Forgive me if this has been discussed before, but I would like to share my observations with 5 volt MTH PS2 boards and would like some feedback. I personally have yet to see anyone else observe this on here. I have a few engines with 5 Volt boards, and from what I’ve observed, they seem to smoke more dense and have louder sound than their 3 Volt counterparts. My main example is my RailKing PRR L-1 Mikado (30-1164-1) from 2000. When set to max smoke and the labor button held down on the DCS remote, the smoke is extremely thick. Better than a 3 volt RailKing Rugged Rails 2-8-0 I have, which is still pretty good itself. Both engines have brand new wicks and I’m using JT’s Mega Steam smoke fluid. I have also noticed that the max sound volume on my 5 Volt engines, again, especially the Mikado, is very loud and “fuller” sounding compared to my several 3 volt engines. I’m assuming this is due to the 16 ohm speakers they use. My question is, is this just coincidence or in my head, or is there really something to the 5 volt engines having better smoke output and louder sounds? I’m looking forward to seeing what you all have to say about this.
Replies sorted oldest to newest
I don't know about the smoke but the sounds are definitely louder on the ps 2 5 volt boards because there pushed to the limit if I remember correctly the 5 volt amps are 5 watt where the three volt boards amp are 3 watt! the five boards are driven harder then they should be and is one reason the amps fail on 5 volt boards!
Alan
Actually, the TDA7056A on the 5V board is rated at 3W and the TPA2000D1 on the 3V board is rated at 2W. However, I personally haven't seen any significant volume difference between the two boards, and I get more than enough smoke from either of them as well.
GRJ, can you tell us what is the output wattage on the PS3 boards ? Are all PS3 boards out put the same ? ie Diesel , Steam or up grade kit boards ? My observations have been a wide variance of volume level, seems most diesels are adequate, however the last Alco S-2 switcher seemed very poor, whereas the 44 toners seem OK, ( speaker size seems comparable) also most of the steam engines seem to have way lower volume than previous PS2's. Is this just a software scenario or is it a hardware. If it is software cannot we load older PS2 sound sets with greater volume into the PS3 boards to achieve the greater volume ? Thanks Dean
I believe that most of the sound volume issues with PS/3 have been laid at the doorstep of the sound files. Several sound files have been reissued to make sounds louder. A steam PS/3 board set will want to see a PS/3 steam sound file. With the PS32 board that is used for PS/3 upgrades, you can load either PS/2 3V files or PS/3 files.
Another cool thing about these 5 volt boards is that they are very smooth at 1 scale MPH.(at least mine are). I cant get a proto 3 to smooth out til about 3 or 4 scale mph. I know I know I know.........these are "ticking time bombs", but I have not lost one yet.