lunch.  That is my opinion and I am a big big MTH fan but they missed the mark on these HS-Heritage units.

 

 

Martin correct me if I am wrong, but BNSF, UP, HS and others have ES44 units with nose doors on both the left or right sides all dependent of road number.  BUT all the HS-Heritage units are of the new version/phase with doors on right plus other details.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×