Skip to main content

Hello, I am trying to put a new smoke unit in a 1981 MPC #746 Reissue from the 80's. Everything is fine with the train,until I go to add the smoke unit to the "HOT" terminal on the e-unit.Then It shows a short.

 I take the smoke unit wire back off, everything is fine again. I'm thinking this smoke unit must need to be grounded someplace. This is one of the fancy ones that shot smoke out of the sides by the driverods.   When it does run,(for 3-4 seconds before it shorts out, and the breaker pops on the Z-750)it is working fantastic .  

What am I missing here ?? I bought this unit as a NOS replacement, and it does work great.Do I run the lead for the smoke unit somewhere else?,or do I just need to ground it??  

Please help, been fighting with this for long enough,I need some advice. Anyone have a wiring diagram for this Loco or not?

 

 Thank You,Kenny Baughman

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

My guess is the heater element is shorted out. When the heater has become overheated the core becomes conductive and glows cherry red, and makes lots of smoke, for a few seconds before the circuit breaker pops. Are you sure the smoke unit is really new? Does the unit have that stinky overheated smell? Could the headlight bulb be defective, or maybe the wires to the headlight be bad?

I don't know how many ohms the smoke unit is.It is similar tot the one in the original #746,but it is larger, and has tubes running out of the top to the sides, to produce the steam cylinder effect.  

Are you sure that 75 watts is not enough for a loco??  I have some 110 watt postwar transformers I could try it out with. I tried it with a CW-80 also, and it shorted it out ,once I added the smoke unit in the mix

It's pretty close to the limit on both of those, but trying a better, more powerful conventional transformer is a step in the right direction to troubleshoot.

I am very familiar with the 8100, but you will need to check the smoke unit impedance too, with an ohmmeter,  to determine if it's really shorted or it's just very low resistance. The headlamp is wired in parallel to the smoke unit, so remove the bulb before testing. You can also test the smoke unit alone by powering it from a transformer with alligator clips before connecting it to the locomotive. Be sure there is at least 12 drops of smoke fluid it before testing.

I would guess that anything below ~16-19 ohms, is too low for plastic bodied smoke units.

What happened to the original smoke unit?

Where would I put the alligator clips to test it? Obioulsly, one clip would go to the place where the wire running to the e-unit goes.Where would I put the ground?,or second clip?   The original unit still works,I just thought a fresh one would produce more smoke,,and it had a few leaks around the high temp cement . 

Ive never seen a plastic smoke unit except old Marx. But there are only two connections to a heating element 98% of the time, be it a space heater or smoke unit. They are just resistors in any form. That's why he suggested an ohm reading (you really should put aside a few bucks for a cheap harbor freight unit, or eBay special[$15-30] It's a valuable tool in the hobby)

You've found one lead, Jump it to the hot leg, (center). There is either another wire to be found, or a connection to the chassis somewhere to supply a "ground" to the common leg.(outer rails) that might just be a tab touching a mounting screw or something.???

  A fan unit might complicate it slightly with three or four wires. But it doesn't sound like it. Can you clue us incase Rob doesn't answer right away?

kennyb posted:

Where would I put the alligator clips to test it?

To the two light bulb / headlamp leads.

kennyb posted:

The original unit still works,I just thought a fresh one would produce more smoke,,and it had a few leaks around the high temp cement . 

Unless the specification of the element itself is changed, there is no improving it. They were not prolific smokers. I have sealed those leaks with Walthers Goo.

The usual issue with these is that the surgical tubing used for the steam chest emissions gets brittle & breaks.

For those unfamiliar with this unit, it is a modification of the first 909 smoke fluid equipped loco, the 746, introduced in 1957. On the 8100, there are fitting at the top of the bowl to allow for steam chest emissions tubes.

746:

CropperCapture[73]

8100/611:

8100-60-1CropperCapture[72]

Attachments

Images (3)
  • CropperCapture[73]
  • 8100-60-1
  • CropperCapture[72]

Does this engine have an electronic e-unit and a railsounds tender?

Blue wire, hot comes from the motor terminal and other wire to chassis ground

Edit; I am not very good with the supplements - the 6-8100 in 1-9 has no wiring diagram.

Edit 2; added 6-8100 from S1-9 - no wiring, but does show a fuse for the smoke unit.

Attachments

Last edited by Moonman

It works fine with the old smoke unit in it, but does not produce smoke like the replacement one that is shorting out.How/or Can I fix the new one?The new one gets HOT right away, and is producing smoke like crazy, but is shorting everything out after 3-4 seconds.There is nothing wrong with the old smoke unit, but I wish I could get the smoke coming out of the one that is shorting, it looks fabulous before it shorts out!!! 

Red hi-temp automotive silicone would be another GREAT heat proof glue and sealer. It can handle exhaust pipe heat on cars no problem. It would let you reopen the thing one day too. JB Weld is my buddy, but kinda permanent.

Was that unit from 57 plastic? Bakelight?  Must have been a good one, I don't recall ever seeing one sitting on Gramps bench.

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×