Originally Posted by Erik C Lindgren:
True story at out local train show:
A guy came up looked at Rick Trinkle's Dash units running his worm train and insisted we were operating a larger scale than "o gauge" as he stated it. "That's not O gauge it's like larger is this gauge 1???, I have those same engines in O gauge MTH and they are the best you can buy..." He exclaimed - implying that his MTH models were spot on in the dimensions area. I corrected him and told him these were 1/48. His response to me was stand offish and furreled his brow and growled at me. "Those are not O gauge.. I know I'm a TCA member since 1995 and know O gauge when I see it; this is not O gauge!" I asked him politely to bring over a o gauge model and sit it on the track to prove it.. He walked away- rather mad.
I feel bad at the fact some many fine models were produced by MTH to "fit the box" dimensions. I guess a handful were scale however by far most of these models were scale for some parts then shortened or truncated to assume some role as to fit a O-54 curve somewhere I don't know. This dynamic does not appear in HO like our scale. Still my models run on 1/45 track.
Go figure
I understand, Erik. I've been on the other end of it. Guy comes in during an open house and looks at my train full of Weaver and Atlas O scale cars (with scale wheels and Kadees yet) pulled by a pair of MTH U25's (also with scale wheels and Kadees) and says it's not scale sized (probably looked at that third rail and got confused). Was an H.O. modeler from a local club. I didn't have to correct him as a visitor was a former member of Citrus Empire O scale club and did it for me.
I guess it all depends on what bubble people live in.
The locomotives are beautiful, by the way. How do the newer OMI units run?