Skip to main content

I worked on my old Santa Fe warbonnet Set #218 (Variant B - 2 A units) over the weekend. I then tested  the powered unit on the Tree layout.
It would only pull 3 modern MTH railking cars!!!
Admittedly, this old house is no where near level flooring.
But more than that had it spinning in place on the up hill 180° O-31 RealTrax corner.
I really expected a bit better performance. I even carefully scraped and wiped the wheels thinking I might have gotten oil on them somehow (they did have accumulated black crud on them).
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

The gentleman below supplied the answer.
 
It must be a ferrous metal, (containing iron) such as steel or other iron alloy to attract to a normal magnet.
 
Put a magnet on different types of metals to see for yourself. That is why magnets pick up steel paper clips, but not copper rivets, or gold coins or silver dimes, aluminum beer cans.....or even good quality stainless steel. 
 
Rare earth magnets are another story. Greg
 
Originally Posted by quebesh:

the magnatraction has no affect on non ferric track.

I thank all of you for the replies and Yes I know why my track is a poor match for Magnetraction.

I was just surprised the traction was so low on a flat top rail. Perhaps some weight will help.

 

Alibatwomble;

I am surprised to hear about your Phantom. Mine pulls all 4 cars fine on my RealTrax layout in the basement. Admittedly the curves are wider there. Mine is also TMCC so I wonder if they also changed the wheels along the way. Mine does need the motor to be rebuilt as it consistently pops my breaker after a couple laps pulling all 4 cars (over current limit). Any other engine can pull the 4 cars forever with no problems.

You may find you can put traction tires over two of the driven wheels, which will give you the pulling power you need. With 031 curves and no grooves in the wheels the tires may or may not stay on. A little rubber cement might keep them on. I added two tires to a plastic 2-4-2 steamer (246?) and it greatly increased its pulling power on Gargraves track. The tires stay on without grooves, probably because they are stretched so tight and my radius is 072.

 

You can also add weight. My 1055 Texas Special ALCO was very basic (from a promotional set) and had no magne-traction, but did have a steel weight riveted to the back wall of the locomotive and it pulled 7-8 free rolling cars on level track.

 

Whatever you do, enjoy your holiday layout!

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×