....and wanted to build a small switching layout with one or two small diesel locomotives at most, what would be the best brand locomotive to purchase?
Sound is not a factor, I can take it or leave it.
Rick.
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
What time period?
In my opinion, the best running loco currently available that fits what you want would be the Atlas O SW8/9. Single motor drive, good slow speed control, and smooth runner. I have had people tell me they fun better without the sound, so you may want to look for one without the new sound decoder.
What is your budget?
Simon
I believe the negative of a DCC sound decoder equipped AtlasO ( or other brand) locomotive when running on DC is is the higher starting voltage. Running on DCC they are fine. A very nice industrial switching locomotive to consider is a Yoder GE 44 tonner. Brand loyalty is not as big a factor in O 2 rail as standards generally provide good interoperability. I research the prototype I may want, find out who made one, and then ask around about any issues with the model. Over the years I've purched more used models than new ones ( even a few basket cases for rebuild) in an effort to build a roster suited to the time and place I'm trying capture the operational feel of.
Hope you join us - we are quite a diverse but small and growing fraturnity..
Ed Rappe
Patrick:
Late or post steam to Pre-1969.
Simon:
I have plenty of rolling stock so I am just looking at one or two locomotive purchases. And I have several three rail locomotives for conversion if practical.
But, to answer....under $500.00 for one or two units.
Rick.
Rick,
Sending you an E-mail.
Simon
I am fond of Yoder s-12 and 44T. His 70T is very nice too.
Rick
For pre-1969 I would have to add my voice the the Atlas SW 8/9 chorus. If you want a four axle road switcher I'd consider an Atlas Geep or an MTH GP35 or U25B. If you go the MTH route you will have the ability to run 2 rail O out of the box or swap axles to run 3 rail scale.
I would take Atlas or MTH over a Yoder switcher for consistent quality in the drive train. I have run a narrow gauge Yoder 70 tonner. It had a high amperage draw starting in one direction. Take a look at the drive train and decide if it is up to your standards.
