Skip to main content

This may be a better question for the DCS forum but I figured I'd check here first...

I've got an MTH/LionelCorp 4696 Brass Piper (Protosound 2) on the Christmas layout right now. I fired it up this afternoon and noticed the smoke unit fan was running really loud with the engine idling. It's smoking at max and doesn't seem to let up. If I turn off smoke via the DCS remote then the fan stops, as expected. If I leave smoke on and get the engine moving forward it smokes normally, with only intermittent smoke fan pulses in sync with the speed. But once the engine stops, the smoke unit fan spins up to max and it smokes continuously.

This isn't normal, right? I don't remember the engine doing this before. But my kids (whom I love *ever* so much) sometimes operate the trains and don't always do a great job shutting them down properly. I'm wondering if something got a little messed up here. I tried doing a factory reset on the engine via the DCS remote but that didn't change anything. Am I imagining this? The engine shouldn't be smoking forever at idle, right? Any other suggestions?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Todd Pytel posted:

 the smoke unit fan was running really loud with the engine idling. It's smoking at max and doesn't seem to let up. This isn't normal, right?

I don't remember the engine doing this before.

The engine shouldn't be smoking forever at idle, right? Any other suggestions?

I think the fact that the motor is loud, is what now drew more attention to it. The motor might be going bad? 

It smokes at idle as long as it's turned on. The wick does change some smoke volume as it goes thru it's life. If it was partially blocking the flow it may have lessoned that as it burned in. Maybe you had the smoke volume set differently on the DCS remote and it got changed by someone?

Later diesel models had smoke motors wired differently so that the smoke volume increased as the diesel motor revs went up. So they smoke less at idle.

That's the only change I'm aware of myself. I don't have any tinplate and I'm not aware of this method of wiring for it. Even if it was, it wouldn't change itself with use!

Bruk posted:

With all MTH PS2 and PS3 enignes, it is normal for the smoke unit to be constant when in neutral and is is normal to puff in sync with the chuff sounds

almost all except diesels

Last edited by Engineer-Joe

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×