Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by Stuart:

I can't believe how many major wrecks CSX has been having.  It seems they're averaging at least one per month.  Is this just bad luck, or general incompetance on the part of those who run the railroad?

 

Stuart

Ah, just wait, once PTC is in place all railroad problems are solved. No more accidents, all trains run on time.  (And I am Santa Clause..)

Originally Posted by DominicMazoch:

PTC will not stop any trains if a loose cut of cars roll onto the mainline.  And PTC signals will come fron the front of the train with locomotives, unless there is a pusher on the rear.

 

Will FREDs get PTC transmitters?


Dominic is correct of course.  I should have add phrase "sarcasism off" as PTC won't fix all troubles but can compensate somewhat for human inattention.  PTC can't fix poor roadbeds, negleted hotboxes etc etc.

 

Originally Posted by rrman:

Interesting that they just push stuff to the side rather than using the big hook to upright and rerail cars.  Guess its cheaper and gets a critical line re-opened and revenue ($$$) moving again.  Besides isn't that why RR have insurance, let insurance pay for it.

None of the "big railroads" have "big hooks" anymore. With professional contractors like R.J.Corman and Hultcher, it is much faster, and less expensive in the long run, than maintaining all those "big hooks" and the huge quantity of wrecking crew personnel that went with them.

 

Insurance doesn't pay for all of it. Most railroads have multi-million dollar deductible policies. 

The Big Hooks had to attack a wreck from the ends of the mess.  If track was torn up, it had to be replaced before they could advance.  Cleanup could be a long drawn out process.  Dozers and mobile cranes can attack a wreck anywhere as the photos show.  Once the debris is removed, the tracks can be repaired and the line reopened.  The wrecked cars can be removed at any time.  Time is money.

 

Tom

Originally Posted by jay jay:

Those are fascinating photos, Josh; thanks for posting them!

Thank you very much! Also, I wanted to point out, those bulldozers appeared to be holding the fallen coal cars in their position, so they didn't roll further down the embankment and into the garage behind me. There was a large crane on the other side of the tracks that was waiting to move into position to begin clean up.

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×