Skip to main content

I received the Bertoia catalog for the Jerry and Nina Greene auction.  It is a beautiful collection.  There is no way I could afford any of the pieces, nor would I want to put them on my operating layout where they could be damaged. However, I love the Marklin Bridge on the cover and I really like some of the Marklin and Bing stations.  This is where replicas will do for me.  However, I have never seen these reproduced except for the Leipzig Station by MTH.  I like that station, but would prefer one of the 'Dutch' styled stations.  Maybe MTH will make another... In the meantime, how hard do you think it would be to scratchbuild or kitbash this bridge in plastic or tin? 

Marklin Girder Bridge 44389619_1_m 

It would not need to be a perfect replica, but close would be great.  Also, I would probably scale it more for standage gauge, as this is 1 gauge.

George 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Marklin Girder Bridge 44389619_1_m
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

It would be a fun project. I saw that bridge when they were trying to sell it a few years ago through Sothbeys. It is bigger than you would think. 

One thing I noticed with the old Marklin is that they used similar metal stamp tooling in very creative ways. There was a vertical post stamping that was used for both fencing and balconies as well as cut down and used vertically as turnstyles. 

I'm sure there are some cross bracing metal stampings that you could use to solder together a bridge that would be similar to the bridge you posted. Another place to look for decorative stampings is costume jewelry findings.

Here is a similar Marklin bridge from a book I have that I think might use some of the same castings as the one you showed. The towers look the same.

image

Here is the cover of a different book that has a straight on view of the auction bridge if you really want to make a replica it this pic might help you.

image

Here are a few variations using the same towers.image

One more image of the one you liked from the auction.image

 

Attachments

Images (4)
  • image
  • image
  • image
  • image
Last edited by Silver Lake
overlandflyer posted:

this will keep me away...

Buyer's Premium
 25.5%
 
if there is some benefit to sellers who go to auction houses which continue to set record highs in buyer's premiums i'd really like to know because it certainly cannot be to attract buyers.

That and the estimated $20k that this bridge could sell for.  I guess a $5100 buyer's premium doesn't matter when you are in that range.

The book "The Golden Years of Tin Toy Trains" mentioned by Silver Lake is for sale on British ebay.co.uk for a much lower price then it is in the US. Many of the items in this book were photographed from the Jerni collection (before Jerry Green decided to quit collecting). It is a beautiful book with trains and accessories that you wil not see much in real life.

Regards

Fred

Last edited by sncf231e
George S posted:
overlandflyer posted:

this will keep me away...

Buyer's Premium
 25.5%
 
if there is some benefit to sellers who go to auction houses which continue to set record highs in buyer's premiums i'd really like to know because it certainly cannot be to attract buyers.

That and the estimated $20k that this bridge could sell for.  I guess a $5100 buyer's premium doesn't matter when you are in that range.

not much of a Märklin fan, or a structure collector, ... or for that matter, pieces with replacement/ repo parts (e.g. this bridge).  there were some Bing pieces that were of interest, but again, most seemed to be partially or fully restored.  not my collection milieu.

and while the auction house seemingly tried to be artistic about it, their photos of most items left a lot to be desired.  very few complete pictures such as the trucks in Dorfan lots (tremendously important to see) or the underside of practically everything in the catalog.  would have expected a lot more from a house charging such exorbitant fees.

the number you really want to look at isn't $5100, but $2100;
...the difference between 15% and 25.5% of 20k.
if i wanted my life to cost 10% more, i'd rather move to Hawaii.

cheers...gary

Definitely drool-worthy material. Scanning Marklin at places like Bertoia is a nice pastime, but as you say, above my paygrade.

Here's some reproductions on Tinplate Times: http://www.tinplatetimes.com/p...ng%20Bauer/bauer.htm

....and the stuff that's more inside my paygrade: paperplate! 

http://www.littleglitterhouses..._tin_city_bridge.htm

And then there's the bridges that cry out to be "tin-plated", like the one you posted: http://www.shorpy.com/node/852...ze=_original#caption

George S posted:

... how hard do you think it would be to scratchbuild or kitbash this bridge in plastic or tin? 

Marklin Girder Bridge 44389619_1_m 

It would not need to be a perfect replica, but close would be great.  Also, I would probably scale it more for standage gauge, as this is 1 gauge.

George 

I wonder if it was 'compressed' from this actual bridge across the Rhine between Strasbourg and Kehl ...

Strasbourg_-_Pont_du_Chemin_de_fer_sur_le_Rhin_carte_postale_1920

It has the flavor of "International border crossing". Note the flags on model and actual versions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhine_Bridge,_Kehl 

Attachments

Images (1)
  • Strasbourg_-_Pont_du_Chemin_de_fer_sur_le_Rhin_carte_postale_1920
Last edited by Ace

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×