Skip to main content

So I picked up my RK F-3 ABA last week and had an opportunity to give a test run this weekend.   My Impressions are:

 

- I can confirm that the sound in PS-3 is definitely off a little, but not across the board.  The bell and engine sounds, for example, are loud and crystal clear but the horn is somewhat muffled.  It just doesn't have the blast that my PS-2 E-8's have (or any other PS-2 engine I own, for that matter).  I can compensate for it to an extent by lowering the volume on the other sounds and cranking the horn to 100, but it only helps some.  

 

- Visually, it's fine.   Definitely not "premier" level, but good for me and the kids. Enough detail to keep it interesting, and the paint job is great.  Didn't realize just how long 40 inches is on the layout, and I may end up running it A-A moving forward.  

 

- It runs smooth - REALLY smooth.  3 scale MPH gets it moving without much hesitation and at 5 MPH it's silk.  At the moment, I've got a mix of ten or so boxcars hooked up and performance is solid across the board.  Forward, reverse, turnouts in both directions - no issues.  

 

- This engine has the worst, and I mean THE WORST PFA freight announcement I've ever heard.   I didn't think it could get any worse than the stooge on my RK Allegheny who manages to spill water on his feet, but the entire sequence is wrapped around... wait for it... a downed tree on the tracks!   Literally, its "Hey, there's a tree on the line!!!!" and then the crew decides after calling it into dispatch that they can move it themselves.  So the doors open, there's a pause ( I assume they go move the tree...) they come back, tell dispatch the line is clear, and head on down the line.   That's it.  I don't buy these things for the PFA experience, so it's more humorous than anything, but who thinks these things up?   My SD70 has a nice, meaningful rap, and most of my passenger engines are good as well, calling out names of nearby towns and such.  Unless I'm missing something, this one is a dud.   May have to download something new at some point.  

 

Overall I really like it and it will be a fixture on the layout, but I may have to resort to doing my own voice-overs

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I definitely agree that MTH's PFA is ridiculous... the only thing worse is Lionel's crewtalk/towercom. But I think my favorite thing about both of them is that the back and forth dialog of the "crew" is very clearly and obviously the same person! At least the MTH guy tries to do two different voices, albeit not very well. Of the PFA dialog I have heard, hands down the worst one is from the McDonald's F40PH set circa 2003: "aaaahhh...would you look at all that FOOD! Those all beef patties." Imagine that line spoken by someone who is high and looking for munchies, and there you go!

The guy that announces the station stops on the Proto 2 Trolleys and Subway cars gets my nerves. I just turned them off. Actually they never made station stop announcements on the old subway trains anyway. At least since I remember riding back to the late 50's in Philly. On trolleys and busses it would depend on the operator. Today they use automated announcements that get to your nerves after a while as well lol.

Post

OGR Publishing, Inc., 1310 Eastside Centre Ct, Ste 6, Mountain Home, AR 72653
800-980-OGRR (6477)
www.ogaugerr.com

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×