Why did MTH sell its best tooling, molds and design rights? In my opinion, the answer is easy. It is the hallmark of a failing business desperate for cash flow that is unable to borrow any more money from its lenders. (This ship is sinking fast! Everybody in the small lifeboat! Hope we have enough water to survive!)
Mannyrock
First of all, how do you define best tooling, molds and designs? Atlas and Lionel bought what made sense to them, whether this is the best of the best I don't know. We know that MTH was up for sale and a deal fell through to buy the whole business, we know that DCS was spun off, and obviously that a decision was made to stay in business. If the business was in trouble, desperate for cash flow, who would even consider buying it? They would do due diligence and run the other way and that is not what happened, per Scott S the buyers associates and family simply didn't want to be in that business. Put it this way, if they sold the lines to lionel and Atlas out of desperation they would have been in trouble when the original selling of the company was anticipated and that doesn't appear to be the case.
My guess, for what it is worth, is that the deal to sell the product lines to Lionel and Atlas was a done deal and there was a change of heart with the rest of the business. I don't know if Mike decided a smaller MTH was easier to handle, I don't know if the employees basically have taken it over and selling the old building and the sale of the lines went to Mike and then perhaps the employees bought the remaining piece (or maybe Mike still has a stake). I do think this is something of a chaotic transition, it sounds from what Scott posted that this was done pretty fast, so this could very well reflect that, that the deal with Lionel and Atlas happened then there was some kind of change of heart.
My one concern with MTH is the one I said in another post, that right now there are a lot of questions with what MTH is going to be going forward. If they don't have a repair service, will people be willing to buy their product? What exactly are their plans, is it just special orders? Are they going to have new products or is it just 'living off' of their existing tooling to get as much out of it as they can, kind of like Lionel did back when it was trying to hang on in the 60s? Hopefully there will be some clarity, would like there to be an MTH when I finally can start buying new stuff again when I have my layout in running shape