Skip to main content

How about a certain number of units undecorated , and decal sets for various roads , so you get more units in the order to reduce price and also being able to cover the ones and two's of various roads.

With custom decal makers , it would not be a stretch because the decal sets for deisels would not have much nomenclature like freight cars, also offer road names less cab numbers , with a small dry transfer set for multiple road numbers .

If Scott will do the Big Red #990, I will swing and spring 4 sure!  Scott will need to make sure that the hood end lighting is functional, unlike the current MTH units.  Also hoping that these units will be geared more realistically than typical 2 /3 rail locos.  We don't need to go 140smph at 15v.  Lower gears = better low speed, and the Non-China drive will help a bunch too.  As the EMD salesman said when these guys first appeared... " All the advantages of a Shay, with none of the disadvantages !"  U-Rah ! 

Originally Posted by Scratchbuilder1-48:

How about a certain number of units undecorated ,Atlas O has done this for some time, The GP 7 pictured was undecorated, unfortunately these undecorated models, have to be pre-ordered, there is no price difference.  It's an excellent idea, but most likely a very small part of the market.  and decal sets for various roads , Keep in mind that most paint and litho detail on these units is done with paint stamp tooling that is pretty sophisticated. Weaver does  paint stamp detail at the facility in Northumberland, PA.  Seldom would you see decals on these newer models, IMO. That being said, decal or dry transfer vendors have become more difficult to find. IMO.  so you get more units in the order to reduce price and also being able to cover the ones and two's of various roads.

With custom decal makers , it would not be a stretch because the decal sets for deisels would not have much nomenclature like freight cars, also offer road names less cab numbers , with a small dry transfer set for multiple road numbers . 

I also did custom work with These Atlas SW9 models.

 

Last edited by Mike CT

If 12 units is the minimum required for a road name, perhaps it might be possible for Scott to add more road names onto his order form. That way people have to put their money where their wishes are.

 

It would be helpful (but might be an IT pain) to have a counter up until 12 units so if a road name is stuck at 11 orders, someone might order a second and push it to the minimum.

 

 

Well, I may as well throw another ingredient into the pot!!  I'd like to see a low hood sd9 version done in DMIR,  B&LE,  or UNION RR.  The DMIR had quite a number of the low hood versions that ended up on other sister railroads.  I know the UNION had 4 of them in the late 70's because I used to see them when I worked at the USS Homestead works and around the area where I lived in West Mifflin. They were initially operating in their DMIR colors,  but were eventually all repainted into the UNION blue and white.  Anyone else interested in low hood units? 

 

Nick

Originally Posted by jonnyspeed:
Originally Posted by Bill McBride:

A Sunset GP30 would be quite the offering as well...

 

 

From your lips to Scott's ears! I'll take a few GP30s for sure!

And with my luck the announcement will come out right after I finish my GP30 conversion project. Then I'll be deciding on getting another one or two.

 

A CF7 would be a much better choice, though. PRB did one (Topeka Cab) several years ago in brass, but there hasn't been one mass produced. The key here would be to offer them in the branch lines and LA Junction, where they spent a long time in service (some still in service today). Of course, there would have to be sufficient reservations.

Last edited by AGHRMatt
Originally Posted by AGHRMatt:
Originally Posted by jonnyspeed:
Originally Posted by Bill McBride:

A Sunset GP30 would be quite the offering as well...

 

 

From your lips to Scott's ears! I'll take a few GP30s for sure!

And with my luck the announcement will come out right after I finish my GP30 conversion project. Then I'll be deciding on getting another one or two.

 

A CF7 would be a much better choice, though. PRB did one (Topeka Cab) several years ago in brass, but there hasn't been one mass produced. The key here would be to offer them in the branch lines and LA Junction, where they spent a long time in service (some still in service today). Of course, there would have to be sufficient reservations.

 

Matt, work more quickly on that GP30. Better yet, start on a CF7.

 

I (and John Albee) always thought that  CF7 would be like printing money between Santa Fe, LAJ, and a host of modern short lines. Athearn has certainly produced a ton in HO.

 

It's a perfect engine for those in, or interested in O, with little space.

 

 

 "The key here would be to offer them in the branch lines and LA Junction, where they spent a long time in service (some still in service today)"

 

   Yeah, CF7's have lasted a long time. Roaring Camp tourist line on the ex SP Santa Cruz branch has two.   GP30's were not all that popular or long lasting compared to SD9,GP9's or most  later power.....DaveB 

Originally Posted by rheil:

 It sure seems the SD demonstrator scheme will prove successful for Sunset. To me it is reminiscent of the colorful scheme used on the FM Train master demonstrators. The FM demonstrator scheme was sure successful for C&LS and MTH.

 

HW - might be good to let Scott know which roads tried the SD demonstrator.

For the masses that were unlucky enough to get the C&LS demos or weren't in the MTH club and missed out there... it might be a stretch but a 3rd rail TM1/TM2 demo would be nice someday. 

Originally Posted by Rule292:
Originally Posted by rheil:

 It sure seems the SD demonstrator scheme will prove successful for Sunset. To me it is reminiscent of the colorful scheme used on the FM Train master demonstrators. The FM demonstrator scheme was sure successful for C&LS and MTH.

 

HW - might be good to let Scott know which roads tried the SD demonstrator.

For the masses that were unlucky enough to get the C&LS demos or weren't in the MTH club and missed out there... it might be a stretch but a 3rd rail TM1/TM2 demo would be nice someday.  

The MTH FM Train Master demos, surprisingly were NOT offered in 2-Rail with fixed pilots & full length hand railings. Thus, I did not purchase one from those dealers that did obtain some.

Originally Posted by Hot Water:
Originally Posted by Rule292:
Originally Posted by rheil:

 It sure seems the SD demonstrator scheme will prove successful for Sunset. To me it is reminiscent of the colorful scheme used on the FM Train master demonstrators. The FM demonstrator scheme was sure successful for C&LS and MTH.

 

HW - might be good to let Scott know which roads tried the SD demonstrator.

For the masses that were unlucky enough to get the C&LS demos or weren't in the MTH club and missed out there... it might be a stretch but a 3rd rail TM1/TM2 demo would be nice someday.  

The MTH FM Train Master demos, surprisingly were NOT offered in 2-Rail with fixed pilots & full length hand railings. Thus, I did not purchase one from those dealers that did obtain some.

Thanks for the info on the 2r versions.  I sent an inquiry to MTH once I saw somewhere on here that they were being done and never got a response... I guess this is why.

 

Originally Posted by Rule292:

For the masses that were unlucky enough to get the C&LS demos or weren't in the MTH club and missed out there... it might be a stretch but a 3rd rail TM1/TM2 demo would be nice someday.  

The MTH FM Train Master demos, surprisingly were NOT offered in 2-Rail with fixed pilots & full length hand railings. Thus, I did not purchase one from those dealers that did obtain some.

Thanks for the info on the 2r versions.  I sent an inquiry to MTH once I saw somewhere on here that they were being done and never got a response... I guess this is why. 

 

I must admit that I could NOT figure why MTH did not offer that FM Demo styling in both 3-Rail and 2-Rail models, especially since their Train Master model was retooled some years ago, for both 2-Rail AND 3-Rail (with both of the underframe configurations), and they have been offering all the other "announced road names" in 2-Rail AND 3-Rail. Go figure.

Asked Scott to put me down for both numbers of demonstrators .

 

MTH told me they do not do 2-rail of anything in their so called "limited edition" stuff which was what they considered the TM demonstrators.  I Grrr'd a bit and they said such things were exclusive for their "classic O Gauge" dealers and customers.  I think that was one of the last nails in the coffin that put MTH off my list for anything.

 

As for undecorated that is possible if you reserve them.  However, there will be no decals.  The builder does not make decals for one loco or one road.  It's a mishmash to make best use of available decal paper. And it is apparently one of the the most expensive parts of any model.

 

I'm not sure how to be clearer, if you want SP Zebra stripes reserve them, if you want SP bloody nose reserve them.  If you want any road done any way reserve them and lobby like is being done for the demonstrators.  You will be encouraged to provide Scott details of what you are describing.  There is no best or appropriate, only what people reserve.  They are not made to spec, there is no make this and you'll sell a million of them, it is a case of money talks and BS walks.  You are encouraged to reserve 25 or more of something you think will sell a million of and then sell them yourself; on your dime.

Last edited by rdunniii

I'm debating which to order... the SD9 SP Black Widows or SD7 Tiger Stripes on a "hope" he gets enough reservations.

 

I can't seem to find aprox time frames (years) for the SD7 Tiger Stripe versus the SD9 Black Widow. They can't be that many years apart right? 

 

and of course mine would be 3R

Last edited by Former Member

"I can't seem to find aprox time frames (years) for the SD7 Tiger Stripe versus the SD9 Black Widow. They can't be that many years apart right?"

 

  The first SD-7 came to the SP in 1953, they had one tank( no water tank because there was no steam generator) and worked on the NWP. Late in the year more came with the water tank and generator. By 1954 they were ordering SD9's instead. Can't recall the exact  number but maybe 40 SD7's and 150 SD9's were ordered in a couple of years time span. Many of the SD9's were rebuilt and stuck around to the end or near the end of the SP, any painted  after 1959 were painted grey and red so the Black Widow scheme faded away over a period of years, I recall still seeing some in the late 60's but can't recall when the last one was repainted.....DaveB  

Originally Posted by rdunniii:

...

 

MTH told me they do not do 2-rail of anything in their so called "limited edition" stuff which was what they considered the TM demonstrators.  I Grrr'd a bit and they said such things were exclusive for their "classic O Gauge" dealers and customers.  I think that was one of the last nails in the coffin that put MTH off my list for anything.

 

...

 

That's specifically why I've passed on every special locomotive since 2009, even though I run on 3-rails for now. I'm leaning toward one CNW and one SP.

There were also a few SD7s that got re-painted from tiger stripes into Black Widow paint.  The "Espee...Into the 90s"  book by Don Strack(?)  had a full feature on these beasties with tons of pictures. Included was one of the ex-demo 990 in double winged BW paint, because she had dual controls !  Scott is going to have his hands full making all these variations, should the numbers tally up !  Here's to hoping that Scott will pull out all the stops and make this his defining Diesel moment!

"There were also a few SD7s that got re-painted from tiger stripes into Black Widow paint"

 

   and maybe the best of all was the kodachrome merger scheme. I've seen SD9's in it but can't recall if I ever saw an SD7 merger painted, in later years the SD9 and SD7 locos kinda blended together so I might not have noticed one. ....DaveB 

Last edited by daveb
Originally Posted by Mike CT:

If you check the Sunset Thirdrail order page for the SD 7/9 offering here are the current choices, AM January 22, 2015.

Click on Choose Road

SD7

Demo

BO

CBQ

CNW

Chessie

Milw

DRGW

GN

NW

PRR

SP

South

UP

 

SD9

BO

BLE

CS

CBQ

CNW

DMIR

DRGW

GN

PRR

NKP

NS

South

SP

Interesting.  A dollar says the following don't make the cut

 

CNW

Milw

NW

South

NS

CS

 

And probably

 

Chessie

BLE

DMIR

NKP

 

Anybody care to prove me wrong by getting enough reserved?

 

I agree Kodachrome SP would be nice but 2 Demos is all I can afford for 1 run.

 

OBTW, yes I'm stirring the pot

Add Reply

Post
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×
×