Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Pitman offers a very large array of "can" motors.   Those ordered with "rare earth" magnets have significantly higher torque than lower priced Pittman's with the same physical dimensions and voltage specs.  The various models come in many different lengths, diameters, bearings (solid vs. ball), single shaft or double, and voltage ratings.  Bottom line - Pittman motors are not all created equal. 

 

Ed 

Last edited by Keystoned Ed

As I've stated before chipset, Lionels "Pullmor" motor is their old postwar style motor that was the standard before the develpoment of the "can motor" to power model trains.

 

Lionel has offered "Pullmor" powered locos in recent years to appeal to the folks who remember trains operating that way as a kid.

 

"Pullmor" motors are Lionels "old fashioned style motor thats big, noisy, runs hot, eats gobs of electricity, and is extremely sensative to load changes such as inclines and curves and slow speed crawls ( as we know them today) are basically unattainable.

 

"Can motors" are the more modern way to power trains in the last 15 years. They are just as powerfull, run cooler, use way less electricity and run virtually silent, along with allow a model train to achivev the prototypical slow speed crawls of a locomotive departing or switching.

 

 MTH never used "Pullmors" because they are a "Lionel" thing. I'm betting Mike doesn't care for their operating characteristic either.

 

Can motors are made by several different  "electronic motor manufacturers".

 

I would guess Lionel, MTH, select particular can motor brands based on specifications and possibly price.

 

There really isn't a bad "can motor" Pittman, Buhler, and now Canon are all brands Lionel has used or is using. They all run well and observing operation of locomotives equipped with each. there really is no descernable diffence.

 

I believe Rich stated that the Canon motors Lionel is using these days are superior to the Pittmans. Again, I don't think you could tell by comparing loco operation.

 

Lionel "touted" the Pittman brand can motor back in the early 2000's because some time prior to 2000, Lionel locos were not offered with any "can motors". It was a "new" thing.

 

Lionel also flubbed some product descriptions in early 2000 as well. I.e. the CC Niagra was advertised as having a "Pullmor" motor when it infact came with a can motor.

 

Any (non postwar/ classics) scale offering 2000 to date will have a can motor.

 

 

Last edited by RickO
Originally Posted by RickO:

As I've stated before chipset, Lionels "Pullmor" motor is their old postwar style motor that was the standard before the develpoment of the "can motor" to power model trains.

 

Lionel has offered "Pullmor" powered locos in recent years to appeal to the folks who remember trains operating that way as a kid.

 

"Pullmor" motors are Lionels "old fashioned style motor thats big, noisy, runs hot, eats gobs of electricity, and is extremely sensative to load changes such as inclines and curves and slow speed crawls ( as we know them today) are basically unattainable.

 

"Can motors" are the more modern way to power trains in the last 15 years. They are just as powerfull, run cooler, use way less electricity and run virtually silent, along with allow a model train to achivev the prototypical slow speed crawls of a locomotive departing or switching.

 

 MTH never used "Pullmors" because they are a "Lionel" thing. I'm betting Mike doesn't care for their operating characteristic either.

 

Can motors are made by several different  "electronic motor manufacturers".

 

I would guess Lionel, MTH, select particular can motor brands based on specifications and possibly price.

 

There really isn't a bad "can motor" Pittman, Buhler, and now Canon are all brands Lionel has used or is using. They all run well and observing operation of locomotives equipped with each. there really is no descernable diffence.

 

I believe Rich stated that the Canon motors Lionel is using these days are superior to the Pittmans. Again, I don't think you could tell by comparing loco operation.

 

Lionel "touted" the Pittman brand can motor back in the early 2000's because some time prior to 2000, Lionel locos were not offered with any "can motors". It was a "new" thing.

 

Lionel also flubbed some product descriptions in early 2000 as well. I.e. the CC Niagra was advertised as having a "Pullmor" motor when it infact came with a can motor.

 

Any (non postwar/ classics) scale offering 2000 to date will have a can motor.

 

 

Great info, thanks Rick.

 

Originally Posted by Keystoned Ed:

Pitman offers a very large array of "can" motors.   Those ordered with "rare earth" magnets have significantly higher torque than lower priced Pittman's with the same physical dimensions and voltage specs.  The various models come in many different lengths, diameters, bearings (solid vs. ball), single shaft or double, and voltage ratings.  Bottom line - Pittman motors are not all created equal. 

 

Ed 

What is a "rare earth" magnet?

Joe 

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×