I am looking to get some NH motive power and I’ve been looking at the EP-5 K-line version. Other than the skirts around the trucks and couplers that seem to disintegrate anyone have some experience with the engine good bad or indifferent? Thanks.
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Hi Chris. I have one. When I first got it, I did not have TMCC. It ran poorly. Gary put in a ERR but I never really ran it. Then it got the zinc rot.
The outside third rail pickups will hit the screw heads on Z switch machines. I had to put new countersink flat head screws.
Hi Don. I have seen a few on eBay for not crazy money but I’m think there may be a reason for that. Thanks.
Chris...I've had mine for years....tmcc runs great...best looking EP5 ever...only fault is the horn...not a HANCOCK 4700....no rot yet...(fingers crossed).....third rail shoes WILL hit so be careful....all the best joe
Loved the two TMCC NH versions that I owned - will probably pick one up (again) in the near future. Mine ran great despite being equipped with K-line cruise. The detail was great - nicely detailer pantographs too.
In my mind the only downside was the blue-white LED. Others have mentioned the pickup shoes - these can be removed with a small screwdriver if they hit your switches.
In terms of zinc rot, some of these are impacted. Zinc rot or not, the pilots are a delicate point. If you look closely at online listings, you'll start spotting some where one or both pilots are broken.
Here’s an old video of mine on a layout. It had really smooth startups under TMCC control.
Attachments
I have the K line TMCC version has been running great for years. lots of miles on the flower city hi railers layout as well.
I have one that has been two-railed :
I also have a stock one for running on friends' three-rail layouts.
Note that the K-Line EP-5 has been compared very favorably with a brass import (Overland?) as being the better of the two.
Attachments
This would be a good candidate for 3D parts printing.
@Alex W posted:Loved the two TMCC NH versions that I owned - will probably pick one up (again) in the near future. Mine ran great despite being equipped with K-line cruise. The detail was great - nicely detailer pantographs too.
In my mind the only downside was the blue-white LED. Others have mentioned the pickup shoes - these can be removed with a small screwdriver if they hit your switches.
In terms of zinc rot, some of these are impacted. Zinc rot or not, the pilots are a delicate point. If you look closely at online listings, you'll start spotting some where one or both pilots are broken.
Here’s an old video of mine on a layout. It had really smooth startups under TMCC control.
The LED’s I can change easy enough and I only have one switch on one loop to worry about or I can run it on my 5 rail track with no switches. Nice looking cars behind it!
Cris, I had the Great Northern version and never had any issues. I got rid of it when my catenary system, I wish I had kept both.
Here's my EP 5 with a William's pilot replacing the rotted K Line one. The only altercation needed was to drill new holes in proper location. The Williams is almost identical to the K Line one. You can check to see if Bachman stills has the pilots in stock. Lenny J
Attachments
@Lenny J posted:Here's my EP 5 with a William's pilot replacing the rotted K Line one. The only altercation needed was to drill new holes in proper location. The Williams is almost identical to the K Line one. You can check to see if Bachman stills has the pilots in stock. Lenny J
thanks Lenny.....good to know...joe
It would be good if they had them in stock.
I guess after K-Line went under, no other company bought up the dies/tools needed to build this?
@RadioRon posted:I guess after K-Line went under, no other company bought up the dies/tools needed to build this?
Lionel reissued this under the K-line by Lionel banner in 2009 - only Milwaukee Road from what I recall. No cruise this time around.
A New Haven reissue with Legacy would be pretty great. Maybe with those sparking pantographs from the Vision Line GG1
My TMCC version runs fine.....some zinc rot issues (bought a conventional one for a song (< $100) and have changed out the truck sides. Had to change out some switch machine screws to clear the 3rd rail feet.....
This video is fron 2015:
Peter
Good info. I have two Williams EP5's so I may check the parts.
Thank you.
@Alex W posted:Lionel reissued this under the K-line by Lionel banner in 2009 - only Milwaukee Road from what I recall. No cruise this time around.
Easy to drop the ERR CC-M in those to add cruise.
I have the K-Line Milwaukee Road EP-5 (by Lionel). No problems at all. I use it with GRJ's YLB battery (with the lead to attached to the center rail pickup.)
If you go to the Williams parts site go to the universal parts section not the EP5 section and they show the pilots in stock.
@Lenny J posted:If you go to the Williams parts site go to the universal parts section not the EP5 section and they show the pilots in stock.
Could you be a little more specific about that location. I don't even see a "universal parts" section. There's a "general parts" section, but the pilot isn't there. Thanks.
Here's my best effort to get you to the parts. go to estore.bachmantrains.com, under categories go to O scale - Williams, on the left side of the page got to universal (it appears under streetcar), go to page 4 and you will find the pilots. Let me know how you make out.
@Lenny J posted:Here's my best effort to get you to the parts. go to estore.bachmantrains.com, under categories go to O scale - Williams, on the left side of the page got to universal (it appears under streetcar), go to page 4 and you will find the pilots. Let me know how you make out.
Thanks for the help, Lenny. I found them eventually. If someone can solve the puzzle to figure out how get to the right place at that site, Bachmann ought to give you the parts for free as a reward!
Attachments
@Lenny J posted:Here's my best effort to get you to the parts. go to estore.bachmantrains.com, under categories go to O scale - Williams, on the left side of the page got to universal (it appears under streetcar), go to page 4 and you will find the pilots. Let me know how you make out.
Just a warning. That Bachman site has been hacked and asks you to install a bogus Browser that you don't want to open the page. At least that is what happened to me. Just say no.
@Lenny J posted:Here's my best effort to get you to the parts. go to estore.bachmantrains.com, under categories go to O scale - Williams, on the left side of the page got to universal (it appears under streetcar), go to page 4 and you will find the pilots. Let me know how you make out.
@iguanaman3 posted:Just a warning. That Bachman site has been hacked and asks you to install a bogus Browser that you don't want to open the page. At least that is what happened to me. Just say no.
That URL is incorrect. Bachmann is spelled with two n’s. Try this one, instead: https://estore.bachmanntrains.com
If you are still looking for replacement pilots there are 2 on ebay under K Line ep5. These are Williams but easy to adjust to K Line