Skip to main content

Yesterday I was able to buy a few Menards cars from my local store. One of them was the new Saskatchewan hopper.

It's a nicely made car. However when I tried running it on my Lionel O36 Fastrack I found it had trouble smoothly running around the curves. At times some adjoining cars would cause the Menards car to derail. So I looked a little closer at the car.

I found that the trucks couldn't swing fully due to two things:

1. The stirrup steps interfered with the wheels and

2. the body rubbed on the top of the truck sideframes.

 To fix the problem I first took a single edge razor blade and carefully removed a tiny sliver of plastic hanging down below the bottom edge of the body at both sides and ends of the car. That fixed the side frame rubbing.

Secondly I chose to file off a  bit of the black plastic on the back edge of all 4 stirrups. The filing was not noticeable due to the solid black color of the plastic. Be careful not to scratch either the body paint or trucks when filing.

The truck is removable from the body with just one screw. But you can't easily separate the truck into it's parts. I thought about adding a spacing washer to lower the sideframes and wheels but it looked like dis-assembly would be a mistake. So I chose the razor blade/file fix.

It's no biggie as I don't mind a bit of adjustment on a $20.00 car.

After the work being done the car smoothly negotiated the O36 curves without any trouble and have not derailed again.

This is the only Menards hopper I own so I can't say if other versions have this issue.

Mark

Last edited by banjoflyer
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I have some of the original hoppers from back when they started releasing these, and never had any problems. I just picked up the new Union Pacific covered hopper the other day off of the shelf and it has the same probably as Banjoflyer's from above.  I picked up my order of 6 more hoppers this morning, but have not un boxed them yet. I don't see it as a big deal, IMO always fixable!! Menard's keep em' coming!

Jeff

I just bought 2 of these hoppers. A BNSF and a Saskatchewan. Beautiful cars but both cars had one truck installed wrong. I did not want to send them back.

There is a lip on the end  of the truck mounting plate that should slip over the plastic cross rail on the end of the car. Both cars had the lip mounted below the bar and the trucks were tipped up and not parallel to the track.  One pair of wheels was on the rail,  the other pair above the rail.

Use a very small head Phillips screwdriver. Remove the one mounting screw, slip the truck lip over the plastic bar,  reinstall the screw, and it is fixed.

Add Reply

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×