Skip to main content

Hi Guy's,

I turn to you my train guru's of the three rail world for help!

I just took my Vision Hudson out of the box and ran it for a few minutes and refilled the stack. Then the smoke stopped working, The fan motor is not making it's whirring noise and no smoke is wafting out of the stack either. I do how ever have a cab light flashing three times.

Move over Hudson, Brand new Santa Fe 3751 coming out of the box...Worked great for ten minutes. Put smoke fluid in the stack now that stopped working. No whirring noise, no wafting, no nothing. I do, however, have the cab light flashing three times on that one also.

Also so you are aware, the whistle steam effect works fine on both engines.

I did the factory resets on both as per the manual, I cycled the power on and off, I blew down the stacks till i was blue in the face.

I never had this problem before. I can work on them if I have to. I hate to take apart these engines though. If I have to I will. I'm not afraid to do that. I have plenty of experience with TMCC engines. Never had to open a legacy. I used to own a train store so I have worked on everything from pre-war to TMCC.

Thanks in advance for suggestions.

Getting a head ache,
Mike R
Last edited by Mike R
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I may be wrong, but it sounds as though you may have overfilled the smoke units and drowned the motor/electronics. The 3 flashes indicates a smoke unit fan problem, and overfilling can cause this.

With many modern units, turning the locomotive upside down to drain excess fluid doesn't always work, as the fluid can end up all over the inside of the bodywork, and leave a right mess.

If you don't wish to take the body off and investigate further at this time, I would suggest that you leave the locomotive for a day or two, and then try again. You can still use the locomotives in this time, but be sure that the smoke units are switched off. (Using the switch, not just on the remote.)

If you have tried to reset them 3 times, the smoke units will be locked-out. But this can be reset by re-programming the ID number of the locomotive.

Thank you everyone for the replies.

I was hoping you guy's would have a different suggestion from what I've already tried.

 

To answer the statement that they were overfilled, that didn't happen. I only put in about twelve to fifteen drops in each stack.

 

Please keep the suggestions coming. I would hate to send these engines back to Lionel for repair. As I know they won't be back till after the Holiday's.

 

Thanks again,

Mike R

While I can not say for sure in both cases  it seems as though Lionel has had a bad batch of smoke unit fans in recent offerings. I recently replaced the smoke unit fan on my legacy k4, it was noisey when new a year ago, finally got worse and quit altogether. Lionel offered to cover it under warranty but since it was near the very end I ordered a replacement fan as it was a fraction of the cost of one way shipping.

 

I have also had good luck with oiling the fan motor shaft bushing on some of my other locos in the case of  noisey or inoperating fans. The nice thing about the new units is that the fan runs while the loco is stationary so their easy to test on the track with the shell off. I'd probably start off removing the fan from the housing and putting a drop of oil on the shaft bushing give it a spin with your finger and the turn it on. If it works run it in a vertical position for a few minutes to work the oil into the bushing.  Test it on and off a few times, if it responds normally then reassemble. If either of these fans were overly noisy its likely they'll have to be replaced, I didn't realize how bad mine was until I replaced it, the old one would vibrate the fillings out of my mouth.

 

Most of the latest legacy steamers with the exception of the s3 I think, have "shell mounted" smoke units as opposed to the "chassis mounted" units used in the past. These units are a bit more tedious to repair but not the worst if your careful. Nicole makes some good points but on the newer smoke units the fan is enclosed in a seperate housing with a hose connected to the resovoir. Its not completely unthinkable that you could have gotten fluid on the fan motor it is signifigantly less likely to happen as the fluid has a long way to go. Additionally the fan is mounted horizontally in the housing so if fluid got that far it would pool and leak out of the housing before it could soak the motor.

 

Once the problem is addressed either replacing the fan or getting it working, the code will cease, no more blinking light. 

 

 

Having said all that warranty is a good way to go especially on a brand spankin new loco. I thought Lionel picked up the shipping both ways on VL stuff.

 

BTW I recall Mike Reagan, warning against removing the shell as some of the detail parts are attached to the frame. I'm sure its not completely impossible since OGR had photos of one with the shell off.

Last edited by RickO

Rick O,

 

Thanks for the input. Some really good ideas.

 

I left the Santa Fe 3751 alone for about an hour. She started to work correctly and the code is now gone. Now the amount of smoke isn't as good as it was when I first pulled out of the sealed box two hours ago.

 

I really think the culprit is a bottle of no name smoke fluid I got from a well known Lionel Dealer. I wasn't to keen on buying it but he said it was the same as Lionel smoke fluid and would work fine. After all the problems I started to look at everything I did. I realized that I had put this new smoke fluid in both engines. So I took a look at the fluid and noticed it was much thicker than my old fluid. It must be a heavier weight oil. So it must be gumming things up inside the unit. I tried some LGB Smoke Fluid after a reset. Whada'ya know! It started smoking like a campfire. The fluid burnt out real fast, it's a lot thinner than normal smoke fluid. So I won't be using that NO Name Smoke Fluid any more.

 

All that being said the Hudson still has the problem I'm deciding if I should box it up and send it into Lionel or just wait a few days. Maybe the thick oil will dry up.

 

Thanks for the input,

 

Mike R

Mike R  the pipette that came with your new engines from the tip look about an inch up and you will see a line across it fill to that line and add smoke fluid since I started using it nary a 3 light flash since.

seems as these newer units are on the fussy side but after this if it keeps giving the 3 flashes send it back as my NKP 765 has done it on and off now I know why today I smelled an electric burning smell ha I happened to have it pass below me and saw a bright orange glow i killed the power and after 3 minutes it stopped sending smoke out the stack and thank goodness it's a metal body other wise probably be a blob of plastic. will disassemble in morning see what is all destroyed as it's 2 years old warranty all gone.

 

just thought I'd give the rest of you a heads up so you may avoid my issue.

 

$oo

Thank you everyone for the information.

Just an update.

The Sanata Fe Legacy 3751 is operating fine. The thick no name smoke fluid was the culprit.

The Vision Hudson is now my main area of concern. Last night I tried a reset by changing the ID number. Only because it wouldn't take the reset with its original ID due to the fact that I did it too many times. Now I'm just getting idle sounds from the tender with no chuff and no bell sounds (it moves), and no whistle (smoke effect works).

Does anybody have any idea of what could be wrong. I know it was something I did. It has to be. Everything was working fine till I started using that $&**** smoke fluid.

I turn to you once again oh guru's of the three rail world. Lol!

Mike R
Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×