Skip to main content

I want to have smoke from my trains, but not this type

So, this LIRR M7 beauty arrived in the mail today for me and I was very pleased.

20210903_15473320210903_154723

What I wasn't pleased with was when I opened the box the interior and packaging reeked of cigarette smoke along with the entire car. Have opened all the train doors to help try to dissipate the smell.  To each his own (smoking) but the seller made no mention that the train was coming from a smoke filled home.  They could have at least had the courtesy to do so.  I see many items for sale where the seller makes a point that their item is from a smoke "free" home.

Back to the topic.  I have no intention of returning the train (but won't buy from that seller again), but what is the procedure that one does to remove cigarette smoke smell from a plastic and metal unit?  With clothes, you just run them in the washing machine... model trains not so much.  Or will the smell just go away eventually on its own?

Attachments

Images (2)
  • 20210903_154733
  • 20210903_154723
Last edited by Amfleet25124
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

You might try wiping down the car with a damp paper towel or cloth to perhaps remove some of the smoke film (and odor) from the surface.   Another option is a light spraying of Pledge or Armor-All followed by the paper towel or cloth wipedown process.   These are untested suggestions so use your best judgement on what you want to try. I know the smell can be very difficult to remove; some of the more passive options may not work in every situation but should be tried first. Good luck.

Dale

@train steve posted:

For the lightest cleaning I use Ivory dish liquid on a white washcloth. You can dilute as you see fit which gives you more control in the process.  I agree it might be smoke film, the white wash cloth will show you,probably best to remove body.

Hope this helps.

I agree. A smell would go away. The smoke "film" remains. I've cleaned my sister's car windows and the rag gets good and brown after I finish the inside surface. Right, she smokes while driving.

Confronted with the same problem, and after trying some of the ideas suggested above, i found charcoal works the best. Assuming it doesn't have a film of cigarette smoke on it or you have removed said film, just wrap it lightly in either tissue, newspaper, or paper towels; then place it in a large plastic bag with a half a dozen charcoal  briquettes, and seal it with a twist tie. Leave it alone for at least a week or two and hopefully it will have worked. Good luck.

Last edited by modeltrainsparts

Kevin.  Ask your wife if she has any "Mrs Murphy Lemon liquid soap"  I bet she does.  A small amount on a soft cloth.  Wipe down the entire car.  All the nicotine will come off without hurting the finish of the car.

Now take some tissues wet them with the Mrs. Murphy and insert through the doors.  Let it sit over night.  Next day you will be amazed'.. smell will be gone'.. ANd you'll have a nice clean car'...

I will add one more that worked for us..ground coffee. We had an uncle whose house burned due to smoking in bed. We restored a console soul stereo system and some furniture salvaged from the fire and placed ground coffee in a plastic container in the stereo on the advice of a furniture restorer and it worked after about a week. And no it didn’t smell like coffee afterwards. I have used this technique on trains for years placing the coffee in a bag with the item.  I leave it for 24-48 hours . Usually wash with Dawn before and after. Cheapest ground coffee works just fine

Extremely interesting answers here.  I am convinced that many plastics are porous and somewhat unstable, and that the plastic will absolutely absorb odors.   (Try getting the fish smell out of an old cat plastic cat dish.)

I think that packing it for a long time in finely crushed charcoal may work.    I guess I would get some filter charcoal from a fish pet store, and crush it up really fine with a mortar and pestle (or a hammer and a plastic bag), and completely pack the cars in it, inside a zip lock freezer bag.  Let it sit a month.

Mannyrock

A mix of water, vinegar and baking soda is the standard method of washing down walls and ceiling of an apartment formally inhabited by a smoker. (As a side hobby in real estate, I have lots of experience doing this!) I don't think this formation would harm the plastic or the paint. You can try it in a small area as a test. In more difficult situations I use an ozone generation machine, but that definitely damages plastics and destroys lung tissues if not used correctly...Not recommended for toy train use!

Absolutely wrong, Tom! The number one method for getting rid of this horrid smell is for Kevin to just give me the set. He’ll never have to smell it again and I promise to take very good care of them.

^^^

  I'll send it right over Strap'

Thanks everyone for their ideas. I had it wrapped in dryer sheets all day and while I was out this evening purchased a charcoal filter sheet.  The package (I purchased a single car, not a RTR set) is all wrapped up in a time capsule cocoon now (Star Date 2021.09.06) and packed away in the laundry room.  Will revisit it on Monday, wipe it down with dish soap and see -  or smell - the results.

20210904_21584220210904_22002120210904_22021420210904_220409

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 20210904_215842
  • 20210904_220021
  • 20210904_220214
  • 20210904_220409

Doesn’t ozone do this?  Put it in a box and turn up a postwar transformer.  Just speculating. I knew a fellow who had a dry cleaner store, and he had a special room that he would ozone up for house fire clothes restoration.
Maybe this could be a science project .
I would still wipe it down first to remove any icky smoke film.
Alan

As suggested above,used coffee grounds.We restored arcade and pinball machines.As you know several came from smoke filled bars and pool halls.Used coffee grounds removed all of the smell from the machines.We simply put the wet grounds in a bowl in the units.This should work with your purchase.Maybe in a sealed plastic container..Hope you get the smell gone!

Maybe the coffee idea will work.  I have never tried it.  But, I would be careful.   Coffee is highly acidic.    Putting wet coffee grounds directly against your paint and decal surfaces may (or may not) have some unintended results.

I think I would first try wrapping the engines in a loose porous cloth, and then packing it in dry coffee.

Perhaps dry kitty liter would be better?  I don't know.  (It is a highly absorbent porous clay.)

Mannyrock

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×