In the Lionel 2023 vol 2 catalog I see were Lionel will be offering 2-8-0 Condolidation locomotives.Does anyone know what motor they will using.I belong to a modular club and I would like to pull around 20 cars for about 45 minutes and just want to know pulling power and also are these MTH old tooling . Thanks
Replies sorted oldest to newest
The motor won’t be you’re limiting factor. The weight of the engine, how good the traction tires are and the weight of you’re twenty cars. I would think 20 cars a little much for this smaller size engine.
I have a MTH Pennsy Consolidation and it can pull 15-20 with no effort. This locomotive is from years ago also
I would be surprised if the '23 volume 2 Consolidations are any different "under the hood" from the Pennsy-style consolidations in the 2018 big book. The motor in those was a medium-duty Mabuchi RS-385PH, and I believe the gear ratio was 16.5:1, back-drivable.
I don't think that you'll hurt the loco pulling 20 free-rolling plastic cars on flat track and broad curves. By free-rolling, I'm excluding die-cast metal cars, and passenger cars with the added drag of pick-up rollers and wipers. Any more than 20 freight cars, and I think you would be working the loco pretty hard. My $.02.
If you're pulling modern cars with needle-point axles, 20 cars on level track is child's play. The plot thickens if you're running on grades, or pulling older post-war cars that have more rolling resistance.
You're worried about the Consolidation pulling them? How about a BEEP with no traction tires and five heavyweight 18" passenger cars? Like I said, level track is easy.
Attachments
After watching any Mr Muffins train running videos I never worry anymore about putting too many cars behind any new engine. I know he MU’s some trains but also runs single engine.