Has anyone purchased the just released RK Imperial N&W J 30-1633-1? I would be interested in any reviews or opinions from owners. Thanks.
Replies sorted oldest to newest
Didn't buy one but saw one run and on the shelf at Catoctin Mountain Trains. Overall, a nice engine. Runs great. Only thing I didn't like was the lack of fat roller bearing rods found on the real 611. Otherwise, had terrific sound. Whistle sounds like the exact one on the 611 last time it ran in the 1990s.
If I had the $$$, one would've followed me home.
I finally sold enough other items to fund the purchase of one. ;-) I just ordered one from one of our Forum sponsors and received word it shipped today. I will be away next week when it arrives, so won't see it until a week from Monday. I will report in once I have had a chance to give it a run.
It is a really nice loco. I think it is very good value for the money.
But I have a scale Legacy model and one J is enough for me. I
I have admired the 611 J since I first saw it in Roanoke 25 years ago. My favorite streamlined steamer.
The scale Legacy is a great choice for your layout, Lee!! I would have to sell my whole roster of locomotives to pay for a Legacy. lol I certainly enjoy watching the neat locomotives on your layout!
I recently received one from my wife for our 30th wedding anniversary. Me and my dad went to Mr. Muffins Trains and she told me if I saw something that I really wanted to go ahead and pick it up and she would pay for it as a gift from her to me. When people come downstairs to see my train layout this engine quickly becomes their favorite one. I think it is because of the amount of smoke it puts out plus its streamlined looks. The added bonus for me is that the passenger sound effects calls out that one of the stops on its route is Cincinnati which is my home town. Runs and sounds great for the money, I would also highly recommend Mr. Muffins Trains for there friendly service and very cool store, well worth the drive.
Attachments
This isn't really going to be very helpful, but as a default, I think the Imperial line from MTH, in fact the entire RK line, is so under-rated. They have all the same guts as the top of the line Premier. So you're getting extreme value when compared to any competitor's offerings. And, it is really one-stop-shopping for a very complete fleet, given you get the full suite of features in any MTH locomotive, despite entry-level prices and mid-range prices in the non-Premier stuff, and they can all be operated using one system and remote.
Peter
I have admired the 611 J since I first saw it in Roanoke 25 years ago. My favorite streamlined steamer.
The scale Legacy is a great choice for your layout, Lee!! I would have to sell my whole roster of locomotives to pay for a Legacy. lol I certainly enjoy watching the neat locomotives on your layout!
We have one 611 left in stock if anyone is interested.
Thanks
Pat
# 611 4-8-4 Imperial "J" Northern Steam Engine w/Proto-Sound 3.0 - Norfolk & Western 611 | ||||||||||||
# 611 4-8-4 Imperial "J" Northern Steam Engine w/Proto-Sound 3.0 - Norfolk & Western 611 http://www.patstrains.com/View...Details=View+Details A visit to the Norfolk & Western in the early 1950s was like a scene from Jurassic Park: prehistoric beasts romping in their natural mountain habitat. At a time when other roads were letting their remaining steam engines rot away and giving them minimal service in dirty, dingy, soon-to-close facilities, the N&W was still running a first-class steam operation and even building new power. With its main line through some of the nation's richest coalfields, it was still betting on the future of steam; as late as 1955, the N&W didn't roster a single diesel. The majority of traffic was handled by what N&W fans call the "holy trinity of steam": the massive Y6 2-8-8-2; the articulated greyhound Class A; and the N&W's glamour girl, the streamlined Class J. The Class J 4-8-4 was an engine of quiet superlatives. Handsome, powerful (5100 hp), and, as a test on the Pennsylvania Railroad proved, capable of hauling 15 cars at 110 mph, it was designed and styled not by one of the big three builders (ALCo, Baldwin, and Lima) or a famous designer like Raymond Loewy or Henry Dreyfuss, but by the N&W's home-grown team of designers and craftsmen at the road's Roanoke, Virginia shops. For power and quick acceleration through mountainous territory, and to make room for the largest possible boiler, they equipped the streamlined J with 70" drivers - unusually small for a 4-8-4 and fully 10" smaller than the Southern Pacific's Daylight GS-4 of the same wheel arrangement. Built in several groups between 1941 and 1950, a mere fourteen J's were able to handle 80% of the N&W's passenger traffic, because their designers addressed one of steam power's key weaknesses: down time for maintenance and repairs. Equipped with Timken roller bearings on all axles and rods, Timken-designed lightweight pistons and rods, and an automatic lubrication system that reached more than 200 points including the bell bearings, the Js were designed to go a quarter-million miles between scheduled shop visits. Like a race car, they were engineered for quick pit stops: in less than an hour, a J could be fully serviced, lubricated, filled with coal and water and ready for its next dash over the road's 676-mile main line between Norfolk and Cincinnati, hauling the deluxe daylight Powhatan Arrow or the overnight Pocahontas. Our Imperial N&W J is more fun to operate than any previous version of this magnificent locomotive, with its N&W whistle, passenger station announcements, synchronized chuff and puffing smoke, and speed control so smooth you won't spill the water in the diner. Features Die-Cast Boiler and Chassis Die-Cast Tender Body Authentic Paint Scheme Real Coal Load in Tender Die-Cast Locomotive and Tender Trucks Engineer and Fireman Figures Metal Handrails and Whistle Metal Wheels and Axles Remote Controlled Proto-Coupler Prototypical Rule 17 Lighting Constant Voltage Headlight Operating Firebox Glow Operating Numberboard Lights Tender Backup Light Tender Truck Safety Chains LED-Illuminated Engine Class Lights Separately Added Metal Grab Irons Legible Builder's Plates Cab Interior Light Painted Cab Backhead Gauges Precision Flywheel-Equipped Motor Synchronized Puffing ProtoSmoke System Locomotive Speed Control In Scale MPH Increments Wireless Drawbar Onboard DCC Receiver Proto-Sound 3.0 With The Digital Command System Featuring: Passenger Station Proto-Effects Unit Measures:22 1/8 x 2 1/2 x 3 7/8 Operates On O-31 Curves Steam DCC Features Headlight/Tail light Bell Whistle Start-up/Shut-down Passenger Station/Freight Yard Sounds All Other Lights (On/Off) Master Volume Front Coupler Rear Coupler Forward Signal Reverse Signal Grade Crossing Smoke On/Off Smoke Volume Idle Sequence 3 Idle Sequence 2 Idle Sequence 1 Extended Start-up Extended Shut-down One Shot Doppler Coupler Slack Coupler Close Single Horn Blast Engine Sounds Brake Sounds Cab Chatter Feature Reset Labor Chuff Drift Chuff
|
I have admired the 611 J since I first saw it in Roanoke 25 years ago. My favorite streamlined steamer.
The scale Legacy is a great choice for your layout, Lee!! I would have to sell my whole roster of locomotives to pay for a Legacy. lol I certainly enjoy watching the neat locomotives on your layout!
Thank you, Pat!!
My wife was pleased you had one so I could get it right away. I'll be away at a school for my work when it arrives, but she will take good care of it until I get home Friday!
Is there a difference between the RK Imperial 611 that Mark just purchased (from MTH 2014 Vol.1 20-1633-1) and the RK Imperial 611 from the catalog just released (MTH 2015 Vol.2 30-1674-1)?
Peter
Peter is right. I actually pre ordered the one from the 2015 catalog. Then Pat called me to see if I wanted the one from the 2014 catalog. Specs seem the same and the price is the same, so I took one from his stock. If there is a difference I don't care. My locomotives are all used, and the newest was from 2007. It's like buying an end of the year new car. ;-) They must be expecting a lot of sales this year because of the added interest of the 611 being refurbished.
This isn't really going to be very helpful, but as a default, I think the Imperial line from MTH, in fact the entire RK line, is so under-rated. They have all the same guts as the top of the line Premier. So you're getting extreme value when compared to any competitor's offerings. And, it is really one-stop-shopping for a very complete fleet, given you get the full suite of features in any MTH locomotive, despite entry-level prices and mid-range prices in the non-Premier stuff, and they can all be operated using one system and remote.
Peter
The good thing is, in another 5 years I may be retired, and can take a trip where I want to go, like back to Roanoke to see the real J which I first saw 25 years ago.
Thanks Pat!
Attachments
Looks like a real beauty ! I love the Imperial items, so much detail! I'd like to get one someday. Hope you have fun running it :>
Thank you! Yes, it runs very nicely! Now I have a nice set of Williams Powhatan Arrow cars to go with it.
I have one of the first few mth n&W j.It has a piston smoker in it and pulls with the best of them.I might get it up graded to proto 2 sound.I just have not made my mind up yet.I rode behind the real j from spencer nc to lynchburg vir and back.I will never forget her whistle.So deep deep and powerful sounding.