Skip to main content

Just picked up one of the Amtrak P42 Genesis 50th Anniversary Engines from Atlas and they look great!  Matching cars are in transit.  This one happens to be a Phase VI version.

IMG_4982

Here it is with matching cars!    Jump to 23:00 to see it running.

Attachments

Images (1)
  • IMG_4982
Last edited by Sean's Train Depot
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Just picked up one of the Amtrak P42 Genesis 50th Anniversary Engines from Atlas and they look great!  Matching cars are in transit.  This one happens to be a Phase VI version.

IMG_4982

I saw the 2-Rail pilot model of the P42 and Amfleet car at the March Meet.  While I don't expect brass quality from Atlas, I found it disappointing.  Golden Gate Depot did a much better job on the Amfleet cars and I expect their P42 to look much better when they're delivered.  The new Atlas Autorack that was just released is magnificent!   Why can't the rest of their new product look as nice?

@Brad Kowal posted:

I saw the 2-Rail pilot model of the P42 and Amfleet car at the March Meet.  While I don't expect brass quality from Atlas, I found it disappointing.  Golden Gate Depot did a much better job on the Amfleet cars and I expect their P42 to look much better when they're delivered.  The new Atlas Autorack that was just released is magnificent!   Why can't the rest of their new product look as nice?

Plating goes a long way...  Hopefully in the next run.

Thanks!

- Mario

@Brad Kowal posted:

I saw the 2-Rail pilot model of the P42 and Amfleet car at the March Meet.  While I don't expect brass quality from Atlas, I found it disappointing.  Golden Gate Depot did a much better job on the Amfleet cars and I expect their P42 to look much better when they're delivered.  The new Atlas Autorack that was just released is magnificent!   Why can't the rest of their new product look as nice?

Because in buying MTH's tooling for the Amfleet cars they probably saved a boatload of cash over essentially cloning GGD's efforts (and avoid over-serving the market for finescale versions of these cars). It's probably also why Atlas didn't buy MTH's autorack tooling -- their Gunderson model was probably already in the works (or planning stages) when that opportunity presented itself.

---PCJ

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×