Skip to main content

Noise that is. One person talking is understandable. 2 is manageable,maybe. 3 at once makes understanding incomprehensible. Little can be understood in a crowded room full of people. The same thing I think could be said for train noise. On larger layouts 3 or more trains run at once. Can the human ear segregate and make sense of it or does it become a cacophony of noise? Beethoven,my favorite composer was a master at blending sounds,he wrote his music that way and has many masterpieces.  Train sounds are random and not composed and not Beethoven.

 

I live near the CSX. I hear one train occasionally, very rarely 2 at once passing each other. On many layouts and train shows many trains run continually on loops all with sound units and crew chatter,not pleasant to me. I put mine on timers. Only 1 train (2 or 3 per loop) runs per loop at a time and at spaced intervals. With 6 loops and the use of timers only 1 or 2 trains usually run at once.IMO time and time intervals is the least modeled aspect in model rail roading.  Peace in the valley! To each his own but I do not like layouts too busy or too active. They are not prototypical to real life and not enjoyable to me. I am a toy train guy without realistic scenery but still pay attention to this aspect. To each his own. I also design my layout so trains appear and disappear like real trains. I do this with tunnels and putting the layout in 2 rooms. I also time accessories such as carnival rides to turn on and off, not run continually. The ferris wheel has to stop so the riders can get on and off! Same thing with the passenger trains. What is your opinion and preferences?

 

Dale H

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

When my club has an open house we run 11 trains at once. We also have carnival noise, circus music, spooky sounds in the ghost town. When everything is running it can overload the senses.  Our guests find it exciting. The human brain allows us to concentrate on one thing and block out the rest.  I'm still happy at the end of the day when we shut all the noise off.  Then after it's all over I like to run one train and relax. 

Last edited by Pat Kn

When you're dealing with models, think of yourself hovering over the layout in a silent aircraft of some type. Think of the size of everything in relation to where a scale you would be. So, you'd really be a couple of hundred feet away from (normally above) everything, or further in some cases. Even getting down close and low, you're still a good 20-30 scale feet away at least, I'd think (in smaller scales, it'd all be greater distances of course).

So, from that far away in real life, what would you hear? Would trains be that loud? Probably not. Could you possibly hear anyone's voice other than through a bullhorn? Nope, you wouldn't at all.

I would suggest that knowing this, for the most part, scale sounds on layouts are usually proportionally way too loud than what they'd be in real life if you were that far away from things.

IMHO- When I host up an Open House for the Detroit 3 Railers... all lights, sounds, animation, and smoke is on.

It gets very loud, smokey, and something about it just puts a smile on my face....

 

Now when I run trains alone or with a few friends, usually the smoke is on  only for a bit, the sounds are turned down with the lights... and the show is relaxing...

Last edited by J Daddy

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×