Skip to main content

This maybe a silly question as I'm sure I already know the answer to this, but I need confirmation. 
Has MTH made a scale version of the PRR S-2 turbine 6200 (similar to the Lionel scale turbine)? 

Some I know claims to have one, but everything I have found in research tells me it's a railking o-27 one. Now I may be wrong and it could be a uncataloged model, but with no photo evidence and no part number to go off of, I'm clueless. 

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

MTH has not offered a Scale PRR S-2 Turbine.The've offered Railking/Railking Imperial model and the Rugged Rails "Bantam" turbine (Similar in size to the Lionel Post war model).

 

The Railking/RK Imperial is about 80% of full scale and is still a large and imposing locomotive. 

 

Hope this helps.

The story is that the Lionel S2 Turbine was one of the Mike Wolf-Lionel partnership projects before the relationship went south. I believe Lionel owns the tooling outright.  Lionel has released it twice -- once in Conventional, and once again in TMCC and it's doubtful they'd loan out the tooling for a competing product, but you never know. About the only alternative I can think of would be to re-motor a conventional Lionel S2 with a can motor and install a Proto-2 kit.

I have the ProtoSound equipped one, and it is a nice sized locomotive.  You can tell it's not scale when placed next to the PRR T-1, but it doesn't look bad if you don't know better.  It does go well with my scale K-Line PRR bay window caboose, but does seem small with scale reefers and big when traditional sized stock cars.

There are several of the scale Lionel 6-18010 conventional version on the big auction site now. These have no traction tires and have the reputation of being poor pullers. They are, however very pretty.

 

I have the 3rd Rail version, and it is a great puller. As for the 072, keep in mind that is a minimum. The bigger, the better.

Last edited by Gilly@N&W

Well I guess that answers my question then. 
I didn't think they made a full scale turbine...but I did know about the newer Lionel one. (which im a huge fan of but sadly don't own) 

I'd like to one day get a scale turbine because the very first Lionel post war engine I got (and what really got my started into O-scale (was a post war Lionel 2020 Turbine. So i'd like a scale one to go with it, but not til I get a layout with O-72 curves. 

Attachments

Images (2)
  • Lionel 2020 1948 Steam Tubrine (PRR 6200) (1)
  • IMG_20150611_222205

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×